Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
176 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: honest, stress-free process, well-prepared, responsive, friendly, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Too easy job done
over 2 years ago
Too easy job done

Shellie was very easy to deal with no problems.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
Excellence
over 2 years ago
Excellence

We chose Shellie to handle our very reluctant property sale after searching online for the most honest real estate agent in our area. Additionally she has proven to be diligent and thoroughly professional in all aspects of the selling process. It is also hard to imagine a more good-natured and compassionate person to represent your interests.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
Wonderful experience
over 2 years ago
Wonderful experience

Shellie was knowledgeable and professional and made the experience easy.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
Honesty, helpful and great to work with!
over 2 years ago
Honesty, helpful and great to work with!

Shellie is one of a kind when it comes to real estate agents. I had to sell my home after my husband passed away and she was the only one I knew that would understand my situation and make the process as easy as possible. She is always calm and kind and that's the thing that stands out for me. She has your best interests at heart and always keeps it real. I can't thank Shellie enough for helping me to sell my property to allow me to move on with my life. She can be trusted and will always be gently honest with you through the whole journey.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Buyer review
The buying experience felt like a true local business interaction should.
over 2 years ago
The buying experience felt like a true local business interaction should.

Buying with Shellie was genuinely a refreshing experience for us. In a time when it’s almost a chore to deal with real estate agents, or feeling like we were just another number for many other agents, Shellie was the exception to that experience. We have sold and bought in the past but never felt as comfortable and valued as we did with Shellie. Will definitely be willing to recommend Shellie to friends and family (we already have given glowing recommendations). Felt like a true local business interaction should. We got the sense that Shellie was interested in preserving and encouraging the growth of the wonderful Malanda community. As a family with young children we are thankful that Shellie found us a new home. Thanks Shellie, we appreciate our buying experience with you and your team.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
Shellie is an experienced and professional Agent. Has great Market knowledge & communication skills
over 2 years ago
Shellie is an experienced and professional Agent. Has great Market knowledge & communication skills

Thank you Shellie for your professionalism in selling our parents' home. Shellie kept us, as a family, informed at all times and was readily available to answer our questions and address our concerns. She was considerate in arranging timelines to fit in with us, and concerned and respectful of our parents.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
Simple and straight forward
over 2 years ago
Simple and straight forward

When we engaged Shellie to sell our property, she told us that she already had a couple of families looking for a home, and asked if we'd mind if she took a couple through the place the following day. Of course not. They were satisfied enough that they made an offer on the spot. Shellie led us through all the legal pitfalls - so much has changed since we bought the place - and made everything flow pretty smootly. She was quick to make adjustments to the contract as requested by either party, and was passed on any questions without delay. We wouldn't hesitate to recommend her to anyone looking to sell a property for a good price and with alacrity.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Buyer review
Simply the best!
over 2 years ago
Simply the best!

Shellie was amazing from beginning to end. We really liked her honest, caring approach & combined with her knowledge of the local area, made her the perfect choice for our real estate needs. We will be forever grateful to Shellie for helping us secure our new home in Malanda & would have no hesitation in recommending her to take care of your real estate needs.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
5 stars all the way
over 2 years ago
5 stars all the way

We continuously use Shelly with our property purchases and sales. There is a reason why we haven’t needed to look elsewhere and that because for us Shelly is the only agent we need. Professional and efficient. See you on the next ones Shelly!!

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Buyer review
Great service
over 2 years ago
Great service

Shellie made the purchase of our house very easy and we felt very supported through the process. Fantastic service. Would highly recommend. Communication was excellent and she was very professional.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
Seller review
Fantastic Service
over 2 years ago
Fantastic Service

Fantastic service from Shellie. Nothing was too difficult. She is professional, approachable and a pleasure to do business with.

Shellie Nightingale

Shellie Nightingale

  4.9   (461 reviews)
157 - 168 of 176
Nightingale Real Estate Tablelands
Contact Nightingale Real Estate Tablelands
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent