Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 131 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Impressive agent
about 8 years ago
Impressive agent

Peter was very professional from the start of the sale of my parents home. He kept us informed of what was happening throughout all stages of the sale of the property. We were very impressed with his skills as an auctioneer. I would have no hesitation in using Peter again.

Buyer review
Genuine and talented at what he does
about 8 years ago
Genuine and talented at what he does

Peter is extremely genuine, which is extremely rare to find in this industry. We had viewed a few properties that was within Peter's scope and whilst he was clearly working for the vendor, he also had our best interest at heart as the buyer. He knows the market and is realistic in all of his advice. Thanks for your support Peter!!! So glad we met you and so glad we purchased our dream home with you!

Seller review
Brilliant agent
about 8 years ago
Brilliant agent

Pete, Thanks so much for your work on our Townhouse. Your attention to detail and communication was first class. For the second time in the past few years who achieved a perfect result. I look forward to working with you on our project. well done. Paul and Karen

Seller review
A great and knowledgeable agent.
about 8 years ago
A great and knowledgeable agent.

Peter is the agent that dealed with me during the sale of my property and I found him to be very knowledgeable and reliable. His dedication to achieve a great result was very apparent during the whole process. Peter also communicated well with me throughout the sale and made great effort in explaining the process at all times. I find Peter to be a very professional individual that goes out of his way to achieving the best possible outcome for his clients and I have no hesitation in strongly recommending him to any interested party.

Seller review
Job well done
about 8 years ago
Job well done

Peter did a great job selling our house. He knows the local market very well and worked hard to great the deal done. He kept us up to date on potential buyers and was always available for a discussion. He gave us tips on preparing the house and was present at the photo shoot. Job well done. Davis

Seller review
Very Professional
about 8 years ago
Very Professional

We are very pleased that we went with Peter Hickey of Buxtons to sell our home. From the very outset he was attentive to detail and completely professional. He organised a comprehensive, high standard marketing campaign with wide exposure. He communicated well throughout the process with regular reports and updates. But the best thing- he received an exceptional result at auction. He and his team fulfilled all our expectations and we highly recommend him. Thankyou Peter. Richard and Laurel Warhurst

Seller review
Your next Real Estate Agent
about 8 years ago
Your next Real Estate Agent

Many thanks to Peter for selling our house and making it hassle free for us. We had a difficult situation with a family member and access to part of the house was impossible. Peter handled this situation with a great deal of skill and empathy and was still able to sell our house in a week of it being put on the market. Peter is a nice person, easy to work with, punctual, informative and always keeping us informed. We can thoroughly recommend Peter as your next Real Estate Agent.

Seller review
We needed the top man ...
about 8 years ago
We needed the top man ...

And in Peter Hickey, we got him. Readily recommend him for his personability and professionalism. Even people who attended his opens and auction commented immediately on his overt quality of professionalism. For several years while waiting for my stubbon nongenerian father to let go of his independence and his wonderful Beach Road unit - which we knew would happen as a result of a crisis - Peter Hickey guided him and us kids through what we would need to do. It happened but because Peter had us well prepared we effortlessly entered a smooth sales campaign, auction and one hit, sold-on-the-day and for the quoted price auction. We're fans! Thanks Pete!

Seller review
Sale of property 43/15-19 Graham Road Highett 3190
over 8 years ago
Sale of property 43/15-19 Graham Road Highett 3190

Jenny and I have nothing but thanks and appreciation, for the process and results you achieved on the sale of my Mothers' unit in Highett. You made us feel more confident than we were, and your communication and advice from the start to the finish of the campaign was excellent. We really appreciate everything you did for us Peter. We will definitely pass on to friends and everyone your expertise and knowledge of the Real Estate Business etc. Thanks again Peter.....Cheers Tony & Jenny Quinn.

Seller review
Peter Hickey from Buxton's highly Recommended Real Estate Agent and Auctioneer
over 8 years ago
Peter Hickey from Buxton's highly Recommended Real Estate Agent and Auctioneer

Peter was totally attentive to our needs from day one through to the actual sale of our property on Auction day. Peter attended each OFI. Peter knows his market well and the area. Peter led his team very well. He's the Captain, but was very inclusive. A real team approach/effort. Peter is genuine and honest. So refreshing. I highly rate Peter and yes will recommend him to others.

Seller review
Best Agent in Bayside for sure!
over 8 years ago
Best Agent in Bayside for sure!

This is now the third property transaction that Peter has managed so diligently for us. His attention to detail is impeccable. He understands the market so well, gives you upfront and honest advice from the get go and his advice rarely misses the mark on reality. His constant, candid and to the point communication is a great strength of his. At no stage does he try to convince you to lower your expectations but instead just works harder to meet them. Including obtaining the last $500 out of a buyer on a $2M+ purchase. Need a hand organising the preparation of your property to go to market...Peter will help with that too. He has an armoury of top quality, respectful and well priced tradies at his disposal to get any job done in quick time and at the right price. All in all, Peter is an extremely hard working, down to earth, diligent and loyal agent who I highly recommend to anyone selling a property in Bayside.

Buyer review
Professional and reliable agent
over 8 years ago
Professional and reliable agent

I have now purchased two properties through Peter Hickey. He has provided me with good, reliable advice, realistic to my needs. Peter has been readily available and followed through on inquiries. He has kept in touch after sales have been completed. I am happy to recommend his services:

73 - 84 of 131
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent