Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Jay Cleary, the best Real Estate Agent I have ever dealt with.
about 5 years ago
Jay Cleary, the best Real Estate Agent I have ever dealt with.

Jay Cleary's professionalism was nothing short of excellent. His knowledge of the market and understanding of what I required, guided me through one of the most horrific times in my life. I would recommend Jay at the drop of a hat.

Buyer review
Perfect customer experience.
about 5 years ago
Perfect customer experience.

The Service provided by Jay was incredible. After looking at other properties and dealing with a number of agents, Jay was a breath of fresh air. From the initial phone inquiry I found Jay to be courteous, professional, informative and his communication was spot on. Jay managed to make the whole purchase experience easy from start to finish. As the purchaser I feel Jay fought for the best result for his vendor whilst ensuring transparency and keeping us well informed throughout the process. I would not hesitate to recommend.

Seller review
very satisfied
about 5 years ago
very satisfied

Very professional and Jays communication was excellent achieved desired result highly recommend Jay

Buyer review
Highly recommend
about 5 years ago
Highly recommend

Jay help my wife and I buy our first home. You would be hard pressed to find a more professional real-estate in Bathurst. Jay was up front and honest with us from the get go. As a first home buyer Jay made the process as easy and painless as possible, he was aways easy to communicate with and fast with his replies. We never had to chase him for anything. I would highly recommend Jay to all of my friends and family in a heart beat, he went above and beyond to help us. Thank you Jay! We appreciate all the help you gave us. Regards Jesse and Angie

Seller review
Quick result exceeding expectations
about 5 years ago
Quick result exceeding expectations

Jay Cleary provided a personal experience, keeping us up to date on all matters as they progressed. The line of communication was excellent and prompt at all times. More importantly, Jay was able to get us a result within 24 hours that was well above our asking price. I would highly recommend Jay (and Sandy) and would have no hesitation is requesting their services again.

Seller review
Very up front what you see is what you get
about 5 years ago
Very up front what you see is what you get

We brought our first home of Jay over 10 years ago he is our go to agent for all property's we buy and sell. Best agent by a mile over the last 10 years we have brought and sold property through Jay and has always strived for the best outcome's for us as vendors and when buying he's honest approach is second to none. That's what sets apart Cleary & Fairbrother property agents from the rest. Great communication skills always answered our questions throughout the process

Buyer review
Excellent service
about 5 years ago
Excellent service

We purchased through Jay and found his level of service above and beyond our expectations. We would highly recommend him to anyone looking for great service and knowledge of the area.

Seller review
very profesional
about 5 years ago
very profesional

Great result achieved through constant communication very happy with service provided would happily recommend jay his knowledge and professionlism second to none

Seller review
We sold our Bathurst residential property through Jay.
about 5 years ago
We sold our Bathurst residential property through Jay.

Jays marketing knowledge was spot on. He always kept us informed and up to date on market changes. He was very professional but very approachable re any questions or queries we had. We would throughly recommend Jay to anyone who was considering selling or buying property.

Buyer review
Great experience
about 5 years ago
Great experience

We had bad experiences with other companies and Jay helped us out so much with showing us the house and going through the whole house with us and explaining the whole process! Best agent we have worked with since we started looking for a house! Thank you so much Jay you have made our experience amazing!

Seller review
Jay is one of the good guys
about 5 years ago
Jay is one of the good guys

Like his business partner Sandy Jay is a friendly, down to earth man. His warmth & honesty are apparent to all who meet him. From my interactions with Jay...I’ve found him to be polite, efficient & reliable. It’s always a pleasure to do business with authentic people like Jay & Sandy.

Seller review
Professional to the highest degree
about 5 years ago
Professional to the highest degree

Jay and Sandy have recently sold another property of ours and as always they have conducted themselves as nothing but professional. This sale became a little complicated due to circumstances out of both the purchasers and our control, and we feel Jay and Sandy both managed the situation perfectly, kept us 100% up to date and passed on all offers and options for us to forward and ensure there was nothing left on the table. We would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother Property Bathurst, and we will continue to use them in the future.

337 - 348 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent