Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
104 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Best Practice Real Estate Agent
7 months ago
Best Practice Real Estate Agent

There are a huge number of real estate agents in Australia, but very few who can be called excellent in everything they do! Matt Carroll is one of them! From our first contact with him, he was professional, knowledgeable, warm and respectful. He listened closely to our expectations and then exceeded all of them! Ongoing communication was regular and informative ultimately leading to a successful sale of our property in Safety Beach at exactly the price level he told us to expect and in less time than the average days on market for the area. My wife and I strongly and unreservedly recommend Matt and his amazing team to anyone looking to buy or sell on the Mornington Peninsula!

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent Outcome - Sold after the first open house
8 months ago
Excellent Outcome - Sold after the first open house

I had been closely monitoring the market for months, and it was clear that properties with Scenic were selling faster than those listed by other agencies. Matt stood out as a real estate agent who genuinely understood the market, and his approach was refreshing and effective. From the beginning, Matt was incredibly honest about what he believed was a realistic sales price for my property. I appreciated that he didn’t promise inflated numbers like other agents. There was no hyperinflation of expectations – just clear, straightforward advice. His communication was excellent throughout the process. I always felt well-informed, and he was always available whenever I had questions or needed guidance. Thanks to Matt’s expertise, my property was sold after the very first open house. That speaks volumes about the combination of the right advice, realistic pricing, and effective marketing strategies that Matt brought to the table. I couldn’t have asked for a smoother, more successful sale. If you're looking for an honest, professional agent who delivers results, I highly recommend Matt and the team at Scenic Property!

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Buyer review
Great Service – Thank You, Matt
8 months ago
Great Service – Thank You, Matt

I recently bought a property with Matt’s help, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From day one, he showed outstanding professionalism, deep market knowledge, and a genuine commitment to securing the best outcome. What truly set Matt apart was his friendly and approachable nature—he made the entire journey feel straightforward and stress-free, keeping me well-informed and supported at every stage. He was consistently available to answer any questions and offered clear, practical advice throughout the process. I’d gladly recommend Matt to anyone looking for a reliable and personable real estate agent.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
We couldn’t be happier!
8 months ago
We couldn’t be happier!

Matt and his team were patient and supportive through the sale process. They provided valuable guidance on how much to do the property to best present it for sale. Property was sold within 24 hours on going on the market and we were more than happy with the price. We cannot speak highly enough of Matt Carrol and the team at Scenic Property

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Best Agent in Safety Beach if not on the Pen'
8 months ago
Best Agent in Safety Beach if not on the Pen'

Matt was a gun from start to finish. We knew we had the right agent when we met him after talking to the other Agents in the area and he never let us down - from his "take charge" approach, his advice to "trust the process" and the fact he just got the job done with zero drama. Matt knows the Safety Beach market better than anyone and his reputation here on the Pen' and beyond is second to none. If you don't use him, you will get a second rate result !

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Highly Recommend
8 months ago
Highly Recommend

Matt and his team were the perfect choice to sell our house, we went in hesitant, and they put our mind at ease. Matt has a great knowledge of the area and his team helped us prepare the house for Sale and to get the best outcome which we feel we achieved. Everything from the first meeting to the quick sale ran very smoothly and we couldn't be happier. Matt was very pleasant and easy to deal with and would Highly Recommend him

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Matt made selling our parents home easy and stress free
9 months ago
Matt made selling our parents home easy and stress free

We chose Matt to sell our parents home because he knows the Safety Beach area so well. He was an absolute pleasure to work with - professional, approachable & genuinely invested in the process. Thanks to his expertise and dedication, we achieved a fantastic price for the property in a short time. We couldn't be happier with the result.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Paradise in Safety Beach
9 months ago
Paradise in Safety Beach

Matt was exceptional with his prior knowledge of our house since we purchased the property off him 4 years ago. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience with all that was involved in selling. Thanks Matt!

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Matt and his team have exceptional market knowledge and are very professional.
9 months ago
Matt and his team have exceptional market knowledge and are very professional.

We had a very good experience working with Matt and his team from Scenic Property. They made selling our home stress free and we were contacted after each open day, they were constantly communicating with us until our house was sold.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Very professional
9 months ago
Very professional

Matt was amazing. Kept us very informed and sold our property within a week.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Highly Recommended
9 months ago
Highly Recommended

From the outset, it was clear that Matt was the ideal agent for us. His drive, expertise, and engaging approach made him a perfect fit. Throughout the process, communication was consistently excellent, characterised by open dialogue and a strong ability to adapt to any situation.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
Seller review
Area Expert
10 months ago
Area Expert

Matt's knowledge of the market in Safety Beach is second to none. He advises and sets realistic peice bands and works tirelessly to achieve the best outcome possible for the vendor.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (157 reviews)
13 - 24 of 104
© 2026 RateMyAgent