Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
915 reviewsacross 41 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: stress-free process, local expert, supportive, well-prepared, friendly, responsive, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Tenant review
professionalism
6 months ago
professionalism

Megan's patience, professionalism, enthusiasm, and sense of responsibility as a manager

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Professional and Helpful Property Management
6 months ago
Professional and Helpful Property Management

I had a positive experience renting through McGrath Geelong | Newtown. The team was professional, responsive, and easy to communicate with throughout the tenancy. They handled inspections, maintenance, and the vacate process in a clear and organised manner. Thank you to the team for your assistance.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Landlord review
Very professional
6 months ago
Very professional

Good communication by the agent. Was provided regular updates. Agent was very professional.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Outstanding Support and Professional Service
6 months ago
Outstanding Support and Professional Service

I’d like to sincerely thank Jasmine Jerez from McGrath Estate Agents Newtown for her outstanding support with our application. She handled everything quickly, professionally, and with great communication throughout the process. Truly appreciate how smoothly she managed everything for us. Highly recommended.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Excellent
6 months ago
Excellent

We recently rented a house through McGrath and had such a positive experience thanks to Jasmine. She was always kind, approachable, and quick to respond to any questions we had. She made the whole process easy and comfortable for us. Thank you, Jasmine, for your help and support!

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Landlord review
Poor communication, lack of oversight and attention to detail
6 months ago
Poor communication, lack of oversight and attention to detail

I would like to provide formal feedback regarding my experience with McGrath’s management of my rental properties, as the service has consistently fallen below the standard I expect. Communication has been particularly disappointing. In many instances, I have had to follow up multiple times just to get basic updates or responses that should have been proactively provided. When I call the office, the tone from staff often feels impatient or annoyed, without acknowledgment that the only reason I am calling again is because my previous calls or messages were not returned—sometimes for one to two weeks. Additionally, there seems to be a lack of oversight and attention to detail regarding the landlord requirements. This further contributes to a sense that my properties are not being managed with the level of care and professionalism that I am expecting. I need to see a significant improvement in communication, responsiveness, and overall management. As a landlord, I expect timely updates, proactive handling of issues, and a respectful, professional tone in all interactions.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Exceptional Experience with McGrath
6 months ago
Exceptional Experience with McGrath

Our beginning in Australia couldn’t have been better. The McGrath team provided outstanding support in helping us settle into our new home, from handling all the paperwork to always being kind and helpful over the phone. We are very grateful for their professionalism and care, and the house is wonderful. Thank you, and congratulations on the great work you do.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Landlord review
This is a very professional team who definitely know what both tenants and landlords need.
6 months ago
This is a very professional team who definitely know what both tenants and landlords need.

This agent is very responsive to tenants requests for repairs. As a landlord I appreciate this as it serves to help the tenants feel valued and also ensures that the property is kept in good order. A good working relationship between tenant, landlord and agent is beneficial for all parties and an agent who knows this is invaluable. I am very pleased with the property app that I have been given access to. It provides me, at a glance, with details of rent payments, repair requests, costs and resolution. It also allows me to access all of the documents associated with renting out a property. This will be very handy for taxation purposes. I would recommend McGrath and its property managers to tenants and landlords alike.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Landlord review
Very professional, communicative and thorough
6 months ago
Very professional, communicative and thorough

I had a great experience handing over my property management to McGrath. Sally explained in detail, all the step by step activities that need to be done to advertise the property, the related costs involved, property compliance as per the legislation etc. The conversations were clear and transparent. Thereafter the leasing process and finally handing it over to the PM was all smooth and seamless, I was updated at every stage. I must say after dealing with couple of othe property management agencies in the past, you can clearly feel the difference with McGrath. I had called them initially as they showed no. 1 in rate my agent and they surely live up to the expectation.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
McGrath is the best
6 months ago
McGrath is the best

I am extremely happy with the Service.They were very supportive and made it easy for us to get accommodation.I will forever be grateful.Mcgrath Geelong are very professional.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Tenant review
Very professional
6 months ago
Very professional

The arrangement of the rent was very professional.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
Landlord review
Sublime service from start to finish
6 months ago
Sublime service from start to finish

Excellent experience from start to finish - starting with Sally who offered an extremely personal and competitive service and most importantly was open to negotiation, then Krishna who was able to secure tenants quickly and at very competitive rates, and finally Sarah who has taken to looking after the property and managing it as her own. Could not be more impressed by the overall landlord experience with the team at McGrath Geelong so far.

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management

  5   (2 reviews)
49 - 60 of 915
McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management
Contact McGrath Geelong | Newtown Property Management
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent