Paul's profile

Paul's reviews

  4.9  
Paul has 313 reviewsacross 17 different locations, showing 12.
over 7 years ago
Good honest agent

Paul and the Buxton team provided a realistic and honest assessment and provided great attention, feedback and a good result in a currently difficult sales environment. Well done.

over 7 years ago
very easy to deal with

We were faced with selling an elderly parent's property to finance admission to a nursing home. From the very beginning Paul was easy to talk with, honest and genuine. We discussed the prospect of selling the property in its current state; or spending a little bit to give it a fresh look, which is the option we choose. Paul stayed in contact with us to monitor the reno progress, and we were able to place the property on the market quickly once completed. Once listed the feedback from Paul & Natalie was excellent following each open date so we were able to gauge the level of interest of buyers. In the end we accepted an offer prior to auction, in which Paul was able to offer guidance on current market activity in a falling price period, and all with the added bonus of a very short settlement which worked extremely well in our favour.

over 7 years ago
Great Auctioneer

It was our first time buying at auction and we were quite nervous. Paul acknowledged us before the auction began to offer any assistance and was friendly and funny throughout, taking the fear away from the process. We understandably expect an auctioneer and agent to have the vendor's best interest in mind but I do believe Paul genuinely helped us too. Paul is nice and friendly which put us at ease and he lives in the same suburb so was a good reference for the area. A great buying experience overall.

over 7 years ago
Honest, Enthusiastic and Methodical

During the buying process of our last house six years ago we met Paul and he really stood out amongst other agents for his genuine and knowledgeable approach. As buyers we found him to be very attentive and honest, so when it came time to sell he was on the list of agents we talked to. Paul’s local knowledge and his passion for the area is clear from the outset and it was this enthusiasm that won us over. Together with Natalie Alesi, they both worked rigorously throughout the campaign, keeping us well informed with comprehensive and methodical reports. They were always friendly, professional and very supportive during the process and delivered the results despite the market being very difficult. Paul’s authentic and engaging manner and his skill with negotiating make him an excellent auctioneer. We highly recommend Paul and Natalie for their meticulous attention to detail and their warm and enthusiastic approach.

over 7 years ago
Fabulous team

We sold our property in Highett with Paul and Natalie in a tough market but they found a buyer and got us a great result!!

over 7 years ago
Stress free

Passed in, Paul helped us reach an agreement with the seller in a stress free and low pressure way. We were wrapped with the outcome!

over 7 years ago
Professional and Prompt

Paul Sibley and his team helped make buying the house very easy. They were always quick and responsive to our queries and resolved any issues in a timely manner. I am happy with their service and would recommend them.

over 7 years ago
Exceeded our expectations

We cannot recommend Paul highly enough. We received such a professional and personal level of service throughout the entire progress and we were just so impressed. We were very emotionally attached to this house having brought home 2 of our babies here and he made us feel like our home was in great hands. I would be more than happy to act as a referee should anyone have any questions.

over 7 years ago
A very good real estate agent

We can highly recommend Paul Sibley as a real estate agent. His professionalism, honesty and down to earth approach make him one of the best agents that we have come across.

over 7 years ago
He gets results!

Paul was our first choice as agent as we had seen him in action as an auctioneer when the market was 'hotter' in and around Highett, and he demonstrated all the skills you would want in an auctioneer. I had also met him at several opens, and he was always professional and personable. As our agent he kept us in the loop at all times, and displayed integrity and tenacity. I believe he is an honest agent who is keen to do his best in all circumstances. I would not hesitate to recommend him to others and would use him again to sell a property in the future.

over 7 years ago
Excellent agent

Paul has been a great agent throughout our purchasing process. He was responsive, without being pushy, and got a excellent outcome for us as buyers. Great work Paul!

over 7 years ago
Great Service, Honest, Open & Gets Results

We recently sold our investment property in Moorabbin with Paul and can honestly say that we couldn’t have been happier with the service and the result. The truly great agents still achieve great results even in a down market, and Paul is certainly one of those. He is likeable, honest and hardworking with a great knowledge of his local area, which drives his teams results. However, Paul would openly acknowledge that it is a team effort and Natalie Alesi also needs a mention as she is equally adept, is highly organised and a great communicator. Together they make a fantastic team and we would recommend their services to any prospective Vendor within the Buxton Hampton East area.

193 - 204 of 313
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent