Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
910 reviewsacross 41 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, local expert, supportive, well-prepared, friendly, responsive, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Tenant review
Professional, Responsive and Reliable Property Management Team
4 months ago
Professional, Responsive and Reliable Property Management Team

I’ve had a very positive experience with the team at McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management. From the beginning, they have been professional, organised, and extremely responsive to any queries or concerns. Communication has always been clear and timely, whether it was regarding routine inspections, maintenance requests, or general updates. Any issues were handled efficiently and with genuine care, which gave me confidence that the property was being managed responsibly. What stood out most was their proactive approach and attention to detail. They made the entire process smooth and stress-free, and it’s clear they value both landlords and tenants. I would highly recommend McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management to anyone looking for a reliable and professional property management team.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
No proper communication or professional service at all!!
4 months ago
No proper communication or professional service at all!!

Very disappointed with the service from this agency. We have been requesting multiple maintenance issues to be addressed since December, through phone calls, emails, condition report, and follow-ups, yet nothing has been properly resolved.Responses are extremely slow, and once in a blue moon Tegan (the said property manager) replies. Every time I ask for feedback, I am told “it’s on tapi” or that they are “requesting quotes.” However, the status never changes beyond that. When I try to call, she is always “busy,” and there is no proper communication or accountability. The front gate is literally falling apart and we had to put a concrete block so it doesn’t collapse on ourselves or the vehicles, the rails of fence are cracked due to the neighbour’s dogs (should be Rottweilers), there is no proper lock on the gate, and there is absolutely no sense of security. These are serious safety concerns that have been ignored for months. We are currently seeking advice from Consumer Affairs regarding this matter. Extremely disappointed with the lack of action and professionalism. Do not recommend at all.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Excellent
4 months ago
Excellent

Jasmine and Sarah from McGrath made the process of applying for and moving into our rental so easy. They were great to communicate with through out the process and went out of their way to get a move in date that suited us even though it put them under time pressure. I would highly recommend Jasmine and Sarah for property management services.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Impeccable
4 months ago
Impeccable

We had a fantastic experience working with McGrath to find our first rental in Geelong. The team was incredibly professional, responsive, and made the entire application process feel seamless. We especially appreciated how clearly they communicated every step of the way. Highly recommend them to anyone looking for a stress-free move!

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Review for McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management
4 months ago
Review for McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

I had such a great experience with the team at McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management for 23/259 Bellerine Street. From the beginning, they were friendly, approachable, and easy to communicate with. They always responded quickly and made the whole process feel simple and stress-free. I really appreciated how supportive and helpful they were whenever I had questions. It was honestly a pleasure dealing with them, and I’m very happy with the service I received. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable and professional property management team in Geelong. Thank you again for all your help! Athip

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Perfect service
4 months ago
Perfect service

Highly professional issues resolved in a timely manner great communication

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
professionalism
4 months ago
professionalism

Megan's patience, professionalism, enthusiasm, and sense of responsibility as a manager

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Professional and Helpful Property Management
4 months ago
Professional and Helpful Property Management

I had a positive experience renting through McGrath Geelong | Newtown. The team was professional, responsive, and easy to communicate with throughout the tenancy. They handled inspections, maintenance, and the vacate process in a clear and organised manner. Thank you to the team for your assistance.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Landlord review
Very professional
5 months ago
Very professional

Good communication by the agent. Was provided regular updates. Agent was very professional.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Outstanding Support and Professional Service
5 months ago
Outstanding Support and Professional Service

I’d like to sincerely thank Jasmine Jerez from McGrath Estate Agents Newtown for her outstanding support with our application. She handled everything quickly, professionally, and with great communication throughout the process. Truly appreciate how smoothly she managed everything for us. Highly recommended.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Excellent
5 months ago
Excellent

We recently rented a house through McGrath and had such a positive experience thanks to Jasmine. She was always kind, approachable, and quick to respond to any questions we had. She made the whole process easy and comfortable for us. Thank you, Jasmine, for your help and support!

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
37 - 48 of 910
McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management
Contact McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent