Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
981 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Weekly update rhythm
over 1 year ago
Weekly update rhythm

Tim routinely kept us informed of the prospective buyers on the weekly basis, very professional.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Very knowledgeable
over 1 year ago
Very knowledgeable

Geoff has great knowledge of Winchelsea and surrounding area. He was able to tell us about the market and what to expect. He advised us on how best to present our home in order to get the best possible outcome. Following his advice our home sold in a matter of weeks and his communication was excellent.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Best of the best
over 1 year ago
Best of the best

Geoff was exemplary in every regard. The way he works is head and shoulders above other agents in the wider area. He's also extremely personable. I'd recommend Geoff without hesitation

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
The Best Real Estate Agents on the Surf Coast
over 1 year ago
The Best Real Estate Agents on the Surf Coast

The service, professionalism, communication and market knowledge that Geoff has is second to none. We received weekly updates and the market pricing for our property was spot on. We never felt out of the loop and Geoff made us feel like we were his only client even though he is super busy. I rate McCartneys and Geoff highly and I would not use any other agency on the Surf Coast they are across every aspect of Buying and Selling Real Estate. Geoff was our first choice of agent when we decided to sell our property mainly because we purchased the property through him 16 years ago and we were impressed with his relaxed calm manner and professionalism then and now. I will be recommending Geoff to all our friends and neighbours.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Best agent in town
over 1 year ago
Best agent in town

Tim achieved a fast and fantastic result for us in a tough market. We highly recommend Tim as the most genuine and professional agent in town, always maintaining a high level of respect for his vendor and their property.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Tim made the selling process uncomplicated
over 1 year ago
Tim made the selling process uncomplicated

It’s easy to write good things when an agent obtains the price range you were after. It’s the things along the way that tells of an agent’s quality and professionalism. Tim gets a big tick ✅ on all of the following. Intial appraisal range - Accurate ✅ Marketing strategy ✅ Feed back ✅ Negotiation Skills ✅ After Sales service ✅ We’ve sold a number of properties over the years, on many occasions the ink hasn’t dried on the contract and the agent is off chasing the next deal. Tim’s services are A1 right through to settlement. We highly recommend Tim and his company.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional
over 1 year ago
Exceptional

Tim is an outstanding agent. Professional, Pro active, Knowledgable, Personable, organised, hands on, with an exceptional work ethic. Our experience with Tim as first time buyers on the surf coast was incredibly positive. From the first inspection, through to settlement, Tim went above and beyond to answer all of our questions, (and we had many) and facilitate our every request. His communication skills were exceptional, at all times keeping us informed of all updates. Tim is very professional, but also just as importantly very personable, which made finding, and ultimately securing our dream holiday home in our dream location, a very enjoyable, stress free process. We highly recommend Tim. Should we ever want to buy again, or indeed sell on the surf coast, Tim would be, without question, the person we would engage.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional, proactive and knowledgable!
over 1 year ago
Professional, proactive and knowledgable!

Exceptional . Tim is an outstanding agent. Professional, Pro active, Knowledgable, Personable, organised, hands on, with an exceptional work ethic. Our experience with Tim as first time buyers on the surf coast was incredibly positive. From the first inspection, through to settlement, Tim went above and beyond to answer all of our questions, (and we had many) and facilitate our every request. His communication skills were exceptional, at all times keeping us informed of all updates. Tim is very professional, but also just as importantly very personable, which made finding, and ultimately securing our dream holiday home in our dream location, a very enjoyable, stress free process. We highly recommend Tim. Should we ever want to buy again, or indeed sell on the surf coast, Tim would be, without question, the person we would engage.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agent in Town
over 1 year ago
Best Agent in Town

Tim achieved a fast and fantastic result for us while at all times remaining professional, respectful and genuine in his approach. We would highly recommend Tim and the McCartney team for selling any Surf Coast property - Tim is by far the best agent in town.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Communication
over 1 year ago
Great Communication

Thanks Tim for your time and patience helping us to purchase our new home ,

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Hard working
over 1 year ago
Hard working

We had a difficult property to sell, and we got there in the end thanks to Geoff's persistence.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
A very seamless experience
over 1 year ago
A very seamless experience

Thanks, Tim, for your efforts in selling our property so quickly, we were very pleased with the result. Your open communication, professionalism and honesty were appreciated

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
109 - 120 of 981
© 2026 RateMyAgent