Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 563 reviewsacross 25 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jay's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, supportive, reliable, responsive, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Above and Beyond!
over 5 years ago
Above and Beyond!

From the moment we rang to book an inspection we were hugely impressed by Jay and Sandy’s enthusiasm and ability to accomodate our busy work schedules. In comparison to other local agents Jay was keen to sell our home and we actually signed paperwork on New Years day! We have been kept updated through the whole process of both selling and buying a new home. Jay has made this a breeze and our home was under offer before it was even listed online. We are ecstatic with our sale price and hugely looking forward to moving into our new home. I would highly recommend Cleary and Fairbrother, particularly Jay, for his dedication to making our dream a reality.

Seller review
Working with Jay Cleary was a very positive experience from start to finish.
over 5 years ago
Working with Jay Cleary was a very positive experience from start to finish.

I was very impressed with Jay’s enthusiastic attitude, market knowledge and with how quickly the property was sold, bringing a higher price than I had initially expected.Jay’s communication throughout was the best that I have encountered, a real pleasure to work with.

Seller review
5 Star Service
over 5 years ago
5 Star Service

Jay & Sandy have been absolutely amazing through the whole process of selling our home. Their local knowledge of the market was invaluable, their open and honest approach to every aspect from start to finish of the sale and their genuine character was what made our decision to go with both of them easy. We can’t speak highly enough of the service they have provided and highly recommend them to anyone!

Buyer review
Honest awesome service!
over 5 years ago
Honest awesome service!

After dealing with other agents in town who were less than impressive, I found Jay to be totally honest, who is a man of his word, dedicated and a straight shooter. Old school values! Thank you Jay.

Seller review
Friendly and approachable
over 5 years ago
Friendly and approachable

Jay provided professional and timely advice throughout. He was punctual and friendly in all interactions and followed through at each stage of the process. He and Sandy worked well as a cohesive team.

Buyer review
Ultimate professionals delivering results
over 5 years ago
Ultimate professionals delivering results

Jay and Sandy provided us with a truly professional performance to achieve the outcome that at times proved challenging. We would highly recommend Cleary Fairbrother for any real estate dealings, the dedication to our sale by these two gentlemen would be best described as unwavering even during the normal " holiday " periods, both Jay and Sandy always provided us with their honest and to the point opinion in regards to pricing, marketing, and feedback from potential buyers. Thank You Jay and Sandy

Seller review
A transparent and pleasurable experience
over 5 years ago
A transparent and pleasurable experience

Jay made the experience of selling our house a simple one. His knowledge and expertise were invaluable during the process. We felt comfortable to ask any kind of question and they were always answering promptly and in full. I would happily recommend Cleary and Fairbrother to my friends and family

Buyer review
Fantastic, easy to deal with.
over 5 years ago
Fantastic, easy to deal with.

Jay was great to deal with and made the process of buying very simple with his quick communication, even after hours. Would recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Buyer review
Above and beyond all expectations.
over 5 years ago
Above and beyond all expectations.

After what can only be described as one of the most stressful few months trying to find the perfect house, Jay was able to turn it all around and find us the impossible. He listened to what we wanted and never made us feel uncomfortable if it wasn't what we were looking for. His knowledge, experience and professionalism were above incredible, and his willingness to go above and beyond for us will never be forgotten. We cannot recommend Jay enough to anyone looking to purchase their forever home.

Buyer review
Very happy customer
over 5 years ago
Very happy customer

Jay's friendly and professional help and care towards my purchasing 25 Macquarie Street was and is much appreciated.

Seller review
Great agent, don't go elsewhere
over 5 years ago
Great agent, don't go elsewhere

Jay was not my first choice in Bathurst as I was led down the garden path by whom I thought was the best local agent but after a disastrous experience, I decided to switch to Jay and he saved the day. Jay was consistently a pleasure to deal with, always updating as to what's going on with the property and working hard to achieve the desired result.

361 - 372 of 563
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent