Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
209 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
over 6 years ago
Exceptional customer service and great sales results

My partner and I have bought and sold four properties with with James Smyth and his team at Smyth Estate Agents. They say the best business is referral business and my experience with James, his sales colleague, John and the team at Smyth Estate Agents has been nothing short of exceptional. I had the experience of discussing my potential sales with other local agents. One such (unnamed) agency is quite large and, on face value, appears to have a high volume of successful sales. However, a closer analysis of some of those sales revealed that the prices achieved did not appear to be the best they could have been. I also had direct experience of the same agency under quoting and over quoting, in that the price I was quoted that they claimed they could achieve for my property was 'inflated' in an effort to get my business. I also saw the same agency 'underquote' to potential buyers in order to attract interest. This had the effect of artificially raising buyers expectations that properties may sell for a lower price, when in fact the properties sold for much more, which led to buyer frustration and disappointment. In contrast, James was conservative and realistic in his price guide. He provided a starting price to potential buyers and gave me a price range. During the sales process, James consistently advised that his aim was to achieve the best price possible for my properties. He assembled a thorough package of information on other sales in the area and market trends and then presented the information in such a way that enabled me to understand the basis for his appraisal. My properties were located in Freshwater and Manly. James has resided in the area for a lengthy period and his knowledge and familiarity with the area was obvious and of immense benefit to myself and I'm sure to buyers. I have also purchased a property through James, during which he also provided a high level of customer service and sound advice.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Exceptional customer service and great sales results

My partner and I have bought and sold four properties with with James Smyth and his team at Smyth Estate Agents. They say the best business is referral business and my experience with James, his sales colleague, John and the team at Smyth Estate Agents has been nothing short of exceptional. I had the experience of discussing my potential sales with other local agents. One such (unnamed) agency is quite large and, on face value, appears to have a high volume of successful sales. However, a closer analysis of some of those sales revealed that the prices achieved did not appear to be the best they could have been. I also had direct experience of the same agency under quoting and over quoting, in that the price I was quoted that they claimed they could achieve for my property was 'inflated' in an effort to get my business. I also saw the same agency 'underquote' to potential buyers in order to attract interest. This had the effect of artificially raising buyers expectations that properties may sell for a lower price, when in fact the properties sold for much more, which led to buyer frustration and disappointment. In contrast, James was conservative and realistic in his price guide. He provided a starting price to potential buyers and gave me a price range for my property. During the sales process, James consistently advised that his aim was to achieve the best price possible for my property. He assembled a thorough package of information on other sales in the area and market trends and then presented the information in such a way that enabled me to understand the basis for his appraisal. My properties were located in Freshwater and Manly. James has resided in the area for a lengthy period and his knowledge and familiarity with the area was obvious and of immense benefit to myself and I'm sure to buyers. I have also purchased a property through James, during which he also provided a high level of customer service and sound advice.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Great selling experience

James has my highest recommendation. Living in the area James has a profound appreciation of the area, the people and period homes. I had a great selling experience with James who is extremely hard working, working after hours to sell my house. He leads a positive team that are all committed to the local community. James has a very personal, friendly approach that you feel extremely comfortable and listened to. Every request or suggestion James acted upon immediately. James is reliable and kept me updated with the process at all times. I never had to chase him as James was always proactive and communicated regularly. I wouldn't hesitate in asking James to assist in the future.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Professional and knowledgeable excellent result

I have known James for over a decade & had no hesitation in choosing SEA when it came to selling my property. His knowledge of the local area & market made him the obvious choice to maximise the potential of the sale . This proved to be a wise choice as the sale was handled in a fast, smooth & highly professional manor. I have no hesitation in highly recommending James & his team at SEA wether you are selling or renting your property, as Rana does an excellent job of managing my rental properties. Thanks James

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Thanks for a great experience and outcome

We found our dealings with James and his colleague John very professional. They had the knowledge that was required regarding the property, kept us informed of how the sale would progress and were great to deal with through all of the steps of our being the successful purchasers of the property. We would not hesitate in recommending the agency of SEA Freshwater for your real estate needs.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Knows his stuff

James always returned our calls and answered our queries and requests promptly. He stuck to the plan we agreed on and we were happy with the result.He knows the locals and the area well and really knows his stuff. He gave advice but respected our views and did not push on things we did not want.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
FIRST CLASS

I FOUND DEALING WITH JAMES VERY EASY FROM START TO FINISHING FROM GREAT MARKETING TO AN EXCELLENT RESULT AT AUCTION

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Excellent Agent - 10/10

Thank you so much for helping secure the purchase of my apartment. Couldnt be happier with my purchase. James liaised swiftly between myself and the previous owners and made the sale within a week of the property going on the market. I was impressed. On top of his professionalism he is also a good bloke, trustworthy and easy to get along with. I would highly recommend anyone looking to sell or buy to engage James and take advantage of his wealth of knowledge in the property market. You will not regret it. Thank you James!

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Above and beyond

Having recently moved to NSW we were not familiar with the local property market. James took the time to talk open and honestly to us about the Northern beaches. His advice was invaluable. James also has a strong relationship with the seller and following the sale has continued to assist on every occasion allowing us early access to the property to do work. He has even introduced us to our new neighbors and provided contacts for local trades and businesses in the area. Our interactions with everyone on his team has been courteous and professional.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
James recently sold a family home for us in Freshwater

Our experience with James was as good as you can experience. James was professional and enthusiastic throughout the process, contacted us regularly and kept us up to date with all enquiries and inspections. he also took great initiative in the final negotiation process. We will not hesitate to use James again.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Perfect house sale experience

In April 2018, from overseas, I contacted James from SEA for an appraisal of our Freshwater house. I was immediately impressed with his local knowledge and professionalism, especially the trouble he went to presenting his report. When in August of this year, we made the decision to sell, we chose James and it was one of the best decisions of our life. James is DIFFERENT! Instead of over-promising, he under-promises, then over-delivers. His unique system, with styling and various trades, advertising and videos, as well as amazing data analysis techniques ensured we found the right buyer quickly (20 days), smoothly and at a great price. It is not that often one is truly delighted in life, but we were delighted by James work. SEA are winners.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
over 6 years ago
Seller of 4BR house in Freshwater

In April 2018, from overseas, I contacted James from SEA for an appraisal of our Freshwater house. I was immediately impressed with his local knowledge and professionalism, especially the trouble he went to presenting his report. When in August of this year, we made the decision to sell, we chose James and it was one of the best decisions of our life. James is DIFFERENT! Instead of over-promising, he under-promises, then over-delivers. His unique system, with styling and various trades, advertising and videos, as well as amazing data analysis techniques ensured we found the right buyer quickly (20 days), smoothly and at a great price. It is not that often one is truly delighted in life, but we were delighted by James work. SEA are winners.

James Smyth

James Smyth

  4.9   (209 reviews)
85 - 96 of 209
© 2026 RateMyAgent