Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
183 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
9 days ago
Extremely professional and trustworthy.

Melanie has a warmth about her and at the same time is extremely professional. We are over the moon with the sale and would certainly recommend Melanie and her team.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
9 days ago
Super clear communication

She delivered on everything she promised. Super clear communication and amazing to work with. Thank you Melanie!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
9 days ago
Very accommodating of us

Melanie made our buying experience smooth with timely communication and was very accommodating of us as first home buyers.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
9 days ago
Couldn’t recommend more

Mel is the best, direct, no fluff, knows the market. I have bought and sold with Mel, couldn’t recommend more. Hayley

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
15 days ago
Mel was great from the first phone call.

Mel was great from the first phone call. Professional, honest and very clear. Loved how easy it was to communicate and Mel was never hard to get a hold of. Highly recommended!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
11 months ago
The 5-star reviews for Melanie are well-deserved

The sale Melanie handled for me was a bit of a bumpy road at times, but her deep knowledge of the St Kilda area, professionalism, and patience made all the difference. Thanks to her steady guidance, we reached a good outcome in the end.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
11 months ago
Josh and Tracy did an incredible job!

Josh, Tracy and the McGrath team have been incredible as both PMs and recently as our sales agents. The market has been soft recently, and despite a well-executed campaign, buyers were scarce. Josh and Tracy did an incredible job securing us a sale and the maximum amount of money they could. We ended up with a number above our reserve, and given the challenges along the way, this was an incredible effort. They were patient, optimistic, kept us well informed and never gave up. Thank you team!

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 1 year ago
Josh was a pleasure to work with,

He made us feel like our apartment was the most important property he was selling and always communicated clearly when providing us updates throughout the campaign. He made a great team with Tracy

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 1 year ago
A very professional team

Living interstate for nearly 15 years I relied heavily on Josh and Tracy who provided great local market knowledge about the best approach to sell my property. After each open for inspection I was called with the results, and we’d discuss the best way forward based on the feedback and how the market was trending in the area. All options were discussed as we progressed through the sales campaign. A very professional team with great market knowledge and customer service.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 2 years ago
Five Stars

Josh & Tracy have been excellent to work with in the 9 years that I've known them. When I first purchased the property they were transparent with me as a buyer, happily provided me advice over the years as my circumstances changed, and were then able to achieve an excellent result when selling the property.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 2 years ago
A very genuine and trustworthy agent

The sale of our property was strategically well managed and invaluable advice given. Josh knows the property market in this area very well and he guided us through a nervous time for us. He is professional and always responds in a very timely manner, his evaluations honest and true. A very genuine and trustworthy agent who works perfectly well with his assistant Tracy Paus.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 2 years ago
Josh is a great person to deal with.

He always kept us up to date with the selling process and developments, which resulted in a successful sale.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
1 - 12 of 183
© 2026 RateMyAgent