Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
183 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
Great great great

Great great great great

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 3 years ago
made the whole process of buying my home a pleasure

Melanie was great to deal with and made the whole process of buying my home a pleasure. Thank you Mel for helping me and my son purchase our beautiful Art Deco home!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Excellent excellent excellent

Excellent Communication Excellent real estate knowledge Excellent sale strategy

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 3 years ago
courteous and very effective

Melanie was completely on the ball, courteous and very effective. I have only praise and appreciation.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Highly trustworthy real estate agent

Top, highly trustworthy real estate agent in the St Kilda area. Knows the area inside out, provided exceptional communication throughout the process and recommended some services (such as staging and flooring) which were all great and lifted the house amazingly. Was able to navigate us through tougher conditions brought about by rate rises and find us a buyer at a great price. Highly recommended, great service - a true real estate leader in the area.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Great communicator

Josh was calm and professional and gave us plenty of feedback about how our house was going during the campaign.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 4 years ago
I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them

I’d highly recommend Team Stirling (Josh & Tracey) as your REA. They handled the sale of my property last year when lockdowns and restrictions were in force with absolute professionalism and were proactive with their communications throughout the process. On top of that they explained what was required to ensure I received the best result during the sale. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone in the future. Thanks again, Josh and Tracey!

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 4 years ago
Efficient & Friendly Agent

Melanie went above & beyond to negotiate with the vendor on my behalf. She was very efficient and communicated clearly. I am so happy with my new apartment - thank you Melanie!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Great advice, communication and result

Josh and Tracy had excellent insight into the market and their advice was gold. We were extremely happy with our sales result and would gladly work with Josh and Tracy again in future.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Didn't Disappoint

Melanie and Josh were a delight to deal with. After a difficult campaign with another agency, we had absolute trust in McGrath to get our house sold, and they didn’t disappoint. Thank you!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Always delivers exceptional results

If you’re looking for a charismatic and knowledgeable agent, then look no further than Josh. We have used Josh multiple times now and he always delivers exceptional results. I highly recommend Josh and his exceptional team; you won’t be disappointed.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 4 years ago
Honest, hardworking and professional team

We were very fortunate to have Josh Stirling and Tracy Paus of McGrath St Kilda sell our home in Balaclava recently. We found them to be an honest, hardworking and professional team from the initial appraisal through to the auction day. They provided sound and timely advice as we prepared our home for sale. We were drawn to McGrath by their solid local knowledge and performance and a recommendation from friends who had sold with them. We would highly recommend these agents if buying or selling.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
25 - 36 of 183
© 2026 RateMyAgent