Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
339 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, honest, supportive, friendly, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Highly Recommend!
12 months ago
Highly Recommend!

This is the second property we have sold with Peter @ Peter Sheils Real Estate and have had amazing service and outcomes both times. From the other side, we have also bought property through Peter & been extremely happy as well. Highly recommend this agency & fabulous staff 100%!

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
Genuine and reliable agent!
12 months ago
Genuine and reliable agent!

From the beginning, Garth was approachable and easy to reach. He was flexible with our needs and made sure to be at the property at times that suited us, which significantly reduced our stress. Garth is a sincerely helpful person who aims to assist you in buying a property—there are no hidden tricks or gimmicks involved. It was wonderful to have such a reliable agent like Garth while my wife and I were purchasing our first home. Thank you so much Garth, we truly appreciate your support!

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Buyer review
Very responsive
about 1 year ago
Very responsive

We were impressed by Peter's availability when we asked to view a property at short notice. He met us on site within the hour and it was a very positive experience. Peter was responsive and helpful with all our enquiries and throughout the sales process, offering a friendly yet well-informed and professional level of service

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Easy selling
about 1 year ago
Easy selling

Dealing with Pete was great He and Natalie were very down to earth with there approach and nothing was too much trouble, highly recommended

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent service, no pressure, clear communication, great result!
about 1 year ago
Excellent service, no pressure, clear communication, great result!

Peter and team were professional from start to finish. Peter has great knowledge of the local area, and his communication skills were outstanding. At no time did I feel pressured, and I really appreciated Peter's no bullsh*t approach. He kept me updated at all times and ensured I had all the knowledge I needed to make informed choices. Thank you again Peter and team ... fabulous result, it was a pleasure!

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Buyer review
Pleasure to deal with
about 1 year ago
Pleasure to deal with

Pete & Natalie are fantastic to deal with, honest, open and willing to help in any way they can.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
All very professional and friendly
about 1 year ago
All very professional and friendly

Good communication with what’s happening as far as people coming through and didn’t take long to sell.

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
He proves you only need one agent!
about 1 year ago
He proves you only need one agent!

Quite apart from Peter’s outstanding negotiating and marketing skills his real stand out quality is his rare moral compass in the industry. He epitomises honesty, integrity and trustworthiness. Truly a genuine human being you can rely on for a seemless, stress free and successful outcome for your property sale. Thank you with much appreciation Peter!

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
Seller review
100% the best agent in all aspects.
about 1 year ago
100% the best agent in all aspects.

We have just sold our 5th property through Andrew with the same fantastic results! We have also recommended him to family who have been equally impressed with the results he achieved for them. Andrew’s professional yet down to earth approach, his communication and negotiation skills with both sellers and buyers make the whole process easy. Just a lovely, trustworthy guy who gets results fast!

Andrew Smaus

Andrew Smaus

  4.9   (46 reviews)
Buyer review
Very Good
about 1 year ago
Very Good

Garth was very helpful & professional for us, having to travel 2.5hrs to the Hunter constantly looking at properties dealing with various agents was a little bit challenging. Finally we found what we needed and wanted. Garth was able to get our offer negotiated & accepted within 24hrs. We would definitely recommend Garth to other vendors & buyers 😊😊😊

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Buyer review
PROACTIVE AGENT
about 1 year ago
PROACTIVE AGENT

Garth has been a friendly and communicative agent on our behalf to purchase our new property in Chisholm. He went above and beyond to secure the necessary requirements for this purchase. At all times he was polite, timely and gave us great customer service. We thank him sincerely for his expertise and can recommend him if you are seeking a quality agent to purchase in the area.

Garth Brennan

Garth Brennan

  5   (44 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent result!
about 1 year ago
Excellent result!

I was selling a deceased estate and came across Peter when he gave me an appraisal. This was at a very challenging and emotional time having just lost my Father. The whole experience from beginning to end was great. I found Peter and his agency very professional and the communication was clear and key to this sale. Peter negotiated the best price on this home and in fact I received a better than expected result. This experience was so good that I asked Peter to give us an appraisal on our own home recently! I would definitely recommend Peter and his Team

Peter Shiels

Peter Shiels

  4.9   (377 reviews)
97 - 108 of 339
© 2026 RateMyAgent