Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
502 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Absolute Professional, Personable, Knowledgeable and Great Agent

Paul has an outstanding knowledge of the Bayside real estate market landscape. He makes a point of building a great rapport and understanding both the seller and potential buyer requirements. No question was too trivial and always answered promptly. Paul provides open and honest communication, builds trust and helps provide calmness when purchasing a property can be stressful and emotional. Thank-you, Paul.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
almost 3 years ago
Unbeatable agent!

Noel was absolutely fantastic in assisting us with the purchase of our property. He went above and beyond in terms of always being available to meet/chat, making the process so seamless for us. This was especially appreciated since we were expecting a baby at the time (hence the delay in getting to write this!). He really did keep everything so stress free for us, and nothing was too much trouble. Highly recommend Noel and would look no further for an agent if required in the future.

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Highly Recommended

We recently sold our property in Hampton East with Paul and his team from Buxton. We got to know Paul as we bought the property through him, and he kept in touch with us and we built a good rapport with him. When it came to selling we were in no doubt that Paul and the Buxton team were the right fit for our family to sell our property. To add to the stress of selling our house, we had relocated to the UK, that didn't matter in the end as Paul was brilliant in setting up a WhatsApp group for us and kept us regularly updated on opens, website traffic and interested parties. Paul has a very open and trustworthy manner, knows the market and area extremely well, and I am very happy to recommend him to any prospective buyers or sellers to work with.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
about 3 years ago
great experience

Paul was brilliant. I was selling from interstate, he was so helpful with everything, always willing to do the things I was not able to. Got the price I wanted all within two weeks would highly recommend Paul and Buxtons RE

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Knowledge and Experience

Our sale was complex due to a development approved next door. Noel gave us a very professional presentation on what his agency offered and took us through many recent sales in the area. Based on this information he provided us with his estimate on what our home would fetch. It turned out to be spot on. He worked tirelessly opening the house 3 times a week and organising further viewings on request from potential buyers. I have no hesitation in recommending Noel, a very experienced, knowledgeable hard working agent.

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Good agent

Paul is very easy to deal with and he has all the contacts from styling, solicitor to gardener. one stop service. Recommended!

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
about 3 years ago
Great agent with prompt responses and communication

Paul and Natalie were both great, non pushy agents who responded quickly and accurately to all queries. So easy to deal with and great, honest communication is what you need when buying and both had it in spades. Made the buying experience so much less stressful.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Can't recommend Paul enough to sell your house!

Paul was a pleasure to work with when selling my house, very knowledgeable in his field and I felt like I could trust his opinion. He clearly has a high level of market knowledge and also has a very warm nature. He kept me informed every step of the way to the point I didn't have many questions. I knew what was occurring and when. And he sold our house. I can't recommend him enough to anyone wanting to sell their house.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Warm and friendly

It has been great working with Paul through the purchase of my property. He is very easy to deal with, professional, warm and very approachable and responsive, answering any queries I had, following up quickly, and guiding me through the process. Would definitely work with him again.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Helpful , Professional and excellent knowledge of market.

Paul has been amazing in the whole journey of buying the house. He has been really helpful , professional and have really good knowledge of the market. His response to my emails and queries were quick and helpful in any way he could. Strongly recommend.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 3 years ago
We found Paul to be professional, personable and knowledgeable

Thank you Paul (and Natalie) for successfully selling our Moorabbin property on Saturday. You gave very good service and helped us with our (at times) difficult decision making. Very early on, we were made what turned out to be a superior buying offer (unfortunately for us these buyers bought elsewhere before our auction). You provided us with very good advice but did not try and overly pressure us into taking this offer and you respected that it was our decision to still proceed to auction. Of course we would have liked to have matched or bettered the early offer but we are satisfied that on the auction day we received current market price (and it was within your initial guidance range - you certainly know the local market well). Thank you again and it has been a pleasure dealing with you.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Very impressed with the whole selling process of my property

I am extremely happy with my experience of selling my home with Buxton Real Estate. My good friends recommended Paul at Buxton Hampton East to help sell my house & his expertise in the whole process was remarkable. The whole sale process went very smoothly, I couldn’t be happier. For anyone selling or buying don’t go any further than Buxton Real Estate.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
61 - 72 of 502
© 2026 RateMyAgent