Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
180 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, empathetic, well-prepared, responsive, friendly, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Second to none
about 2 years ago
Second to none

Shellie has been an absolute pleasure working with over the years we have known her, always going above and beyond in her professionalism with a personal feel. We highly recommend Shellie and her team as she is second to none. From all of the Taylor family

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Buyer review
Excellent
about 2 years ago
Excellent

I found Shellie very helpful in all my questions about the property I was purchasing. Her knowledge was wonderful. I would recommend her gladly to others.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Shellie's market knowledge and professionalism is way above standard.
about 2 years ago
Shellie's market knowledge and professionalism is way above standard.

I would recommend Shellie to anyone, her communication and professional attitude was fantastic. The time frame she sold our Mothers house in was amazing. Her approach to both vendors and buyers was great. If you need to buy or sell a house please consider this Real Estate Agency

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional and excellent to deal with.
about 2 years ago
Very professional and excellent to deal with.

Very professional, high quality advertising & marketing through Realestate.com. Sold in 3 days. Could not do enough to help us. Highly recommended.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Experience
about 2 years ago
Great Experience

I had a great experience with Shellie & Sasha selling me my first home. Thank you!

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Service above and beyond!!!
about 2 years ago
Service above and beyond!!!

Shellie went above and beyond for us and we are extremely grateful. From the very first meeting Shellie and her team were all in to get things moving. Nothing was a problem and everything was done so quickly and we were kept informed every step of the way. Shellie's knowledge of the area was an incredible asset and gave us a good indication from the start as to what we could expect from the sale based on house prices in the area. Cannot recommend Shellie and her team enough. πŸ’—

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Amazing results!
over 2 years ago
Amazing results!

Shellie goes beyond the call of duty for finding the right property for the right person. After having my property listed with other agents on the market before finding Shellie, she made the sale of my property easy and stress free.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional Friendly Service
over 2 years ago
Professional Friendly Service

Very happy with how Shellie handled the sale of my home. Professional , friendly and very good communication.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Very pleasing result.
over 2 years ago
Very pleasing result.

Shellie has extensive knowledge regarding the areas she works within. She is extremely approachable and a lovely friendly and caring person.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Buyer review
Gets the job done!
over 2 years ago
Gets the job done!

Shelly knows how to find the right property for the buyer. Her long standing and deep connection to the community means she knows when properties are coming up for sale and who each property would suit. She is efficient in connecting sellers with their buyer. Hand working and efficient.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Market knowledge, communication and professionalism were excellent.
over 2 years ago
Market knowledge, communication and professionalism were excellent.

Dealing with Shellie took away a lot of the stress involved with selling my house. It started with the initial listing showing the house and property at its best with excellent photographs and drone footage. Thereafter, she was excellent in facilitating communication between buyer and seller. When I was prepared to accept a particular offer, she advised me that she was sure I'd get a better offer if I waited and that is exactly what happened. The offer that I finally accepted, was $10K more than what I was initially prepared to accept. I would highly recommend Shellie to anyone looking for a friendly, reliable, professional and knowledgeable agent who will offer sound advice - Dudley Goodes

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
Seller review
Very easy process
over 2 years ago
Very easy process

Shellie was always easy to deal with and was on the money with price estimate. She was prompt with feedback when showing prospective buyers . I would highly recommend Shellie whether you are a vendor or a buyer

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (465 reviews)
121 - 132 of 180
Nightingale Real Estate Tablelands
Contact Nightingale Real Estate Tablelands
What information would you like?
Β© 2026 RateMyAgent