Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
990 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Excellent agent to deal with
over 8 years ago
Excellent agent to deal with

I have been very fortunate to have Tim Carson as my agent for the sale of my property in Jan Juc. McCartney Real estate have been wonderful agents for my family for many years with holiday rentals and I've been very pleased with their management of my rental property in Jan Juc. Tim Carson has been brilliant, especially as I live in Melbourne and it is difficult for me to travel to Torquay to organize the sale. I have felt confident in Tim's advice and his communication with me has made this process easy and I cannot thank you enough Tim - and your team for the excellent advice and guidance to assist me in placing my lovely home on the market. The people you recommended to prepare the house for sale were wonderful and I am grateful for the wise advice I received from all of you to prepare my property for sale. The house is near Bird Rock however it's clear to me that you all Rock. Best wishes Susan Lonergan

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Good communication
over 8 years ago
Good communication

Kept me up to date throughout without chasing

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Exceptional Service
over 8 years ago
Exceptional Service

Tim was one of the most reliable real estate agents I have dealt with. We have been purchasing property in the Surfcoast region for over 15 years now, and this last purchase really was so easy. Tim responded to my calls, supplied background information in a very timely manner, and kept me informant at all stages of the sale campaign. He offered solid advice and even the after purchase follow up has been over and above. For one of the best guys in the business, I didn’t think he would have too much time to dedicate to each person, however that was definitely not the case. Professional, reliable and approachable was what we experienced. Thanks Tim and all at McCartneys.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Hyett's thanks
over 8 years ago
Hyett's thanks

We have only had positive experiences with Tim. Always available and eager to please. I would recommend him to anyone buying or selling. Thanks Tim!

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Confident and came through
over 8 years ago
Confident and came through

Geoff was super confident that he could sell our property, and that he'd get us a great price. He did. Within a week. Can't fault that!

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Faultless Agent.
over 8 years ago
Faultless Agent.

From the first communication regarding the sale of our property we have not been able to fault the service,the feed back on a daily basis,and the final negotiation has been flawless. Thank you Tim and all your team. Rob and Alison.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic Agent!
over 8 years ago
Fantastic Agent!

The whole process of selling our property, from start to finish, has been an absolute pleasure with Geoff. It was clear from the beginning that Geoff has extensive knowledge of the market, and used it throughout the process to ensure the best results for us. Communication was fantastic, with Geoff making sure that we were both informed of every detail throughout the process, and was prompt and knowledgeable in answering any of our questions or queries. Having such a great, reliable agent throughout this stressful process has definitely made it a lot easier than it could have been! We have already recommended Geoff to many other people, and will continue to do so in the future. Best in the business!

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Buyer review
Thanks.....
over 8 years ago
Thanks.....

Thanks Geoff - made purchase relatively headache free with honesty and no hard sell - what a relief!

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Buyer review
what a change
over 8 years ago
what a change

How delightful it was to deal with McCartney Real Estate again. Professional, no I know it all attitude , knowledge and good business behaviour is definitely the tone for this agency and Geoff was all of those things. A pleasure to have trust in your real estate agent.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic.
over 8 years ago
Fantastic.

Geoff was professional, courteous, informative and incredibly helpful in regards to the property sale. Highly recommended!

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Tim Carson Review
over 8 years ago
Tim Carson Review

Tim was excellent to deal with, we have used a number of agents in selling properties, Tim would have to be one of the best we have used. Great communication and no rubbish talk. We would highly recommend Tim and McCartney Real Estate to any seller or buyer.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Reliable agent
over 8 years ago
Reliable agent

Reliable, honest approach and supplied lots of helpful information. Recommended.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
817 - 828 of 990
© 2026 RateMyAgent