Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
316 reviewsacross 27 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, reliable, supportive, honest, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent outcome
over 1 year ago
Excellent outcome

Bart arrives with a smile and is always contactable. He was always on top of everything with answers to all our questions. He fought for the best outcome and never suggested we take less than what we wanted. He may not control the market but his understanding and reading of it is outstanding. We couldn't find a better agent to deal with.

Bart Portelli

Bart Portelli

  5   (65 reviews)
Seller review
Sold after 1 week - Steven knows McGraths Hill
over 1 year ago
Sold after 1 week - Steven knows McGraths Hill

We trusted Steven with the selling of our property - we met him when we purchased the property 3 years ago. Steven is personable and knows McGraths Hill like no other agent. Very quick to respond to any query that we had during the process - and to our benefit, our property sold after being on the market for one week.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you Steven!
over 1 year ago
Thank you Steven!

Steven has been great to deal with while selling my home. Super knowledgeable of the area, honest with expectations and great communication.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Seller review
Steven was always professional, pleasant & positive. His advise & assistance was invaluable.
over 1 year ago
Steven was always professional, pleasant & positive. His advise & assistance was invaluable.

I can't recommend Steven enough - he was just wonderful to deal with. I was kept up to date with the progress of the sale & nothing was too much trouble (he was even hands on with getting the house spruced up & looking it's best for the market) Steven always answered the phone when I called & responded very quickly to any emails or text messages. Finally a great price was achieved which was definitely a result of his hard work, focus & commitment. Thank you very much Steven!

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Buyer review
Couldn’t be happier!
over 1 year ago
Couldn’t be happier!

Steven was one of the first real estate agents we spoke to when we started to look for our family home and our first impressions were that he was friendly with a sense of humour and took the time to have a proper conversation about our requirements and budget. As our search continued and the more interactions we had with Steven we would now also describe him with equal parts professional, genuine, sincere and transparent. Steven gave us all the facts simply and there was no pressure to rush our decisions. Our situation was relayed to the vendor and the vendor’s situation was relayed to us in a professional manner and with that transparency we were able to achieve a shorter settlement which benefited both parties. In addition to the above Steven was also able to introduce us to our new neighbours whom had also purchased their home from Steven many years prior and it quite evident there was an excellent rapport to this day. We will strongly encourage any friends and family to contact Steven who are looking to purchase or sell in the area.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing service, professional, knowledgeable and friendly!
over 1 year ago
Amazing service, professional, knowledgeable and friendly!

For us selling our family home was a bitter sweet moment and Steven made the whole process seemless and stress free. Steven is very knowledgeable, professional and friendly and nothing was ever too big of an ask for him. Our home sold at the first open home and our friends and family couldn’t believe how quickly it all happened. If you are thinking of selling your home, I highly recommend Steven!

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Seller review
Thank you Steven!
over 1 year ago
Thank you Steven!

We first encountered Steven when we purchased our house and had such a great experience we went through him again when we had to sell. He was honest, sincere and genuine during the buying process, we trusted him during the selling process. This time around, we saw how hard he worked for us to get the best price whilst maintaining his integrity and honesty. We can’t recommend him enough. Thank you Steven.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Seller review
Highly recommend
over 1 year ago
Highly recommend

Bart has been a pleasure to deal with all through the process of selling our house. He has a great knowledge of the local market was very thorough with the whole process, keeping us informed and up to date every step of the way. I wouldn’t hesitate in recommending Bart to anyone thinking of selling their home his professional approach, punctuality and transparency make him a pleasure to deal with.

Bart Portelli

Bart Portelli

  5   (65 reviews)
Buyer review
Above and Beyond
over 1 year ago
Above and Beyond

Bart was excellent, he was really helpful and made our experience as first home buyers super easy. Bart’s communication was on point and never made us feel uncertain with our buying process.

Bart Portelli

Bart Portelli

  5   (65 reviews)
Seller review
Knowledgeable and efficient!
over 1 year ago
Knowledgeable and efficient!

Bart’s professionalism and knowledge assisted us in the sale of our home. Bart provided effective and timely communication, which ensued our trust and ease throughout the entire process. Bart took the time to explain each step of our sale and answered a range of questions. I highly recommend Bart to anyone interested in selling or purchasing a home.

Bart Portelli

Bart Portelli

  5   (65 reviews)
Seller review
Fast, efficient and happy!
over 1 year ago
Fast, efficient and happy!

9 years ago I purchased my property off Steve Garay so it seems fit that I would sell it through Steve aswell. I am more than happy with the result and had no doubt that Steve would deliver. Steve knows McGrath’s Hill like the back of his hands. It was a very fast sale, only one open home inspection. Well done!

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
Buyer review
Amazing Experience!
over 1 year ago
Amazing Experience!

Steven was absolutely amazing to deal with throughout our buying journey, he made everything so easy and explained ever step of the way as he knew we were all new to the scene buying our first home.

Steven Garay

Steven Garay

  4.9   (485 reviews)
85 - 96 of 316
© 2026 RateMyAgent