Peggy McAlister

Peggy McAlister

Licensed Real Estate Agent / Auctioneer / Sales Executive at My Agent Team
  •   4.8   (168 reviews)

About Peggy

Peggy McAlister burst on to the real estate scene in 2008 and quickly become recognised as a top performer locally and nationally. Her success was born from an unwavering desire to achieve the best results for her clients and a focused work ethic. Peggy has a magnetism. A confidence in her ability that creates instant trust. Combine her tenacity with a competent eye for detail, her marketing standards, systems and procedures are hard to replicate. During an illustrious career of winning multiple awards, being recognised in the top 1.5% of Australian agents; the desire to be part of something bigger was paramount. The culture of the full female company and surrounding herself with likeminded women was the drawcard for Peggys next chapter. To work with women of equal success and similar professionalism was the keystone for elevating her career. Peggy and I were ships passing in the night, timelines never corresponding and have been competing for 15 years. “To think that such great competitors could come together and create something magical is about timing. It was never about if, it was about when …… "

Peggy's reviews

  4.8  
Peggy has 168 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 6.
Review Peggy
almost 2 years ago
Amazing Agent

Thankyou to Peggy McAllister for the amazing campaign she presented for our home. Peggy's open communication was a key factor in making the sale of our home a comfortable experience. The amazing result was achieved through her dedication and professionalism. Thanks Peggy for all you have done and continue to do. Tony & Jody Pan

over 2 years ago
If you want sell your home, contact Professional Peggy McAlister and Sam My Agent Team Batemans Bay.

I had the pleasure of meeting Peggy when we purchased this home 4 years ago. If you indeed want to sell your home, call on Peggy. She is prompt,knowledgeable, and gets the job done so professionally. I cannot even compare her to the Agent we presently are going through after purchasing our new home in Albion Park. Peggy and the Agency My Agent team at Batemans Bay are fantastic. We advised Peggy we only wanted to be online no longer than 8 weeks, our home sold in 53 days. I have much respect for our Agent, Peggy McAlister and those whom she works with, are very impressive. Peggy respects the home owner selling, never overpowering in any way at all, the top business woman that I believe she is, gets the job done. If you present a lovely home, this powerful lady will sell it for you, she is a team player, keeping you updated with stats, follow ups from buyers who were interested in inspecting your home / and overall, this is all said with such respect for Peggy McAlister. You go Girl, you deserve every word that we wrote here in this honest review about your dedication in the Real Estate World. Thank you Peggy, we will always remember you, you knew we were sad to sell our home. Life happens, and sometimes one has to change paths... and we have found another beautiful home. Thank you for your dedication to selling our home in Surfside. You know I always had the confidence in you, you gave us the lowest appraisal as you knew the market well you were still the chosen one to sell our home. Thank you so very much Peggy McAlister and Sam for being so prompt in every way, it also was very much appreciated. What a great team you both make!.

almost 4 years ago
We would highly recommend her...

We had every confidence in Peggy. She was very professional. She knew the market and we were very impressed with her efficiency. Peggy was delightful to work with. We would highly recommend her.

about 4 years ago
Fantastic market knowledge

Fantastic market knowledge and competitive information about listings near by. Excellent communication and personal service tailored to our scenario and sales situation. Thankyou Peg! We really appreciate you working so hard to get us the best result, in this sale as well as past and possible future sales.

about 4 years ago
I would highly recommend Peggy and her team

We were extremely happy with the professionalism of Peggy and her team. It was obvious from the very beginning that she was on top of the market and its trajectory. She was thorough in all aspects during the sale of our beloved property and her communication with us was outstanding. She was able to gauge the very unique nuances that are required in this industry to get the best results for both parties involved. I would highly recommend Peggy and her team.

Show all 168 reviews

Peggy's properties

Peggy has 14 properties for sale and sold 37 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$869,000
34 Maunsell St
Moruya NSW 2537
3
1
5
House
SoldMay 10, 2026
$750,000
10 Boondi Street
Malua Bay NSW 2536
3
2
2
House
SoldMay 7, 2026
$810,000
8 Elouera Close
Lilli Pilli NSW 2536
3
2
2
House
SoldMay 4, 2026
$410,000
4/16 McMillan Rd
Narooma NSW 2546
2
1
1
Unit
Show all 51 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent