Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
144 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, reliable, local expert, friendly, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Landlord review
Best Property Manager
over 7 years ago
Best Property Manager

Caitlin is the best property manager we have ever had - and we have used that “other” agency in Avalon (you know the one with the picture of the sand (I think it is emblamatic - you will be treated by them like a grain of sand) - and would never use them again! Caitlin is proactive, knowledgeable, consultative and communicative. I have always found her advice to be spot on. We are very happy with her and would not hesitate for a second to recommend her - I’m sure you will be pleasantly surprised

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Tenant review
McGrath Avalon
over 7 years ago
McGrath Avalon

We have absolutely loved renting through McGrath Avalon! Caitlin and the team always go above and beyond to respond to any questions in a timely manner. Caitlin actually cares about her clients and their needs and will always go out of her way to make sure our needs are met. I wouldn’t hesitate to rent through McGrath again in the future. Caitlin has set the bar very high for Property Managers on the northern beaches, you would be hard pressed to find a better one. Thanks for everything, the Baileys.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Awesome property manager
over 7 years ago
Awesome property manager

We have been so pleased with Caitlin at McGrath Avalon. Her communication is 10/10! We feel so confident knowing she is looking after out property.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Fantastic agency
over 7 years ago
Fantastic agency

I would highly recommend McGrath Avalon for their awesome property management work👍

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Tenant review
Excellent agent
over 7 years ago
Excellent agent

Caitlin has been a top class professional who is an excellent communicator and has always been very polite, friendly and easy to deal with!

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Tenant review
Best property manager i have ever had
over 7 years ago
Best property manager i have ever had

Caitlin Capp has been our property manager for just over 18 months. She is timely in her responses and truly went above and beyond to help us secure the perfect rental. I would highly recommend her and McGrath Avalon.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Caitlin Capp
over 7 years ago
Caitlin Capp

Fun to work with and gets the job done.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Excellent agent
over 7 years ago
Excellent agent

We choose McGrath's Avalon to be our rental agent as we like the people who work there . Caitlin was new to the agency and we were not disappointed. Her work ethic, her depth of knowledge and her likeable manner made the decision to give the rental of our house to her. She has left no stone unturned when problems arise, she is efficient and deals with everything in a unobtrusive yet positive way. I have no hesitation in recommending this agency

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Great Communication
over 7 years ago
Great Communication

Our Property Manager has been excellent and made everything easy for us being first time investors, she always communicates promptly and organises anything to do with the property straight away.

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
Landlord review
Fantastic Communication
over 7 years ago
Fantastic Communication

Caitlin has been highly personable and communicative about all matters with my property. Her professionalism, knowledge and efficiency is the best service a property owner could ask for!

McGrath Pittwater

McGrath Pittwater

  4.9   (1292 reviews)
121 - 132 of 144
© 2026 RateMyAgent