Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
3563 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: reliable, friendly, supportive, honest, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Complete and perfect service
about 1 year ago
Complete and perfect service

Karen and her team provided exceptional service, arranging a significant amout of work the prepare the property for sale. This was especially important to me, as I was over 2 hours away. Karen and her team provided excellent planning and communication, and all tasks were completed in amazingly short timeframe. The sale of the property was equally efficient and met our optimistic target after only 1.5 weeks of opens. Karen has been the best agent I have worked with in 35 years of buying and selling property.

Karen Renouf

Karen Renouf

  4.8   (657 reviews)
Buyer review
Fantastic service
about 1 year ago
Fantastic service

Very professional approach, great communication and followup a pleasure to deal with and everything done with a smile

Ming Body

Ming Body

  5   (388 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional Service
about 1 year ago
Exceptional Service

As a Buyers agent and property Investor I appreciate Karen and her team consisting of Ian and Tony for their professionalism throughout this purchase ensuring both parties were kept well informed. I give credit to this team ensuring this sale stayed on track. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend any potential seller’s or purchaser to utilise this team’s exceptional local knowledge and experience to achieve outstanding results. Kind Regards Steve Dowzard

Karen Renouf

Karen Renouf

  4.8   (657 reviews)
Buyer review
Best in the business!
about 1 year ago
Best in the business!

Highly Recommend James – A Truly Exceptional Agent!! James is an incredibly experienced, understanding, and professional estate agent. From the beginning, he took the time to truly understand what we were looking for, while also keeping his seller’s needs in mind. He was the perfect bridge between both parties and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. What really stood out was his genuine care for everyone involved. James isn’t just about making a sale—he’s about making the right connection. His professionalism, communication, and dedication were second to none. We can’t thank him enough. If you’re thinking about buying or selling, James is 100% the person you want on your side.

James Carmichael

James Carmichael

  5   (198 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing Experience!
about 1 year ago
Amazing Experience!

I just want to say how grateful I am to you for this whole process being managed so well….it was such a scary thought starting this process again after feeling so burnt from last attempt with another agent. You really are an amazing agent and we can see you work hard for both sides. To see how much work you put into our sale and to see you have had another 6 or so come on the market in that time and a few sold blows my mind, We would never have known we weren’t your sole focus. We thank you so much. Forever grateful for this positive experience we won’t forget!

Nyree Ewings

Nyree Ewings

  4.9   (1210 reviews)
Buyer review
Peter went above and beyond, he is an absolute legend!
about 1 year ago
Peter went above and beyond, he is an absolute legend!

I can’t thank Peter enough for the incredible work he put in to get our very tricky deal across the line. It was far from straightforward, but he never gave up, working tirelessly behind the scenes, problem-solving, and pushing things forward when most others would’ve walked away. His professionalism, persistence, and calm approach made all the difference. If you’re looking for someone who genuinely cares and will fight to get the job done, Peter’s your guy. Highly recommend!

Peter Stone

Peter Stone

  5   (117 reviews)
Seller review
Professional
about 1 year ago
Professional

James was amazing to work with, very informative and knowledgeable. All throughout the sale he made it a smooth and easy process.

James Carmichael

James Carmichael

  5   (198 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Service
about 1 year ago
Excellent Service

Paul was extremely helpful navigating through the process from start to finish. Highly recommended.

Paul Jackson

Paul Jackson

  4.9   (100 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Service
about 1 year ago
Excellent Service

We would highly recommend Ludwig, our sale was smooth sailing thanks to there expert team.

Ludwig Ehrke

Ludwig Ehrke

  5   (130 reviews)
Seller review
Consummate professionals
about 1 year ago
Consummate professionals

In a word, our dealings with Team Carmichael were 'fantastic'. James forms part of a small team that all have specific roles they specialise in. So, we didn't get just one agent, we got three. Graeme, James and Nick. Graeme, the lister, what a legend. He just keeps following up and he has the ability to stay in touch, keeping us informed about market trends and advising when the opportune time to list or not. All done whilst not being the slightest bit pushy but instead friendly and relaxed. After listing with Graeme the service he and his team provided was exemplary. Daily updates and weekly comprehensive statistical reports were just a part of the service. We really admired Graemes professionalism but also the fact that he is just a great guy. Good on you Graeme. Then there's James. James specifically follows up with buyers after inspections, open homes and enquiries. What was really impressive was that he leaves no stone unturned and he provided detailed feedback straight away. You are not left wondering. As a negotiater his skills come to the fore. A strategic thinker who is able to think outside of the box meant he was able to create opportunities when an apparent stalmate was reached. His ability to deal with multiple offers at the same time and to extract the best possible result was awesome. We are very grateful for his grit and determination. Then there is Nick. Working behind the scenes doing the little things that are a small part of the bigger picture. Advising open times, putting pointer boards out and carrying out any other general duties that are required. We thoroughly recommend Team Carmichael to everyone.

James Carmichael

James Carmichael

  5   (198 reviews)
Seller review
Great service.
about 1 year ago
Great service.

Graeme Carmichael made selling my mother's estate so easy. He was there to guide us through what needed to be done, made every step so easy , managed to get a great price and was always there to answer our questions. Thank you so much Graeme, for making the experience so pleasant and unstressed. I would definitely recommend you to anyone I knew who was either looking to buy or sell. So friendly, accommodating and above all professional.

James Carmichael

James Carmichael

  5   (198 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional solutions and highly profressional
about 1 year ago
Exceptional solutions and highly profressional

I highly recommend Peter. We had tenanted property that we needed to sell in a short period of time to take advantage of another opportunity. Peter's experience and personable approach meant he was able to work with and be supportive of the tenants, which in turn allowed us to get a high number of inspections through in a short period and achieve a great price. He was exceptionally quick in getting the property listed and he continued to find solutions to any challenges that arose along the way.

Peter Stone

Peter Stone

  5   (117 reviews)
565 - 576 of 3,563
© 2026 RateMyAgent