Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 131 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Exceptional job
over 7 years ago
Exceptional job

We recently appointed Peter Hickey to look after the sale of our Parkdale property and so glad we did. We appreciated and valued Peter's input into maximising the buyer interest in our property. We were always kept up to date throughout the process. What made Peter exceptional was his honest appraisal on all matters ranging from genuine buyer interest, current market conditions and focusing on the best outcome for the vendor. We would highly recommend Peter Hickey for any real estate requirement and would have no hesitation in appointing again in the future.

Seller review
Fantastic Service
over 7 years ago
Fantastic Service

Peter provides a fantastic service. He has great knowledge of the area, knows the potential buyers and their circumstances, consistently communicates updates and works hard to obtain a result.

Seller review
Happy Customers
over 7 years ago
Happy Customers

Peter Hickey recently helped sell our Sandringham property and we were very satisfied in all he did in helping us achieve our goal. Peter was willing to push hard for a higher price and assisted us in many ways to get this price.

Seller review
Buxton Sandringham - Peter Hickey
over 7 years ago
Buxton Sandringham - Peter Hickey

Peter is the agent to trust when it comes to selling in Bayside. A respected and knowledgeable agent who's knowledge of Sandringham and surrounding areas is second to none. Peter is honest and very current when it comes to local property sales, which provides you with accurate information to help you make the right decision. Peter has excellent communication details, who calls you constantly to update you on the viewings, who he has spoken too and what parties he has interested in your property. A no nonsense agent who tells you the truth, is realistic and will jump through whoops to help you. I would highly recommend Peter to anyone that is looking to acquire or sell in Bayside.

Seller review
Very Happy with Peter
over 7 years ago
Very Happy with Peter

His knowledge of Sandringham, attention to detail and follow up were second to none. Coming off a very high market he was cautious and did not give us false expectations. Peter kept in continuous contact with us throughout and in the end he negotiated a satisfactory outcome in what became a very tough market. I would highly recommend Peter to anyone thinking of selling in the Bayside area.

Seller review
Great Agent
almost 8 years ago
Great Agent

Sincere thanks Peter for you honesty and openness when we sold our property in Sandringham. Your insight into the market at the time, was accurate and right on the mark which enabled us to set realistic goals and to achieve a result that we were happy with. Thank you also Peter for guiding us through the process of preparing our property. You provided us with excellent advice when we were preparing the property in regards to prioritising the maintenance that was required and with organising SoHo to stage our property.

Seller review
A true professional.
almost 8 years ago
A true professional.

I first came to know Peter Hickey when I negotiated to buy 29 Tennyson St in 2015. He exudes trust and integrity. I had no hesitation in asking Peter Hickey to sell the same property three years later. His preparation of the advertising and face to face promoting of my home at OFI’s exceeded my hopes. On the auction day, the two main prospects failed to attend. I was fearful that the auction would prove to be a disaster. Peter’s auction spiel was excellent and his recommended strategy was perfect. He transformed a fizzer into a miracle! I was very impressed with how Peter Hickey transformed a few reluctant prospects into potential buyers, and got one prospect over the line.

Buyer review
Great agent
almost 8 years ago
Great agent

I has a very remarkable purchase experience with Peter. He has extraordinary communication skills in selling.

Seller review
Peter is a terrific agent
almost 8 years ago
Peter is a terrific agent

Peter is very professional, organised and knowledgable. He was a pleasure to work with through out the campaign. He tried extremely hard to achieve the result we were after. We would thoroughly recommend Peter as your agent.

Seller review
Professional from start to finish
about 8 years ago
Professional from start to finish

Peter and his team provided an exceptionally professional service throughout the whole of the sale of our property. He showed great attention to detail to all aspects of the campaign, including individual follow up with all prospective purchasers and regular feedback regarding interest in the property. The results exceeded our expectations and we would not hesitate to recommend him to other people intending to sell.

Buyer review
Professional and thorough
about 8 years ago
Professional and thorough

In our dealings with Peter as a vendor and a purchaser he has demonstrated professionalism and a great attention to detail. He is highly recommended.

61 - 72 of 131
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent