Shellie's profile

Shellie's reviews

  4.9  
Shellie has 461 reviewsacross 26 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Shellie's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, honest, friendly, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
An agent who does it for love, not money.
almost 7 years ago
An agent who does it for love, not money.

Shellie listened to what we wanted, put forward some excellent options for us, and made the entire process easy. We never felt under any pressure, got some great advice on particular houses and the Tablelands market in general, and Shellie spent more time with us than we would normally expect from an agent. Shellie arranged multiple conjunction visits with other agents and never tried to steer us towards Sole Listed properties. We would absolutely recommend Shellie to any prospective buyer or seller in the Tablelands marketplace.

Seller review
A+ for service and professionalism
almost 7 years ago
A+ for service and professionalism

Shellie and the team at Elders were outstanding in selling our property. Pleasure to deal with and so professional. Thank you so much.

Buyer review
Friendly,honest and knowledgeable
almost 7 years ago
Friendly,honest and knowledgeable

Shellie was a very honest, down to earth person. Her knowledge of the homes and surrounding areas was excellent. There was no pushiness or arrogance to see anything that wasn’t suitable. Shellie was very friendly and had only our interests in mind. We enjoyed thoroughly working with her.

Seller review
Exceptional
almost 7 years ago
Exceptional

Thank you so much for all your fantastic work with this Shelley! I am delighted with the outcome - the way the sale was conducted which explored all options thoroughly and allowed all interested parties a chance to purchase, amount received for block, short period of time that block was sold in and am delighted with who purchased it. I am feeling extremely pleased with everything. Thank you so much for making this possible. All the best Brigitte Daley

Seller review
Outstanding service
about 7 years ago
Outstanding service

Right from the start of selling our house Shellie was professional, easy to get along with (always with a smile) and enthusiastic about our property. The offers started rolling in but none of them were suitable to us. Shellie never pressured us to take any of them and our patience paid off in the end. Shellie found the perfect buyer for our beautiful house and we could not be happier with the outcome. We would highly recommend Shellie to list your property.

Buyer review
What's not to like?
about 7 years ago
What's not to like?

The title says is all, really - Shellie is a wonderful person: extremely knowledgeable, enthusiastic, patient and very, very helpful in all ways. Nothing was ever too much trouble and she always made time to look after any details or issues immediately. Great person and great agent.

Seller review
Sale of two properties
about 7 years ago
Sale of two properties

Shellie Nightingale handled the sale of two properties for myself in a particularly difficult market. She always communicated with me providing updates after inspections and during the sale process. I was very happy with her performance.

Seller review
Very Professional & Personable Agent
about 7 years ago
Very Professional & Personable Agent

Shellie, Thanks for all your help – it was certainly a pleasure working with you – very professional and personable. You told us at the start what you could sell the property for and the features that would appeal to the right buyer. You then went and delivered on what you said in a very timely manner while keeping us informed at all times – could not ask for more. Regards Carol and Bruce

Seller review
Shellie is a total Professional!
about 7 years ago
Shellie is a total Professional!

It has been an absolute pleasure working with Shellie and the team at Elders to sell our property. Shellie has great local knowledge of the area, has great connections in the industry and is totally switched on when it comes to Real Estate. Above all that though is her continuous hard work ethic and her ability to communicate at all times so you feel like you are always in control of your property and its sale. I would recommend Shellie and Elders to anyone wanting sell or buy property.

421 - 432 of 461
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent