Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
460 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
over 5 years ago
Professional, Enthusiastic and Hardworking

It has honestly been a pleasure dealing with Natalie from the very start. The property sold in under five days after listing!! All thanks to the property presentation and hard work delivered by Natalie. I would have no hesitation at all in recommending Natalie and look forward to any future dealings.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Just Fantastic and Awesome to deal with!

Having bought and sold numerous properties and dealing with agents, Natalie by far has to be the out-performing star. She set up a chat with the parties involved, and kept us up to date on each and every detail. She was able to sell the property within the campaign period and always having a great enthusiasm and excitement. It definitely helps buyers and sellers become more comfortable when dealing with a large asset in life. Having a first home buyer buying our asset, Nat was able to hand hold them each step of the way to ensure they were comfortable and had all aspects ticked off. Was a great outcome and the interactions with Nat as an agent was the best I've had so far in my property era. Many thanks Nat and also to Zoe, as they were the team! Cheers

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
She is more like a friend rather than an agent only for business.

Most real estate agents are no different from other retail salesmen, with a lot of smooth talks and over promises. Zoe approached her job with great honesty, kindness and confidence. The sale price is a little bit below what we excepted, but we know it's a difficult time and year for everyone, and Zoe did her best to achieve the best result for us. Overall I'm so glad we made the right decision to let Zoe and Buxton to sale our property.

Zoe Cherrie

Zoe Cherrie

  4.9   (255 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Excellent working relationship

Nat was great to work with and the process of buying my first home easy. She is very communicative and kept me in the loop as a buyer.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
A knowledgeable, positive, driven agent!

Nat was ambitious from the moment I met her! Her positive, will do personality made the selling process so smooth & hopeful! She knew the market so well & knew that what we were aiming for we will achieve! Her communication skills were exemplary and professional. Nat would give me daily phone calls and text messages updating me frequently. She has done such an amazing job! Highly recommend her

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Fantastic buyer management and straightforward

I very much enjoyed purchasing from Nat - She was able to coach me through the process as well as achieve a great result for her Vendor.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
A very pro active plan, an excellent outcome.

David has a real insight in st Kilda area, his market knowledge was very accurate. David always communicated each process always informing me after each inspection with feedback. Outstanding professionalism, a pleasure doing business with David and his team.

David Seeber

David Seeber

  4.8   (117 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Like dealing with a friend!

Natalie was brilliant. Made the entire process feel easy and comfortable. As a first time buyer it can be quiet overwhelming but Natalie was knowledgeable and accommodating to all questions throughout the process.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Zoe Cherrie = great customer experience

Zoe was great to deal with and has great insights and knowledge of the real estate market. Always available to answer any questions. Overall a great buyer experience.

Zoe Cherrie

Zoe Cherrie

  4.9   (255 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Responsive, helpful and dedicated

We came from another auction with Buxtons. During that time we received a lot of helpful advice about the property from Natalie. Ultimately we lost at the auction and felt devastated but were kindly encouraged by Natalie's response to our enthusiasm. With some patience and a lot of help from Natalie and David we found another place we could call home. Waiting on Settlement now but with regards to the agent's skills, there are no complaints, excellent service.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Friendly and Helpful

Natalie is knowledgeable and knows the area well. She was friendly to deal with and efficient. Happily assisted with any inquiries and extra viewings. She also made sure everything ran smoothly to close the deal.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Natalie McCasey, The best of THE BEST!!

Natalie and Matt from Buxton were a pleasure to work with. We found Natalie to be honest, professional, friendly and knowledgeable. She achieved us a great result in such a short time frame. She is hard working and will go the extra mile for you. All our expectations were met and exceeded and her excellent communication throughout the process made all the difference to us. We highly recommend using Natalie as your Real Estate Agent.

Natalie McAsey

Natalie McAsey

  5   (154 reviews)
193 - 204 of 460
Buxton Port Phillip - St Kilda
Contact Buxton Port Phillip - St Kilda
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent