McGrath Croydon

159 Main Street, Croydon VIC 3136
  •   4.7   (68 reviews)

Meet the team

Get to know the 2 agents at McGrath Croydon.

Paul Fenech
Paul Fenech

Principal / Auctioneer / Sales Agent

  4.6   (45 reviews)
About Paul
Directing a team of industry leading professionals to award winning success, Paul Fenech is a force to be reckoned with, accruing over 28 years of real estate achievements with hard work, determination and persistence. His marketing and negotiating skills are beyond compare and have led to record breaking sales reaching 94% above asking price. Always keen to develop and finely tune his skills, Paul attends training courses at both domestic and international venues with renowned real estate professionals at the helm. His personal involvement in sales campaigns is genuine and considerate, always using his adroit initiative to gain maximum rewards for his clients greatest assets. A local for nearly thirty years, Paul has unmatched knowledge of the area, specialising in Croydon and its surrounds. His exemplary talents and career longevity are a perfect fit with McGrath Estate Agents and their dominant industry presence. To profit from this formidable partnership, call Paul Fenech today.
View Profile
Lan Phung
Lan Phung

Sales Agent

  4.6   (40 reviews)
About Lan
Respected for her market knowledge, Lan Phung is an effective Sales Consultant who prides herself on the premium results she achieves for her clients. The opportunity to meet new people and create stress free experiences for them is something Lan finds rewarding.
View Profile

About us

McGrath Croydon are proven real estate experts with years of experience and extensive knowledge of the local area. Our dedicated sales and property management team take pride in having a reputation for excellence that is unmatched in the region. The key to our success is our access to cutting edge marketing, innovative technology and now an extensive networks of interstate clients and investors spanning the east coast of Australia. With experience in a vast array of properties ranging from period homes to large family residences and apartments, our team is versatile and committed. In alignment with McGrath’s renowned six star level of customer service, we consistently provide outstanding client experiences and results.

Our reviews

  4.7  
68 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 6.
over 3 years ago
Everyone did a fantastic job

Paul was very helpful ,delivered on what he promised & a quick sale.

Paul Fenech

Paul Fenech

  4.6   (45 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Delivered what was promised!

Great communication and support. Exceptional market knowledge.

Paul Fenech

Paul Fenech

  4.6   (45 reviews)
over 4 years ago
Only after your listing. Do not recommend

I recently sold my property with Paul and upon the first meeting with Paul to obtain an appraisal. Paul was comforting and sharp. He was also quite pushy to get us to sign us as a listing, which I didn’t mind because I thought he would be good in negotiating with potential buyers. However, that is where it stopped. We never saw Paul again even though we explicitly asked that if we signed with him that he would do our open inspections and be the main point of contact. This didn’t happen. He never attended one of our open inspections and the only time I heard from him was when he tried to convince me to take the first offer we received, which was much lower than my expectation and what we had discussed at the time of listing. Paul plays a volume game and tried to turn over our house as quickly as possible so he could move onto his next victim. A word of caution to anyone thinking of using Paul to sell you home. His first impression is great, but a lot of what he says is just to get your listing and doesn’t stand behind what he says he will do as part of his service.

Paul Fenech

Paul Fenech

  4.6   (45 reviews)
over 5 years ago
The most disgusting experience of my life. Do Not Recommend.

The McGrath Group (Paul Fenech, Croydon Office), advertised a superior property with a bright, white, floor to ceiling immaculate looking kitchen and delivered an ugly, grey and impractical kitchen with the stair landing protruding through the kitchen pantry and cabinets. When I mentioned this to him, Paul had the audacity to send me a photo by text of his home imperfections. To say I was disgusted by Paul’s lack of empathy was an understatement. McGrath Group made me feel like I was worthless. McGrath Group showed no formal process of customer complaint resolution. I felt that now they have my money they have done their job. I then proceeded to express my concerns to the Franchise Founder, John McGrath, and got no response. I have never had such a bad real estate experience and will NEVER use McGrath Group again. Guttered and disillusioned

Paul Fenech

Paul Fenech

  4.6   (45 reviews)
over 5 years ago
Refreshing and compassionate.

Paul was professional, friendly, compassionate and down to earth. Paulwas refreshing to deal with which made the purchase of our house at auction as stress free as possible. We would definitely employ his services again in the future.

Paul Fenech

Paul Fenech

  4.6   (45 reviews)
Show all 68 reviews

Our properties

McGrath Croydon has 25 properties for sale and sold 154 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
Price not available
36 Eothen Ln
Kilsyth VIC 3137
3
2
1
Apartment
For Sale
Price not available
33 Shakespeare Avenue
Mooroolbark VIC 3138
3
1
2
House
SoldMay 14, 2026
$1,300,000
38 Morgan Avenue
Croydon VIC 3136
4
3
2
House
For Sale
Price not available
12 Struan Avenue
Mooroolbark VIC 3138
Land
Show all 179 properties
Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent