Michelle Cottington

Michelle Cottington

Principal of Michelle Cottington Property / Licensed Real Estate Agent at Powered by Smile Elite NSW
  •   4.9   (201 reviews)

Michelle's sales performance at a glance

See how Michelle has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

28
Reviews
92
Median days on market
19
Properties for sale
22
Sold properties
$862k
Average sale price
$19m
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) as lead and supporting agent and published on ratemyagent.com.au. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

  • priceExpertbadge

    Consistently meets client expectations for property purchase price.

  • aotybadge

    Recognised for going above & beyond for their clients.

Michelle's customer service awards

See what RateMyAgent awards Michelle has won

  • Suburb WinnerMoruya
  • 3x Suburb WinnerMoruya - 2026, 2024, 2023

About Michelle

2023 & 2024 Rate My Agent, Agent of the Year - Moruya 2024 Agency of the Year - Moruya As a native of Eurobodalla Shire, Michelle of Michelle Cottington Property is an award- winning agent with an exceptional local knowledge of Batemans Bay and surrounding regions and, as a leading authority in the area, Michelle has established a reputation for exceeding expectations, with a proven track record of success. Balancing an innate ambition to succeed, with an empathetic, down to earth approach, Michelle offers first class customer service and is a motivated achiever who works tirelessly 24/7 to deliver on her promise of securing the best possible result for her clients. ‘Michelle worked with us every step of the way to get us the result we wanted. She is professional, well informed and passionate about today’s market.’ Clinton and Michelle – Rate My Agent Verified Vendor Review Michelle takes the time to listen and understand her clients’ needs, and with reliability and integrity, she goes above and beyond to help them reach their goals. A highly skilled communicator and master negotiator, Michelle builds rapport easily, consistently delivering next level results that exceed expectations; this being reflected in her impressive level of repeat business and referrals from clients praising her ability. ‘Michelle has been a wonderful negotiator between the vendor and buyer in our experience. She is a stellar communicator.’ Susann – Rate My Agent Verified Buyer Review Being a local, Michelle is strongly committed to her community, and is a member of the Broulee Surf Club. When not attending to clients, Michelle loves sports, including surf boat rowing and touch football and values spending quality time with family and friends. With her six-star service, Michelle is committed to ensuring she is showcasing your property to the largest possible audience, with the resources of the entire Smile Elite and Sydney Country Living Group instantly available, creating a competitive edge to deliver the highest possible price.

Michelle's reviews

  4.9  
Michelle has 201 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 6.
Review Michelle
Michelle's qualities as told by our client reviews: dedicated, pleasant, honest, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
An efficient and helpful realtor.
11 days ago
An efficient and helpful realtor.

We happened to see this property for sale while exploring the area. Michelle promptly answered our call and made it easy for us to inspect the property in our constrained timeframe. We found Michelle to be professional and approachable and happy to talk to us outside of usual business hours, which was helpful as one of us was overseas at the time. She has a calm and considered manner, valuable property sales experience and expert local market knowledge. We have no hesitation in recommending Michelle Cottington Realtor and will definitely consider using her services when we sell or purchase in the future.

Seller review
Understood the value of our property and ran a effective and professional campaign
12 days ago
Understood the value of our property and ran a effective and professional campaign

We had a great experience working with Michelle Cottington on the sale of our property. She was professional, communicative, and genuinely listened to our needs throughout the process. Michelle handled every challenge calmly and efficiently, keeping us informed and making the experience feel smooth and stress-free. We appreciated her dedication and support, and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a trustworthy real estate professional.

Seller review
Michelle is amazing
13 days ago
Michelle is amazing

Michelle is honestly the best real estate agent I have ever worked with, and I cannot recommend her enough. My property was on the market for over a year with another agency, and within just one month of working with Michelle, it was sold. That alone says so much about her knowledge, work ethic, communication, and dedication. From the very beginning, Michelle was kind, caring, honest, and incredibly supportive. She kept me updated every step of the way, always answered my questions, and made me feel like I was genuinely looked after throughout the whole process. Selling a property can be stressful and emotional, but Michelle made it feel manageable and positive. What really stood out to me was how hard she worked behind the scenes. She didn’t just “list” the property — she truly marketed it, followed up with buyers, communicated consistently, and went above and beyond to get the best outcome possible. You can tell she genuinely cares about her clients and takes pride in what she does. Michelle is professional, knowledgeable, approachable, and incredibly good at what she does. She has amazing people skills and a calm, reassuring way about her that makes you instantly trust her. I never felt like “just another client.” If you are looking for an agent who is hardworking, honest, compassionate, and truly invested in helping you achieve the best result, Michelle is the person you want by your side. Thank you again, Michelle, for everything you did for me. You are absolutely amazing.

Seller review
Excellent in all areas!
2 months ago
Excellent in all areas!

Michelle is an agent I would highly recommend! She is very professional in all areas, gives honest feedback and is also very quick to respond when needed. The last property we sold was in QLD, and she was very helpful when we had questions regarding how things are done in NSW. She went above and beyond when securing our sale and we wouldn’t hesitate to work with her again. Highly recommend Michelle Cottington Property.

Buyer review
 Michelle is very professional, helpful and friendly.
3 months ago
Michelle is very professional, helpful and friendly.

Michelle provided a professional and friendly service in my search and purchase of my new home. She made negotiations with the seller an easy experience, satisfied my questions on the process and was extremely pleasant to deal with. She has a good knowledge of the area. I highly recommend her when purchasing a property.

Seller review
Michelle is reliable, honest and has a great sense of humour
3 months ago
Michelle is reliable, honest and has a great sense of humour

Michelle is a true local, and has a vast knowledge of the area. She is always professional, and always has a smile and up for a laugh. She always returns our phone calls and arrives on time, if not early for appointments, just to check in. Michelle sold our house in under 1 week!! Thank you Michelle

Show all 201 reviews
map

Michelle's properties

Michelle has 19 properties for sale and sold 22 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$850,000 - $900,000
14 Hawdon St
Moruya NSW 2537
4
2
3
House
SoldMay 27, 2026
$750,000
34 Heron Road
Catalina NSW 2536
3
2
1
House
For Sale
$735,000
53 Bergalia Street
Moruya NSW 2537
3
1
2
House
SoldMay 20, 2026
Show all 41 properties

Michelle's sold properties

Michelle has sold 22 properties in the past 12 months, showing 4.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
34 Heron Road, Catalina, NSW, 2536
34 Heron Road
Catalina NSW 2536
3
2
1
House$750,000May 27, 2026
2 Janari Close, Moruya, NSW, 2537
2 Janari Close
Moruya NSW 2537
Land$380,000May 20, 2026
16 Panorama Parade, Moruya, NSW, 2537
16 Panorama Parade
Moruya NSW 2537
3
1
1
House$740,000Apr 23, 2026
15 Coronation Drive, Moruya Heads, NSW, 2537
15 Coronation Drive
Moruya Heads NSW 2537
3
2
House$980,000Apr 7, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent