Peter's profile

Peter's reviews

  4.9  
Peter has 131 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Peter's qualities as told by our client reviews: hard-working, supportive, detail-oriented, reliable, honest, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Vincent St Sandringham Sale
over 10 years ago
Vincent St Sandringham Sale

We found Peter to be very professional, thorough and well informed. It was a very successful marketing campaign with great communication and follow-up. We were very happy with the outcome and would not hesitate to recommend Peter Hickey. Leanne & Robin Sandringham

Seller review
Achieved a great result
over 10 years ago
Achieved a great result

Peter has always kept us up to date on the market over the years we have known, so when it came time to sell the decision was easy on who to choose. The decision was the right one. We set a dream price that we wanted to achieve and Peter didn't bat an eyelid in trying to achieve that price. In the end despite the property passing in at auction Peter successfully achieve our dream price through negotiation with the party it passed into and at no point suggested we should move from our price! The outcome that Peter achieved was exactly what we wanted and he didn't stray from achieving that! I would recommend using Peter to anyone!

Seller review
Professional service
almost 11 years ago
Professional service

I have been buying, selling, renting out properties for 40 years, often a disappointing experience. However, Peter was a pleasure to deal with, excellent knowledge and communication skills, honest assessment of likely result and good administration of the total process. The best agent I have ever dealt with. I would recommend him to anyone wanting to buy or sell in Bayside.

Seller review
Great negotiator
almost 11 years ago
Great negotiator

Peter is very experienced and understands buyer motivations. He is also persistent and maintains composure under pressure.

Seller review
Exceptional service from the initial meeting to the end!
almost 11 years ago
Exceptional service from the initial meeting to the end!

Peter provided an exceptional service from the initial meeting, discussing all the options and explaining the process all the way through the market days and updates from each to the actual auction day and getting the best possible price as the auctioneer!

Seller review
Satisfaction
almost 11 years ago
Satisfaction

Hi Just a short note to express my appreciation for Peter's efforts. Peter was tremendous not just during the course of the campaign but also over the last four years or so. You kept in constant contact with me providing advice without pressuring me to sell. In addition, both Shana and I were very appreciative of the considerate manner in which you dealt with our tenants which are also friends of ours. Please feel free to pass my details onto anyone you are dealing with if they wish to speak to some one as a reference.

Seller review
Peter Hickey
almost 11 years ago
Peter Hickey

Outstanding experience from the start, would not have any hesitations in recommending Peter Hickey to anyone who is in the market to buy or sell. Thanks Peter for your impeccable professional service.

Seller review
The sale of our home in Hampton
over 11 years ago
The sale of our home in Hampton

As you all know preparing your home for sale is a difficult process. Well having Peter as our representative during the hole process made the hole event a lot easier, in fact it made it enjoyable. He handled the hole process wonderfully, with a professional manner from start to end. Peter used his experience, local knowledge and hard working attitude to obtain us with the best result. If i find myself in the position again that i require to sell a home in the residential area that Peter works not only would i list it with Buxton i would demand Peter be the be the Sales Consultant. Peter also made us feel very comfortable at Buxton, he introduced us to all his office counterparts and made feel very welcome when we had drop in visits to his office...i hope we didn't put out Peter. We also had wonderful comments from the other staff from Buxton including Mark Earle.. Thank you Mark. Buxton have a fantastic salesperson in Peter, he is great at his job. Friendly honest and reliable. Thank you again.. Peter Kind regards Brett White

Seller review
Great result...thank you Peter!
almost 12 years ago
Great result...thank you Peter!

We engaged Peter Hickey to sell our property in Sandringham and were very pleased with the result. Peter is a knowledgable, professional and courteous agent who we would happily use again. We have referred Peter to family and friends, and he has helped them achieve great results too. Keep up the good work Peter! Thank you to you and the Buxton team.

Seller review
Michelle O'Donnell
almost 12 years ago
Michelle O'Donnell

We had originally purchased a property through Peter, and given our experience through the purchase process we decided to select Peter to sell our property as well. I couldn't recommend him highly enough as I believe him to be credible and respectful individual to deal with. It is quite nerve racking and stressful being on both ends of the property purchase and Peter made the process as easy as it could possibly be. He has a warm and friendly manner and excellent communication/contact skills to facilitate a stress free purchase and sale. Thanks again Peter for all your help and the fantastic result we received! Regards, Michelle and Liam O'Donnell

Seller review
Peter Hickey Realestate Agent Testimonial
almost 12 years ago
Peter Hickey Realestate Agent Testimonial

When I was faced with the need to sell my house, and having had little experience with the sale of realestate, I was also faced with the need to select a Realestate Agent. I knew that a friend, George, had sold his house, and had purchased a block of land, on which he had recently built a lovely new house. Hearing of my quandary, George suggested that I consider asking Buxton Realestate Agent, Peter Hickey, to sell my house. After meeting with Peter, and spending some time considering concerning experiences with a few other Agents, I decided to meet Peter, with George, at the Sandringham Offices of Buxton, where Peter laid out his strategy for marketing my house. While it sounded quite optimistic, Peter assured us that this strategy was sound, and he successfully dealt with a few concerns that we raised. At this time, I decided to go with Peter, and have been very happy that I made this choice. Peter successfully sold my house at Auction, with the assistance of his very competent Auctioneer, Mark, for a figure that far exceeded my highest expectations. I am very happy to say that the Sale proceeded as Peter expected, and there have been no post-Auction problems. I must say that Peter was very careful to clarify potential ambiguities, both for me, and potential purchasers, before these could become problems. Bernard Wilson

121 - 131 of 131
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent