Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
423 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Skeptical Sellers meet Super Salesman
over 6 years ago
Skeptical Sellers meet Super Salesman

We interviewed four agents and eventually decided on Jay. We liked O’Brien Real Estate’s broad coverage in the Endeavour Hills area, and we thought Jay presented as a good salesman and negotiator. Jay is energetic, positive, passionate and he gets things done. In the initial stages, photos and advertising got finished very quickly. Real Estate would be a demanding career and Jay seems to have the right personality for it. I had researched prices in the area and I thought Jay’s appraisal was reasonable. He wasn’t inflating the price to get our business. Jay or Shenay called us after every open, and Jay contacted us regularly during the week with updates on interested buyers. Jay conducted negotiations between multiple buyers, and we accepted an impressive offer which we were happy with. The sale fell through because the buyer was unable to sort their finance (No one’s fault- these things happen sometimes) and Jay then negotiated the sale with one of the buyers whose offer we had previously rejected. Something to be aware of is that O’Briens conduct 20 minute open for inspections, and leave a 20 minute gap before their next one - whereas most agents use a 30 minute schedule. However we didn’t see this as a big issue. Regardless of which agent you choose, I recommend you take ownership of the sale process- make suggestions, ask questions. Jay was always happy to answer ours. We were happy with Jay and Shenay's efforts selling our property, and would strongly recommend them to you.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Achieved results
over 6 years ago
Achieved results

Very professionally, knows what he's doing, great to work with. Property sold in 2 weeks!

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Smooth, Calm and Easy! Jay and the team at O'Brien
over 6 years ago
Smooth, Calm and Easy! Jay and the team at O'Brien

Throughout the whole process Jay and team communicated with us at every step of the way and were always available to us when we needed them. I highly recommend Jay & his team. Professional all the way.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Undoubtedly the best realtor in Endeavour Hills
over 6 years ago
Undoubtedly the best realtor in Endeavour Hills

We listed our home with Jay some time ago and we were not able to sell in the first instance. However based on professional and courteous conduct of Jay we listed our home again after nearly a year for the second time with him and just sold the property through him. We found him to be very punctual, organised and honest with his conduct which is contrary to perception of a real estate agent in general. My experience of selling our home through Jay was a positive and seamless (to great extent). We would certainly choose him again if a need arise in the future without a hesitation.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Interactive, great communicator and excellant people skills
over 6 years ago
Interactive, great communicator and excellant people skills

Jay is probably one of the best agents I have utilised to sell a house. Ensured he kept in constant contact, communication was constant and his energy levels are of the chart. Had our house sold in a week with a price above our expectations

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Jay Giblett.
over 6 years ago
Jay Giblett.

I have found Jay to be thorough and competent in his assessment of property, market knowledge, sales strategies, and availability to myself and both he and Shenay to prospective purchasers. His obvious love for what he does and confidence in his own knowledge and skills makes him a great choice.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Selling a house couldn’t be easier
over 6 years ago
Selling a house couldn’t be easier

While Jay’s exceptional market knowledge was instantly apparent, it was his application of this as well as incredible organisational skills that set him apart from other agents. A truly unique, worry free experience. Thank you Jay, for walking us through selling our much loved home, going above and beyond our expectations and delivering a wonderful outcome.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
We had a terrific experience and got a quick sale
almost 7 years ago
We had a terrific experience and got a quick sale

We were really impressed with Jay’s enthusiasm and market knowledge. His ability to keep us updated on the whole process removed a lot of the stress. Being able to achieve the sale within 2 weeks of listing was great.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Jay knows the market and he does everything for both the buyer & seller
almost 7 years ago
Jay knows the market and he does everything for both the buyer & seller

he knows his property market very well was a pleasure he kept us posted on everything from start to finish would definitely recommend him to family & friends interested in selling we were lucky to find him

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent, professional service
almost 7 years ago
Excellent, professional service

Both Jay and Shenay provided a very attentive and professional service throughout the process of selling our home. We were kept well informed at all times. Their enthusiasm and expertise made the whole process stress free for us. We would not hesitate to recommend them.

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
Seller review
Absolute legend
almost 7 years ago
Absolute legend

I am recommending Jay and Shanay to anyone who is looking to place there home on the market, you would be absolutely crazyyyyy if you don't Jay, you are honest and professional from the minute you stepped into my home, unbelieveable and correct knowledge of prices in this current market and area I can never thank you and Shanay enough for assisting myself through this, normally stressful time, with great patience and ease Thank you both Diana

Jay Giblett

Jay Giblett

  4.9   (405 reviews)
265 - 276 of 423
Area Specialist Jay & Shenay
Contact Area Specialist Jay & Shenay
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent