Our profile

Our reviews

  4.8  
109 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 years ago
If her mouth is moving she is lying.

Amie Goddard typifies the problem with the real estate industry. Do not believe a word she says, she is the most in-genuine person I have ever met. Blatantly lied in the pre-signing interview to get the listing. All talk and fake promises, but little action and no responsibility for delivering a poor strategy, illegal underquoting and a mediocre result. Amie didn't even have the courtesy to say goodbye after the auction and a well below-promised result. It showed a massive lack of respect and showed where her priorities are. Purely $$ driven - get you in and spit you out. Do everything you can to avoid Jellis Craig Mentone and Amie Goddard.

Amie Goddard

Amie Goddard

  4.7   (47 reviews)
about 5 years ago
A1 communicator, hard working, great result

Amie recently guided me through the sale of my first house. I had decided to sell right on top of Christmas and shortly after lockdown lifted (with threat of further lockdowns looming) so needless to say I was a little rattled throughout the process. However, Amie put me at ease from our very first meeting, and kept me well updated throughout. She is an extremely hard worker and exceptional communicator and reader of people, which is one of the reasons I chose to go with her/O'Brien. Amie was always readily available to answer questions or discuss concerns - on the rare occasion she didn't answer my call on first ring, she called back within 5 minutes. My house sold pre-auction and I was very happy with the result. I 100% recommend using Amie to sell your house.

Amie Goddard

Amie Goddard

  4.7   (47 reviews)
about 5 years ago
A true Professional and a credit to her Industry.

Bought a Town House recently in Highett and have had contact with Amie Goddard from that office. I realize that the O'Brien Office was looking after the Vendors in this case but ....... Amie was just lovely, she was professional and absolutely transparent with the particulars of the sale. I was the fortunate successful buyer at the Auction and I appreciated the work Byron, the Auctioneer on the day did for the Vendors. Amanda, who helped me during the process was just great too. (Sorry for being quiet Amanda, trained to not be too outgoing :-). Thanks to Christian for the photos and contract. Well done O'Brien's Mentone Office a great team effort that started with Amie, with a great result for all parties, a win/win.

Amie Goddard

Amie Goddard

  4.7   (47 reviews)
over 5 years ago
An agent you can trust and recommend

I met Amie at a busy open. She took time to speak with me, showed an interest in my circumstances, made me feel like a valued client, all without ignoring others. She had great knowledge of the property as well as the market. Amie came across as pleasant, patient and made me feel like she was an agent I could be honest with and trust. I bought my property through Amie who was understanding towards my needs through the whole process. She certainly does not ignor you once you have purchased. I would highly recommend Amie to others and actually have already done so. An amazing Agent, and an example to others as to what a great agent should be like.

Amie Goddard

Amie Goddard

  4.7   (47 reviews)
about 6 years ago
Humble Industry Expert

We’ve been following Amie throughout the Bayside area for a few years when we were looking to initially buy an investment property. While we didn’t buy our current property from Amie, we were motivated to utilise her skill & expertise when selling. During a very challenging economic time (Covid-19), Amie, Byron & Steph communicated some valuable advise about our upcoming auction which in turn brought it forward. We’re delighted in the intel they obtained, as our house sold for a great result!

Amie Goddard

Amie Goddard

  4.7   (47 reviews)
almost 7 years ago
A fantastic experience as a seller. A sale built on trust and transparency.

As potential buyers and investors, my wife and I have known Sam for many years in the Bayside area. When it was time for us to sell our property, we obviously looked at all of the leading agents in the area, but ultimately it was an easy choice for us to go with Sam. Sam's knowledge of the local, and wider market is exceptional. He always remained positive, even when communicating market conditions and strategies that probably weren't the most conducive to selling a property. As a vendor in a flat market, seeing our agent working so hard and remaining positive throughout the entire process made us feel so much more at ease with the campaign, ultimately leading to a successful result at auction. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Sam if you are looking to sell in the wider Bayside area and would happily have a chat with anyone looking for more details on our experience.

Sam Hartrick

Sam Hartrick

  4.8   (75 reviews)
almost 7 years ago
Friendly, approachable and thorough.

Sam's knowledge and advice on market trends was invaluable. His empathetic nature provided much support at a time when it was most needed.

Sam Hartrick

Sam Hartrick

  4.8   (75 reviews)
almost 7 years ago
Excellent service

Sam always provided superb service, quick to respond always, and very personable. Highly recommended.

Sam Hartrick

Sam Hartrick

  4.8   (75 reviews)
about 7 years ago
Absolutely fabulous

Mary took on my property in a slow market. A similar property in the same block took 9+ months to sell. No need for tricks here with Mary. She knows the game inside out and was absolutely confident to get me the sale. Within 3 weeks of listing we had an offer and she closed the deal for us. Great marketing team and insights the team from O’Brien real estate led by Mary Cassar are trustworthy, will do what they say and are committed with the clients best interest at the forefront. I recommend Mary Cassar to anyone who needs a real estate partner to sell their property. Thank you Mary!!

Mary Cassar

Mary Cassar

  4.8   (23 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Job well done!

Obrien Real Estate provided an excellent service in selling our bayside house. In a not ideal real estate market Obrien was able to secure a sale to the satisfaction of both buyer and seller. To both Mary and Greg I extend thanks for the professional effort they put in to secure the sale. Also the referral to Sargeants Bayside conveyancing was an excellent choice. Thank you Obrien!

Mary Cassar

Mary Cassar

  4.8   (23 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Above and Beyond

Mary is professional, warm and got the results I was hoping for. Thank you to you and your team Mary!

Mary Cassar

Mary Cassar

  4.8   (23 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Mary has a very positive and encouraging personality

Mary has been a great source of support and encouragement going through the sales process. Even though the auction did not go ahead as planned, she kept me up to date and optimistic on a positive outcome. Mary really seemed to put her heart and soul into getting me the sale and ensuring that the incoming purchaser was happy as well.

Mary Cassar

Mary Cassar

  4.8   (23 reviews)
1 - 12 of 109
© 2026 RateMyAgent