Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
2111 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Landlord review
Poor Management and slow to action
over 3 years ago
Poor Management and slow to action

December 2022 we had a smooth sign up with Buxton. Choosing a tenant went well. We felt settled and that out property was in good hands. Its April 2023 we have had 4 new property managers, (various reasons for them leaving) and each transition has been hard as we have to explain ongoing issues to be addressed. We have had an ongoing leak in the HWS (Hot Water System) this is disturbing the tenant and should be fixed under warranty. The property manager must organize an appointment between HWS provider and tenant -we provided all details. Countless times we have had to follow this issue up ourselves as landlords, sending emails and making calls which is what the property manager should be doing. If you do not follow up, they don't get back to you. Current property manager is not responsive to emails, we have made complaints about our experiences in writing and they have not been addressed or acknowledged - No response. Whats been happening is that maintenance issues are put through, we assign/approve the action to be taken, the issue is not carried thought/fixed by property manager, then weeks later the Buxton group goes on to send you the same maintenance request in the client portal. Currently, it is very frustrating because this ongoing issue is causing more damage to our property each week and no action has been taken for months. Our experience as land lords with Buxton has not been positive.

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Landlord review
Exceptional service and a great atention to detail
over 3 years ago
Exceptional service and a great atention to detail

Tayla was an excellent agent throughout the process of finding a new tenant for my property. She ensured I was kept up to date with ledes and potential tenants for the property after every inspection, as well as ensuring that when applications did come through, they were objectively assessed as to whether they were a good fit for the property. I would strongly recommend Tayla from Buxton's Ballarat to anyone who has an investment property in the Ballarat area and is looking for a new property manager.

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Tenant review
Incredibly fast approval…
over 3 years ago
Incredibly fast approval…

Nadine was absolutely amazing. Nadine was always contactable and assisted me with my application issues and approval process, making it so much easier. Thankyou for accepting me as a tenant, was an extremely quick process. Inspection of property, application and approval within 6 days is remarkable…

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Landlord review
Respectful and professional service
over 3 years ago
Respectful and professional service

Lily, Sarah and Jorja know the market well and offer valuable advices. They treat us with respect, always ask for our opinion before making any decision regarding our property.

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Tenant review
Professional and go that extra mile to help
over 3 years ago
Professional and go that extra mile to help

Agent Jame is very efficient , kind , helpful and hospitable and the service provided was excellent. As new migrant moving to Australia who wanted to secure a place/house rent in Ballarat, with many queries and request , Agent Jamie is very patient to answer all our concerns and make us feel comfortable with all the process to close the deal with the house owner and also he had to go extra mile to help us with our power connection to ensure that we will be comfortable and welcome to the new place/house that will be staying in Ballarat. I would highly recommend Jamie and the rest of the Buxton real estate team 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Tenant review
Easy to deal with
over 3 years ago
Easy to deal with

Prompt and professional service.

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Tenant review
Great experience
over 3 years ago
Great experience

First house we looked at & we loved it. Was exactly as shown on the rental add, the realestate agent was prompt and really nice! Definitely a stand out among other realestate companies I’ve dealt with previously!

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Landlord review
A very happy Landlord.
over 3 years ago
A very happy Landlord.

Kaelee Elsley is my property manager and i'm extremely happy with the service. Quick to response and action taken when required. Would highly recommend Buxton Ballarat for managing your property.

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Landlord review
Highly professional and quality service
over 3 years ago
Highly professional and quality service

Kaelee has been an excellent agent in managing our investment property. Incredibly knowledgeable and friendly and always willing to go above and beyond. Would strongly recommend!

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Landlord review
Fantastic Experience With Buxton
over 3 years ago
Fantastic Experience With Buxton

Buxton have shown themselves to be very good property managers. The tenants presented have been very good, property reports punctual, and the administration and compliance has been spot on. I recommend Buxton wholeheartedly

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Tenant review
Efficient and very easy to deal with
over 3 years ago
Efficient and very easy to deal with

Everything went well, Nothing to complain. My only issue is the sheer of spam I am getting from 2Apply, and services. I am happy with the service and the responsiveness of our agent.

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
Tenant review
Very helpful and easy to talk too
over 3 years ago
Very helpful and easy to talk too

Buxton has been extremely helpful in our searce for a home replied very quickly to emails and could get on the phone with them any time during there open hours to answer our questions

Buxton Ballarat

Buxton Ballarat

  4.9   (2349 reviews)
841 - 852 of 2,111
© 2026 RateMyAgent