Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  4.9  
Jay has 553 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Phenomenal experience from start to finish!
17 days ago
Phenomenal experience from start to finish!

We worked with Jay and Michelle Peters to both sell our house and purchase our new home, and we could not have been more impressed with them and their entire team—they were truly phenomenal! Navigating both sides of a move can be overwhelming, but their experience really shone through. They gave us such helpful, practical advice to get our property ready for the market, and their communication was clear, open, and consistent the whole way through. They simply could not have worked harder for us, and we were so happy with how everything went. We've already recommended them to multiple people and would gladly work with them again in a heartbeat. Thank you so much, Jay and Michelle!

Seller review
The dynamic duo in local real estate!
28 days ago
The dynamic duo in local real estate!

We couldn’t be happier with the service we received from Jay and Michelle Peters. From start to finish, this dynamic duo were professional, friendly, approachable and genuinely committed to helping us achieve the best possible outcome. They kept us informed throughout the entire process, were always available to answer our questions, and went above and beyond to make everything as smooth as possible. Their knowledge, communication and attention to detail were exceptional. Most importantly, Jay and Michelle made us feel that we were in safe hands. They worked tirelessly to turn a potentially stressful experience in one of happiness and positivity. We truly appreciated their honesty, patience and dedication, and would have no hesitation in recommending them to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Thank you, Jay and Michelle, we are incredibly grateful to you both, for everything.

Seller review
Great Service from Jay and Michelle Peters
about 1 month ago
Great Service from Jay and Michelle Peters

Jay and Michelle Peters were very knowledgeable and professional when selling our home in Newport. We were very happy with their service. Always punctual and kept us informed through the whole process! We would recommend them to anyone wanting to buy or sell in the area.

Seller review
Excellent agent
about 2 months ago
Excellent agent

Absolutely would highly recommend Jay and Michelle. Communication excellent, one of the most stress free experience we have had in selling a house. Jay and Michelle went above and beyond making sure the sale went as smoothly as possible. Nothing was too much. Always contactable and very professional.

Buyer review
Understanding our requirements.
about 2 months ago
Understanding our requirements.

Jay & Michelle were both on point with their communication of the current Property Market, their understanding of our specific requirements needed and their diligent responses to our queries were on the mark. This entire process has been as efficient as possible, and we could not be happier with our purchase and the association with Jay & Michelle.

Seller review
Property sale in a challenging market
about 2 months ago
Property sale in a challenging market

I am happy to say the Jay and Michelle achieved an excellent outcome for the sale of my property in Scarborough in a challenging market due to the new legislation. I know that the negotiations were challenging and with few buyers in the market a fair and equitable outcome for all parties involved was achieved. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend their services to anyone who has property to sell. Thank you both for your expertise and effort.

Seller review
Sale of Duplex in Scarborough QLD
3 months ago
Sale of Duplex in Scarborough QLD

We had a fantastic experience working with Jay Peters to sell out investment property. Jay was professional, highly communicative, and dedicated to getting us the best possible result. We live in another state and we were travelling overseas during the sale. He kept us informed every step of the way, making the process feel smooth and straightforward. We highly recommend Jay!

Buyer review
Made buying a property sight unseen an easy experience
3 months ago
Made buying a property sight unseen an easy experience

Purchasing an investment property is a big decision, and in our case even more so as my sister, wife and I bought the property sight unseen. We had a friend inspect it on our behalf, so we relied heavily on Jay's honesty and communication throughout the process. From our first phone conversation, Jay was responsive, professional and always available when we had questions. We needed to extend our finance approval twice, and he handled both requests without any issues, making what could have been a stressful process feel straightforward. What really stood out was that Jay was genuine and upfront. He was frank about the property and never tried to oversell it. That honesty gave us the confidence to move forward with the purchase. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Jay to anyone looking to buy or sell property. His professionalism, communication and integrity made the entire experience an easy one.

Seller review
Easy to talk to and very approachable.
3 months ago
Easy to talk to and very approachable.

Jay and Michelle are everything you’d want in a realestate agent. Obviously extremely knowledgeable in what’s happening locally. We were very lucky that they had someone on their books that they believed would be interested in our property. This proved to be the case, as we didn’t even go to market. Would certainly recommend them to anyone in the area looking to sell.

1 - 12 of 553
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent