Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
339 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Went above and beyond
11 months ago
Went above and beyond

Garth is very upfront and honest, and went above and beyond to make the purchase a smooth process for me. I am very grateful as a first home buyer to have had Garth’s expert assistance. If you need an agent, I would genuinely recommend him.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Seller review
Respectful, Honest & Patient — Garth Brennan Made a Difficult Sale Smooth
11 months ago
Respectful, Honest & Patient — Garth Brennan Made a Difficult Sale Smooth

When Garth Brennan took charge of selling my late mother’s unit as a deceased estate, he exhibited a level of thoughtfulness, patience, honesty and genuine warmth that went far beyond expectations. From the very start, Garth was incredibly respectful and thoughtful, understanding this was an emotionally vulnerable time. He carefully explained the legal steps, like obtaining probate and transferring the property, which gave me clarity and confidence. His patience shone through at every stage. Whether I had questions about paperwork, probate timelines, or property inspections, Garth answered with compassion and ensured I never felt rushed. He would revisit points multiple times until we were at ease. Garth’s honesty and transparency were invaluable. He provided straightforward advice on pricing and sale strategy, setting realistic expectations for timing and outcome. As a good bloke, Garth treated me with kindness and professionalism. He approached every conversation with empathy. In summary: Selling a deceased estate can be complex and emotional, but with Garth Brennan guiding me with thoughtfulness, patience, honesty and genuine care, it felt managed with dignity, clarity and support. I wholeheartedly recommend him to anyone to sell their property.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional
12 months ago
Exceptional

Peter and his team were professional and knowledgeable right from the start. We chose them because of their confidence of achieving a quick sale. Our family home sold in less than a week for a great price. They made the process very easy and kept us updated with every step. They were also very kind and genuine, like a friend selling your home.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent & personalised service.
12 months ago
Excellent & personalised service.

We trusted Shields+Co because of their excellent reputation in the real estate business, and they did not disappoint. Their reliability and expertise ensured a smooth and quick selling process while achieving a great result. Peter was very friendly, efficient, professional, and well-organized. He personalised our experience, taking the time to understand the uniqueness of our property, making the selling process very easy.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
Great agent
12 months ago
Great agent

Garth is easy to work with and responsive. He made the buying peasy.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Seller review
45 Hill Street Belmont
12 months ago
45 Hill Street Belmont

Peter showed his experience in every way in selling out property every open home was attended by Peter and his follow up with each client was efficient and professional I have no hesitation in recommending Peter to any future clients wishing to sell he will give 100% at all time I wish him well in his Real estate business Thanks once again Helen Moyle

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
Great negotiating skills
12 months ago
Great negotiating skills

Excellent negotiating skills and communication

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Great local knowledge
12 months ago
Great local knowledge

Peter and his staff were really easy to deal with and had great local knowledge. The house sold for a a fraction more than the top end of the price range. Very happy with the result.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
Good Experience
12 months ago
Good Experience

I bought a house with Garth as a buyer. He was helpful to deal with and able to organise a private inspection at short notice.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Buyer review
Fantastic,professional
12 months ago
Fantastic,professional

Pete Was a pleasure to deal with and had great insights into the local area and surrounding suburbs

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Garth gets results
12 months ago
Garth gets results

Garth is always focused on getting the best result for his client. Garth is professional, has deep understanding of the market and is a great communicator. Thank you Garth!

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Seller review
Natalie was Fabulous!
12 months ago
Natalie was Fabulous!

Natalie were fantastic! She was professional, courteous and caring; always taking the time to answer my many questions. The marketing on our property was top-notch. We had 35 groups through on our first open house and 5 offers! Natalie and Peter recommended going to auction as there had been so much interest in our home. It sold just over 2 weeks later. A great result. We couldn't be happier! Thank you Natalie 😊

Natalie Francis

Natalie Francis

  5   (35 reviews)
85 - 96 of 339
© 2026 RateMyAgent