Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
110 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Definitely deserving of his awards!
about 2 years ago
Definitely deserving of his awards!

We intended to get 2 agents to appraise our home to sell, however we felt comfortable with Matt. He was able to provide facts & figures to substantiate his valuation. He sold our home within a week and made the process very easy. Deb & Lucy were friendly and extremely helpful during the sale process. We have sold 4 other homes, however Matt and his teams professionalism has given us our best experience. We have already recommended Scenic to protential sellers.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Epitome of excellence
about 2 years ago
Epitome of excellence

The highest level of communication, guidance and leadership was provided by Matt, Lucy and Deb and we could not be more grateful for the utmost care of the sale. This was more than a financial transaction for us with mixed emotions and Matt, Lucy and Deb navigated all queries and concerns in a timely manner. I would not hesitate to recommend them again and looking forward to welcoming them back into our families decision making for future transactions. When you find a good egg you hang onto it! This crew are the best out of a dozen!

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Easy quick sale
over 2 years ago
Easy quick sale

We asked 3 agents for an appraisal on our block of land. Matt responded within 4 hours with a fair and reasonable appraisal. He then quickly got the campaign ready before Australia Day weekend with drone shots and copy. Even with limited inquiry Matt got an interested party and negotiated them to our price. Excellent agent and would recommend.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Easy to deal with
over 2 years ago
Easy to deal with

Good knowledge about the area

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional and prompt
over 2 years ago
Professional and prompt

Matt was overseas in another timezone, but that didn't make any difference to the level of service he provided us. As for Lucy, she was very thorough and helpful as well.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Great experience, great result
over 2 years ago
Great experience, great result

Matt, Lucy and the team were excellent. From our initial meeting Matt and his team were professional, communicative and informative. We sold in 15 days and we’re delighted with the results and service. Great job thanks.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Secret Weapon
almost 3 years ago
Secret Weapon

Matt has a secret weapon that other agents don't. She is called Debbie. She saved me the need to employ a stylist and was supportive through the process. Matt also guided me through the negotiation process very skillfully. I have recommended Matt and Debbie to a friend who had not intended to use them and is now pleased that she did.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Efficient
almost 3 years ago
Efficient

Matt came to our home and described the process thoroughly and then went about applying all of the the agreed process Efficient effective as professional

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Buyer review
Purchasing my new home.
almost 3 years ago
Purchasing my new home.

Having sold my farm and looking to downsize I came across the perfect fit for me in Matt Carroll of Scenic listings. Initially my contact and inspections were with Deb Keating who I found to be informative and friendly. I was very keen to buy but due reasons beyond my control such as numerous extension requests from my purchaser I was unable to immediately honour my intentions . Matt Carroll was patient and understanding and worked with me and my agent to get the result I was after. He was courteous and friendly at all times during these tricky times.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
Extremely professional, knowledgeable and helpful, and an excellent result.
about 3 years ago
Extremely professional, knowledgeable and helpful, and an excellent result.

I couldn't rate Scenic Property highly enough for their professionalism, honesty, and helpfulness during the sale of my parent's home. Matt and Deb were available on the phone at all times, they demonstrated their extensive knowledge of the Mornington Peninsula property market by giving an honest and on-point appraisal of the house. They communicated what we should do in the lead up to putting it on the market, what external services to consider to refresh the house and even helped coordinate many of these services for us. The house was sold in a very short time frame and Matt worked hard to reach a very pleasing result for us. All paperwork at each stage was managed quickly and efficiently. I expected the house-selling process would be stressful for us, however they managed everything so professionally, and our family felt very supported throughout. I highly recommend Matt Carroll.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
Seller review
TOP NOTCH AGENT
about 3 years ago
TOP NOTCH AGENT

Thoroughly professional, personable and knowledgeable. Matt was proficient and helpful in every aspect of assessing my property and listing my property. His integrity and trustworthiness was very apparent, he's straight down the line. I couldn't recommend him more highly. House sold in under 10 days. Amazing. Thanks Matt and Deb.

Matt Carroll

Matt Carroll

  5   (163 reviews)
61 - 72 of 110
© 2026 RateMyAgent