Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
129 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, friendly, honest, supportive, reliable, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
A successful outome
3 months ago
A successful outome

John's experienced showed in the way he guided me through the whole sales process. He provided regular feedback following open inspections and interactions with prospective purchasers. Come Auction Day he engaged with bidders with a blend of humor and professionalism and achieve a great result for me. I would have no hesitation in using John and Gary J Smith in the future.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Good to deal with, support staff excellent
3 months ago
Good to deal with, support staff excellent

We bought a property through GaryJSmith. Whilst we mainly delt with Catlin who we going to be amazing, John was also the agent. They were prompt, good communicators, easy to get info we needed and prompt to reply. Definitely a great experience and low stress.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Repeat Clients
3 months ago
Repeat Clients

John was exceptional in all communications & went over & beyond at open inspections. Over several years we have bought & sold 3 times with John each time providing excellent service

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Honest and responsive
3 months ago
Honest and responsive

Our experience with John Muscat and Caitlin Clarke was seamless from initial contact and appraisal to the sale of our property. We hadn't sold a property before so didn't really know what to expect. John and Caitlin remained clear and consistent with their advice and communication the whole way through the process, which made the experience stress free without any hiccups. We would happily recommend John and Caitlin to anyone looking to sell their home or investment property.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly professional and easy to deal with
3 months ago
Highly professional and easy to deal with

We recently purchased a property through John Muscat from Gary J Smith Real Estate and couldn’t be happier with the experience. From start to finish John was professional, approachable, and extremely helpful. His communication was excellent throughout the entire process, keeping us informed every step of the way and always making himself available to answer any questions. Purchasing a property can often be stressful, but John made the whole process smooth and straightforward. His knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and genuine care for both buyer and seller really stood out. We truly appreciate all of his support in securing our new home and would have no hesitation in recommending John to anyone looking to buy or sell. Thank you again for all your help. Shane & Barbara

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Second sale with John and Caitlin
3 months ago
Second sale with John and Caitlin

This is the second time we have trusted John and Caitlin to manage our sale. As with the previous sale they have been professional, great communicators delivered on everything they promised. They are an awesome duo. Would highly recommend.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly recommended Agent
5 months ago
Highly recommended Agent

John was excellent from start to finish. Friendly, efficient, and always quick to respond. Made the entire experience smooth and well-managed.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
A confident professional
5 months ago
A confident professional

We met John at our first viewing of our new home. He was very well presented as was Caitlin. They were both very polite, attentive and knowledgable about the property. We visited again at future opens and eventually private openings to ensure we had made the right decision. At all times John and Caitlin were patient and punctual in our arranged meeting times. As we are an older couple. We were helped immensely in our deliberations and negotiations ensuring we were fairly treated in the final stages of purchasing the property. Well done John and Caitlin!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Nothing was too hard
5 months ago
Nothing was too hard

John went above and beyond what would normally be considered a salesman's brief. In understanding my position John did all he could to make the house sale an easy experience for me. Highly recommended to prospective sellers.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Seller review
Experience counts
5 months ago
Experience counts

John and Caitlin were very easy to work with, communicating promptly and respectfully about what do and when about the property sale.

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Genuine, reliable and kind
7 months ago
Genuine, reliable and kind

It was a pleasure to buy our new home from John. He was always available to answer all of our questions and followed up each of our queries quickly. His knowledge of the housing market was excellent and we knew we could trust his professional judgement. His approach was flexible and his manner was always obliging and genuine. Throughout this exciting but stressful experience, we felt reassured by John’s ‘can do’ attitude and he demonstrated his authenticity throughout the entire process. Thank you so much, John! We feel very privileged to have bought our future seaside home from you!

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional
7 months ago
Exceptional

John was highly professional and called me up the day after I viewed the house to ask my thoughts and if I would like to come to another house inspection to get another feel for the house as I was really interested. I expressed my concerns about next doors pets noise and he put my mind at ease about it as I started to just focus on that! Now that ive moved in there is barely ever any noise from next doors pets so was glad John set me straight on this minor hiccup. Very happy to have gone ahead with the house and John and Caitlin were very accommodating and patient throughout the entire process especially when there were a few unprecedented issues before settlement. Thank you both so much for your guidance and professionalism throughout the time. Kind regards

John Muscat

John Muscat

  4.8   (230 reviews)
1 - 12 of 129
Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
Contact Gary J Smith Real Estate - Plympton
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent