Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
982 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
what a change
over 8 years ago
what a change

How delightful it was to deal with McCartney Real Estate again. Professional, no I know it all attitude , knowledge and good business behaviour is definitely the tone for this agency and Geoff was all of those things. A pleasure to have trust in your real estate agent.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic.
over 8 years ago
Fantastic.

Geoff was professional, courteous, informative and incredibly helpful in regards to the property sale. Highly recommended!

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Tim Carson Review
over 8 years ago
Tim Carson Review

Tim was excellent to deal with, we have used a number of agents in selling properties, Tim would have to be one of the best we have used. Great communication and no rubbish talk. We would highly recommend Tim and McCartney Real Estate to any seller or buyer.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Reliable agent
over 8 years ago
Reliable agent

Reliable, honest approach and supplied lots of helpful information. Recommended.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Pleasant Experience
over 8 years ago
Pleasant Experience

Geoff was pleasant to deal with, very knowledgeable, competent and generally kept me up to date. Would highly recommend him to anyone.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
over 8 years ago
Great Agent

Great experience with Tim from start to finish.Regularly kept us updated .on any interest,honestly and openly. We would certainly recommend McCartney Realestste too all our friends

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Experience, Great Agent
over 8 years ago
Great Experience, Great Agent

Buying our new property through Geoff was quick and effortless. When viewing the property Geoff was knowledgeable and honest in his approach. We never felt like he was pushing a sale and allowed us time to look around and discuss our thoughts. Geoff was fantastic when we decided to make an offer and the process was smooth and stress free. We were so impressed with Geoff's approach we enlisted him to sell our current property which he did a fantastic job with. Geoff is an asset to real estate in Winchelsea and we highly recommend him to everyone.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Highly recommend agent
over 8 years ago
Highly recommend agent

We found Tim Carson a fantastic agent with a very open and easy to talk to manner. His communication regarding all aspects of the sale was very prompt and clear. His enthusiastic approach right from the start made us feel very confident and happy to have him deal with the sale. The fantastic result was achieved in only three weeks. We would highly recommend Tim Carson to sell any property, be it on the Surfcoast's many townships or the inland regions. Corey Wylie

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Great Experience, Great Agent
over 8 years ago
Great Experience, Great Agent

Geoff's friendly, professional and easy going manner made a potentially stressful process quick and stress free. Nothing was a hassle with Geoff and he ensured we were well informed throughout the whole process. We are extremely happy with the result of the short sale of our house thanks to Geoff's knowledge and professionalism. We highly recommend Geoff to everyone.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Buyer review
happy ending to real estate search
over 8 years ago
happy ending to real estate search

i visited geoff soon after the mccartney real estate office opened in winchelsea and explained my property requirements. The first three properties geoff showed me were not quite what we were looking for, and he suggested we consider 8 heath drive which met our requirements. geoff was prompt in conveying our initial offer to the vendor, and his assistance in the negotiation process resulted in a sale being made. I would not hesitate to use geoff's real estate services again if the need arises.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
great agent
over 8 years ago
great agent

Geoff kept us informed throughout the sale process. He followed up potential buyers and did his utmost to promote our property. I thought it was helpful that a new office had recently been opened in Winchelsea. We were very happy with the auction result and have no hesitation in recommending Geoff and the team from McCartney Real Estate.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Buyer review
Great communication
over 8 years ago
Great communication

Being a Real estate agent ourselves we are always interested to see how others handle a sale. Tim was diligent, had strong communication and helpful . It made the sale fairly smooth and is a pleasure to deal with. Many Thanks Daniel and Stacey Hayes

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
817 - 828 of 982
© 2026 RateMyAgent