Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
562 reviewsacross 19 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, honest, friendly, supportive, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
We can’t recommend Natalie enough!
3 months ago
We can’t recommend Natalie enough!

We can’t recommend Natalie enough! From first contact she was professional, efficient and very knowledgeable of the local market. She guided us through the usual stressful selling process and remained an enthusiastic advocate through every step. You won’t regret listing with Nat!

Natalie Kay

Natalie Kay

  5   (78 reviews)
Buyer review
Efficient, responsive and genuinely had our best interest at heart.
3 months ago
Efficient, responsive and genuinely had our best interest at heart.

We had such a great experience working with Natalie. She was incredibly flexible and always worked around our schedule, which made everything so much easier. Her communication was next level - she was always quick to reply and stayed on top of everything the whole way through. What really stood out was that she never pushed us into anything that didn’t feel right. She genuinely cared about helping us find the right home, not just making a sale. She was professional, accommodating and extremely efficient from start to finish. We couldn’t recommend her highly enough!

Natalie Kay

Natalie Kay

  5   (78 reviews)
Seller review
Brilliant home sale experience
3 months ago
Brilliant home sale experience

Janelle and the team far exceeded my expectations, they were professional, courteous and caring throughout the whole process, our whole sale experience could not of gone any better.

Janelle Puppa

Janelle Puppa

  4.9   (438 reviews)
Buyer review
good communicator.
3 months ago
good communicator.

One of the few agents in town that kept me posted on new properties that came up that may have been suitable for me. And eventually found the right one.

Janelle Puppa

Janelle Puppa

  4.9   (438 reviews)
Buyer review
Genuinely interested in helping us by negotiating with the seller which ended in a fair deal for all
3 months ago
Genuinely interested in helping us by negotiating with the seller which ended in a fair deal for all

Natalie was extremely knowledgeable on the property and gave us ideas on what could be done on extending the house for our future. She also knew everything about other properties that were for sale in the area and the prices they were asking allowing us to compare apples with apples. Very easy to talk to and communicate with. We would definitely use Natalie again and highly recommend her to everyone that is on the house hunt 🙂👍in and around the Tatura area.

Natalie Kay

Natalie Kay

  5   (78 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional and friendly.
3 months ago
Very professional and friendly.

Nat was always available for any questions l had. Very professional and friendly.

Natalie Kay

Natalie Kay

  5   (78 reviews)
Buyer review
The best Real Estate Agent in Seymour
3 months ago
The best Real Estate Agent in Seymour

Having been looking for a property around Seymour since December 2025, whilst my home was up for sale, Janelle and her staff were friendly, accommodating and professional. Once my house was sold, I only had 35 days to try to find somewhere to live - trying to get settlement of the new home to match settlement of the old. Whilst this did not eventually occur, Janelle went above and beyond trying to find me properties that would suit my lifestyle (with or without renovations). She was always friendly and approachable, nothing was too much trouble, and she kept searching for a home for me that would suit my hobbies, work and lifestyle. She really got to know me, to assist in trying to find me a home. She just did not give up trying to find me the right property. I appreciate all she has done for me and my family, and would recommend her to anyone who will listen.

Janelle Puppa

Janelle Puppa

  4.9   (438 reviews)
Buyer review
Very happy client
3 months ago
Very happy client

I actually felt relax felt free to really look at the property I purchased happy with every aspect of the sale so thanks Ella

Ella Tennant

Ella Tennant

  4.9   (103 reviews)
Seller review
Very Professional and informative from the get go.
3 months ago
Very Professional and informative from the get go.

Ella and the team were very professional from the get go, always keeping us informed, and giving advice where it was needed. The other ratings and the fact that These ladies are the leading real estate in the area speaks for itself. Great work from the team.

Ella Tennant

Ella Tennant

  4.9   (103 reviews)
Seller review
Super quick results! Great negotiation skills and knowledge of the area! Can not thank you enough!
3 months ago
Super quick results! Great negotiation skills and knowledge of the area! Can not thank you enough!

What made Natalie stand out for us was that her team stood out from the start being a stand alone business. They have strong family values and actually care about people. This is our second sale with them, so proven track record. We have been recommending the team to many people for years. Their team have grown and come so far from 1 small office in Seymour! #girlpower #superwoman #amazing #keepupthegreatwork

Natalie Kay

Natalie Kay

  5   (78 reviews)
Seller review
Great result with Janelle
3 months ago
Great result with Janelle

Janelle sold our home quickly and professionally. She was easy to deal with throughout and always accessible. We’re really happy with the outcome. Thanks so much Janelle.

Janelle Puppa

Janelle Puppa

  4.9   (438 reviews)
Buyer review
A Seamless First Home Buying Experience
3 months ago
A Seamless First Home Buying Experience

As first home buyers, we had a great experience working with Janelle. From the very beginning, she was transparent, honest, and easy to communicate with, which made the whole process smooth. We really appreciated Janelle’s professionalism and would happily recommend her to anyone!

Janelle Puppa

Janelle Puppa

  4.9   (438 reviews)
25 - 36 of 562
© 2026 RateMyAgent