Shellie's profile

Shellie's reviews

  4.9  
Shellie has 468 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shellie's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, honest, friendly, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Simply the best!
over 6 years ago
Simply the best!

Shellie is simply the best agent on the Tablelands. She was accurate in her assessment of the market and the market price. She really tried to match buyers to the properties and earned their trust. Always prompt and thorough with her communications. AND she made the sale at a fair price :-)

Seller review
Highest Recommendation
over 6 years ago
Highest Recommendation

Shellie Nightingale has been the most wonderful agent on our behalf. She is knowledgable and confident in all areas of the legal aspects of contracts and really has her finger on the pulse with regard to the market. She was, at all times, pleasant and personable in her dealings with us and with clients she brought here, respectful of our privacy and empathetic with our concerns. She kept in touch with us at all times, apprising us of any matters that might pertain to our situation. She was always very generous with her time, both when in conversation with us and also when it came time for inspections. Her knowledge of the Tablelands is unbeatable. We can not recommend Shellie and Elders' Real Estate Malanda highly enough.

Buyer review
Patient, understanding, profressional and made things happen things got tough
over 6 years ago
Patient, understanding, profressional and made things happen things got tough

As first home buyers, we had very little experience with buying a home, Shellie was introduced to us by a friend and immediately we were able to talk to her openly about our ideas and what we wanted. After acceptance of our offer, Shellie worked hard to make sure all the bumps in the road were dealt with and on one particular occasion, acted swiftly in a time dependent situation to ensure the process ended the way we all wanted it to. I look forward to working with her and Elders again in the future.

Seller review
Excellent agent highly recommend
over 6 years ago
Excellent agent highly recommend

When Shellie accepts a challenge there is no stopping her. It was her determination that sold our home to great buyers. We are very impressed with her professionalism and her service we highly recommend Shellie at Elders Real Estate in malanda. Thankyou very much Frank and Errolle Carr

Buyer review
Review of my agent Shellie Nightingale of Elders Malanda
over 6 years ago
Review of my agent Shellie Nightingale of Elders Malanda

Shellie has been a delight to work with throughout the entire process. From our first meeting the obvious was evident of her local knowledge and customer service provided. Extremely confident salesperson who I would recommend to any prospective purchaser.

Buyer review
Professional, knowledgeable, helpful without pressure
over 6 years ago
Professional, knowledgeable, helpful without pressure

During the purchasing process Shellie's demeanor was low profile, but effective. Due to her communication skills between seller and buyer the sale could actually happen.

Seller review
Excellent service and management of my sale.
almost 7 years ago
Excellent service and management of my sale.

Shellie worked very hard at every step of the sale process. She kept the communication level high, is professional, applied a smart and persistent approach and responded quickly to new developments. Shellie was realistic with opportunities. Shellie made the sale happen. I would highly recommend Shellie as the agent to sell your home.

Buyer review
Shellie sold us the property
almost 7 years ago
Shellie sold us the property

How good is she ???? So easy and efficient to work with. Highly recommend

Seller review
First class
almost 7 years ago
First class

Shellie is absolutely the best agent any one could have Thank You

Seller review
Sale of small acreage with house.
almost 7 years ago
Sale of small acreage with house.

Thanks to Shellie guiding me through the sale of my parents home in a very slow market. I was kept informed all the way through the months leading up to and during the sale. Shellie called me many times including when she had interested parties. Great happy and very helpful service.

Buyer review
Most professional agent on the tablelands
almost 7 years ago
Most professional agent on the tablelands

Shellie was amazing to deal with in every way. As a buyer we felt 100% informed, comfortable and happy throughout the entire process which was great because we had such poor service from other agents. Whether you are selling or buying I would highly reccomend talking to Shellie. The Elders team also handled our insurances too and they were far cheaper than our broker. Thanks again to Shellie, we have found our agent on the tablelands.

409 - 420 of 468
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent