Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 131 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent service - highly recommended.
about 10 years ago
Excellent service - highly recommended.

When it came time to sell my Fathers house, I met several agents and had formal proposals with two. Peter's proposal was slightly more expensive, but the service he provided, before and during the sales campaign was excellent. He dealt with the existing tenants to ensure they were supportive and kept me informed regularly on campaign progress. I was very happy with the sales result too. I would definitely use him again if I was selling a house in the bayside area.

Seller review
Highet Property Sale Feb 2016
about 10 years ago
Highet Property Sale Feb 2016

Peter is a professional, personable Agent who designed and delivered a suburb property campaign and subsequent sale. He kept us informed at every stage and expertly guided to an auction and a very pleasing outcome. I warmly recommend Peter to anyone selling (or buying) in Bayside.

Seller review
Proactive and Professional
over 10 years ago
Proactive and Professional

We were very impressed with Peter during the sale process. He put in a lot of hard work to get us the best result for our sale and went over and above the level of service I expected. He was proactive in following up potential buyers and we achieved sale before auction at a price we were very happy with. I believe Peter worked extremely hard for this result. He managed our expectations and was realistic throughout the process. He was professional and reliable throughout the process. We will recommend him to others in future.

Seller review
Very Helpful and Very Professional
over 10 years ago
Very Helpful and Very Professional

We found Peter excellent to deal with. Never a problem always proactive and very Professional to deal with. Highly recomended.

Seller review
Grab Property Group - Aurelio De Santis (Director)
over 10 years ago
Grab Property Group - Aurelio De Santis (Director)

I have used Peter on a number of properties i have built and sold throughout Bayside. Pete has helped me achieved great results not just in strong markets but more importantly in weak also which is the mark of a good agent. I would have no hesitation in recommending Pete to any vendor and look forward to working with him in the future.

Seller review
Peter Hickey (you deserve more than 5 stars)!
over 10 years ago
Peter Hickey (you deserve more than 5 stars)!

Peter Hickey helped Andrew and I sell our home in December this year. He was amazing to work with and was extremely patient. We run our own business (December is one of our busiest months) and Peter was available at the craziest times to answer questions or to discuss the progress of our sales campaign. He provided weekly updates via telephone calls and email, so that we knew how our open houses were progressing. Two days before our auction he met with us and went through what was going to take place on the day and again on the day of auction, Peter gave us an overview of how the day would go. This really helped manage our expectations (and my stress levels). Everything went to “plan” and we sold our home at auction for an amount that we were extremely happy with. Thank you so much Peter, Patrick and everyone at Buxton’s who helped with the sale of our property. Andrew and I highly recommend Peter to anyone selling (or buying) a property. Simone Jones PS. Oh and Peter the flowers bloomed the day after auction :) 

Seller review
Peter Hickey is a very professional real estate agent.
over 10 years ago
Peter Hickey is a very professional real estate agent.

Peter Hickey sold my house recently. During the selling period Peter communicated openly and clearly with me and kept me informed at every stage. He is a skilled communicator. When we did not agree on certain issues he listened me and offered alternatives when necessary. Peter is a good listener. During open house inspections he always came to property himself to talk to the buyers face to face. He is an energetic salesman. Peter put in a lot of afford to sell my house and sold it successfully. Thanks Peter.

Seller review
Sale of 10 Waverly St, Sandringham
over 10 years ago
Sale of 10 Waverly St, Sandringham

Peter was open, honest and kept us well informed throughout the pre-sale, auction and sales processes. He was always on time and met all commitments made to us. He provided advise about the requirements for presenting our home well and was able to answer all our queries and questions satisfactorily along the way. We felt he was working hard to get the best price for us.

Seller review
Pleased in every respect
over 10 years ago
Pleased in every respect

From our initial contact with Peter, his professionalism and ability to act on opportunities were evident. Throughout our campaign Peters communication was always timely, thorough and positive in what can be a stressful time. His market knowledge and experience of the area meant he was able to find the right buyer for our home. I would highly recommend Peter to anyone thinking of selling in the Bayside area. Dave

Seller review
If you want the best for the Sandringham area?
over 10 years ago
If you want the best for the Sandringham area?

I had done an online investigate of realtor in general and had an idea of what the span of commissions were at that time. I came to Peter Hickey due to a recommendation by my neighbor and my financial adviser. When I ask Peter about his commission, he responded that I could get a lower commission percentage from others, but if I wanted someone who knows the local market and are good at what they do, then he would be the one to go with. Confident. You bet, and with good reason. He did exactly what he said he would do, and his estimate for other costs was with in $3.00. He did a lot of hand holding with me. Peter is reassuring and honest thru the whole process from beginning to after the auction. Best I can say about someone is that they are a good person.

Seller review
Dream Real Estate Agent
over 10 years ago
Dream Real Estate Agent

I have had over three decades dealing with Real Estate Agents, from investing to my own personal properties, so feel qualified in my assessment. Peter, from the outset appeared to be a well informed and likeable personality (I interviewed three agents for the sale of my property). I had never met Peter before, so trusted my previous knowledge, and intuition. Peter was so efficient, ran a great campaign, and achieved a fabulous result for me. One of the most wonderful aspects of Peter is his caring and compassionate manner, a truly decent human being, (I lost my husband two years ago, though I am a very independent person, it has been very challenging, and he was only in his fifties). I told Peter a few days prior to Auction, I would gladly have given him a glowing testimonial then and there, no matter what the result was, in all these years of investing I have never said that to any agent ! I not only achieved my reserve, then an amount I would have been extremely happy with, way beyond that. I am still in shock (pleasantly !!) Bernie Anniss

Seller review
Peter Hickey
over 10 years ago
Peter Hickey

The sale of ones family home is an emotional time whatever the circumstances and I was most impressed with Peter’s human side in this regard. He showed great compassion and professionalism in dealing with difficult circumstances. Peter made the whole process as painless as possible with minimal stressed. He has great communication skills and always followed up each house open with good feedback. His focus was to get me the best possible price and he certainly delivered on this. I was very very pleased with the outcome. I would not hesitate to recommend Peter at Buxton. He genuinely is a really nice friendly person.

109 - 120 of 131
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent