Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
255 reviewsacross 29 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
First rate knowledge and service
almost 5 years ago
First rate knowledge and service

Carl is meticulous in his research and advice. He goes above and beyond to ensure that all bases are covered and that the property has the best chance of sale. His communication with me as the seller was timely, professional, and informative. I will definitely engage Carl and his team in the future.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Calio and Scott Real Estate Agency
almost 5 years ago
Calio and Scott Real Estate Agency

Cannot speak highly enough about our experience with Carl Calio. Carl was sole agent for the sale of our family home in Brighton. Carls home grown down to earth professionalism made this very emotional sale feel more comfortable. We were kept fully informed of any interest and viewings with daily feedback. A family owned and run local business with immense local knowledge and history of the area and surrounds after having lived and raised his family here. I would defiantly recommend Carl Calio and his Business to sell your property.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Couldn’t have asked for a better agent
almost 5 years ago
Couldn’t have asked for a better agent

Carl had extensive knowledge of Brighton and it was clear from the very beginning that he had a passion for the area. He was professional at all times and helped guide us through the whole process with ease, which was great as first time buyers. Above all, he was genuine, friendly and kind - we couldn’t have asked for a better agent.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
House sale Brighton
about 5 years ago
House sale Brighton

Carl was an absolute professional in the sale of our house in Brighton Very courteous and approachable, quick to respond to any issues and always available Would highly recommend to anyone interested in buying or selling in the area

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
You won't find a better Agent!
about 5 years ago
You won't find a better Agent!

Carl is honest, genuine , a Gentleman and an absolute pleasure to deal with. His expertise is second to none and I would highly recommend him and his hand picked team.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent experience
about 5 years ago
Excellent experience

Carl is professional, very polite and always available for clients. He guided us in the process very professionally. I believe he should teach or give some lessons to new real estate agents. So they can learn how to deal with their clients.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Easy to deal with and very professional.
about 5 years ago
Easy to deal with and very professional.

Carl’s market knowledge was excellent his estimate of sale price was spot on

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
For me dealing with Carl was very reassuring and comfortable.
about 5 years ago
For me dealing with Carl was very reassuring and comfortable.

We had a house to sell ,and because this for me is a rarity ,I needed someone on whom I could rely ,Carl came with a recommendation from a family member ,I found Carl to be not only professional but easy to work with, a rare combination and he provided a positive outcome for me this is all good.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Buyer review
Great communicator
over 5 years ago
Great communicator

We were impressed by Carl’s unhurried, diligent and straightforward approach - substance rather than hype. He kept us informed and was responsive to our requests.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
Extremely patient with a complex sale
over 5 years ago
Extremely patient with a complex sale

Carl was fabulous in sorting out my remote and post-separation property sale. He was happy to meet with my parents - who said he "seemed like a good bloke" and they couldn't have been more correct. Despite me being 1500km away and having to negotiate with both me and my ex-partner (separately), once it got moving, the sale couldn't have been smoother. Carl kept me informed every step of the way, but just got on and did what needed to be done. We got an excellent price and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend him to sell your property by the bay.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
Seller review
My experience with Carl Calio and Calio & Scott Real Estate
over 5 years ago
My experience with Carl Calio and Calio & Scott Real Estate

I have been associated with Carl Calio and his real estate team for 15 +years. During this time they have been extremely professional and courteous in assisting me in all areas of maintenance and management of my rental property. Carl is a rare breed who rings when he says he will ring. During periods of his management where increased communication was required, his timing, frequency and informative communication across various media channels was most helpful and welcome. Although our real estate relationship has concluded with the professionally swift sale of my property, I wish Carl and his team well, now and again when the world starts spinning properly. Take care and I hope you still keep that warm smile and genuine handshake available.

Carl Calio

Carl Calio

  5   (242 reviews)
145 - 156 of 255
© 2026 RateMyAgent