Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
496 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: pleasant, friendly, reliable, responsive, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Knowledgeable and honest agent
almost 7 years ago
Knowledgeable and honest agent

Michael made the usually difficult process of selling a property simple. His honesty and responsiveness ensured that the sale progressed smoothly, from the initial stages of finding a buyer to assisting us with local contacts and advice. I would highly recommend Michael to anyone thinking of selling their property on the Peninsula.

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
Buyer review
Rye Beach House
almost 7 years ago
Rye Beach House

Michael has been extremely helpful and friendly assisting us in the purchase of a lovely Rye property. He was very professional and prompt in responses to queries we had. We would definitely recommend him.

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent service and updating of progress
almost 7 years ago
Excellent service and updating of progress

We found that Michael's knowledge of the real estate market and his professional approach to the sale of our property was superb. We cannot speak highly enough of our experience

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
Seller review
First Class Service.
almost 7 years ago
First Class Service.

Our small cottage in Rye was no million dollar property but it was treated like one by Michael and the team from Prentice's. It was neat and tidy and was presented honestly and enthusiastically by the agent to the section of the market that was recommended to us. A fair price, for us and the buyer, was achieved without any fuss and within a very reasonable time.

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
Buyer review
Total professional, knowledgeable and helpful
almost 7 years ago
Total professional, knowledgeable and helpful

Mike provided us with a high level of service when he assisted us with this purchase. Always friendly, and available to help answer queries, and faultless in following through with everything he said he’d do. Thanks again for your great work.

Michael Prentice

Michael Prentice

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Buyer review
Pleasant to deal with, but a couple of issues
almost 7 years ago
Pleasant to deal with, but a couple of issues

As a buyer, I found Michael approachable and easy to deal with. His running of the auction was good, and getting the deposit payment sorted and paperwork done was fast and efficient. He was accommodating in leaving the keys for cleaners, and left a nice little welcome package for us :) Missing a star because Michael did not get back to me during the week before the auction to answer a question I had asked during a scheduled inspection a week earlier (or at least tell me he'd tried but couldn't find the answer), so his service to me as a potential buyer was not as good as it could have been. There was also a costly problem with the hot water heater, which I only found out when I moved in to my new property and had no hot water - the pilot light wouldn't light, so I had to get a plumber round who ended up having to replace a part. ~$500 bucks added to the sale price :( While Michael had no obligation toward me, it would have been nice if he had checked with the vendors that all the basic utilities were functioning before settlement.

Michael Prentice

Michael Prentice

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Seller review
Communication Excellent
almost 7 years ago
Communication Excellent

Great advise and easy to work with during the process.

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
Buyer review
TRUSTING an agent with your budget and with your best interests at heart = Michael Christodoulou
almost 7 years ago
TRUSTING an agent with your budget and with your best interests at heart = Michael Christodoulou

Looking for property in Rye when we live more than an hour away and work weekends was difficult in the fact that timing for OFI was not always possible for us. Michael made it so easy for us to look at properties outside the ‘normal hours’ including times when it was surely Michael’s non work hours. He knew what we wanted and only showed us places that he knew would appeal, he knew our budget, he knew the locations that would be right for us. Phone calls, texts were replied to quickly, professionally and with knowledge. Michael’s experience made our experience more exciting and successful. Thank you Michael.

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
Seller review
Top Shelf Service
almost 7 years ago
Top Shelf Service

Michael Prentice has overseen the sale of our cottage in Rye in an efficient and professional manner that has achieved for us the price he advised would be acceptable to us, as well as being attractive to a prospective buyer. This sale was achieved promptly, dealing with us and prospective buyers in a courteous and caring way. Michael and the staff at Prentice Real Estate in Rye have been an absolute pleasure to deal with.

Michael Prentice

Michael Prentice

  4.9   (277 reviews)
Buyer review
Thank you Michael
almost 7 years ago
Thank you Michael

Michael was very pleasant to deal with and keep me well informed along the process of purchasing this property.

Michael Christodoulou

Michael Christodoulou

  4.9   (227 reviews)
349 - 360 of 496
© 2026 RateMyAgent