Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
183 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Gets the job done!
over 2 years ago
Gets the job done!

Shelly knows how to find the right property for the buyer. Her long standing and deep connection to the community means she knows when properties are coming up for sale and who each property would suit. She is efficient in connecting sellers with their buyer. Hand working and efficient.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Market knowledge, communication and professionalism were excellent.
over 2 years ago
Market knowledge, communication and professionalism were excellent.

Dealing with Shellie took away a lot of the stress involved with selling my house. It started with the initial listing showing the house and property at its best with excellent photographs and drone footage. Thereafter, she was excellent in facilitating communication between buyer and seller. When I was prepared to accept a particular offer, she advised me that she was sure I'd get a better offer if I waited and that is exactly what happened. The offer that I finally accepted, was $10K more than what I was initially prepared to accept. I would highly recommend Shellie to anyone looking for a friendly, reliable, professional and knowledgeable agent who will offer sound advice - Dudley Goodes

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Very easy process
over 2 years ago
Very easy process

Shellie was always easy to deal with and was on the money with price estimate. She was prompt with feedback when showing prospective buyers . I would highly recommend Shellie whether you are a vendor or a buyer

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
What a whirlwind!
over 2 years ago
What a whirlwind!

Less than 24 hours on the market and we had a full asking price offer. Right House, Right Time, Right Buyers & Right Agent... all with minimal fuss. We appreciated the professionalism and knowledge of Shellie and Sasha and would buy or sell with them again in a heartbeat!

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Shellie Nightingale delivers!
over 2 years ago
Shellie Nightingale delivers!

Shellie demonstrated great local knowledge and communication skills. She was able to find an appropriate buyer for us in a very short time frame. She advised us about properties that suited us for sale and was able to convince the vendor that our offer was very reasonable. What a magician to be able to coordinate the sale and purchase of 3 different properties at the same time. Thanks Shellie.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Buyer review
Very Accommodating and Helpful
over 2 years ago
Very Accommodating and Helpful

Shellie was super helpful throughout the whole home-buying process, we were first time buyers and not even her clients but she still took the time to answer our questions about how to navigate the ins and outs of purchasing. Wonderful service, highly recommend!

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Sale and purchase
over 2 years ago
Sale and purchase

Shellie is a pleasure to assist you in both property purchases and sales. She is approachable and down to earth and makes the process alot more stress free.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Very satisfied and very happy with my Real Estate Shellie
over 2 years ago
Very satisfied and very happy with my Real Estate Shellie

I really very happy and satisfied to my Real Estate Shellie Nightingale to be able to sell my property that quick and she’s very friendly and very hard working too. So if anybody want to sell the property please contact Shellie at anytime

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent friendly professional Real Estate lady. Nothing is too much trouble.
over 2 years ago
Excellent friendly professional Real Estate lady. Nothing is too much trouble.

Shelly Nightingale is a true professional Real Estate lady who goes above and beyond when you are either buying for selling your property. Shelly have a no problem attitude and is always there for you with a smile on her face. Unlike many other agents Shelly actulay cares and understands your wants and needs and no amount of questions seems to bother her. Shelly is a true professional Alistair and Gail

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Seller review
Top realestate agent
over 2 years ago
Top realestate agent

Shellie was so friendly, caring, sensitive to my situation. Helped me through tough discussions I had to make in my life. Shellie was so understanding. What wonderful agent and person you are🥰 So very great full for all you did for me Fondest Regards Beryl

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
Buyer review
Down to earth local
over 2 years ago
Down to earth local

Shellie is a lovely down to earth agent who’s vast knowledge and connection with the tablelands comes from a lifetime of being a local. Shellie happy to pull on her pink gumboots and march all over the property answering questions and chatting between sellers and buyers. Very motivated and driven without pushing or pressuring anyone.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (468 reviews)
133 - 144 of 183
Nightingale Real Estate Tablelands
Contact Nightingale Real Estate Tablelands
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent