Buxton Stonnington

92 Chapel Street, Prahran, VIC, Australia 3181
  •   4.9   (17 reviews)

Meet the team

Get to know the 5 property managers at Buxton Stonnington.

Rae Tolley
Rae Tolley

Head of Property Management

raet@buxton.com.au
About Rae
Rae’s solid foundation for both personal loyalty and professional excellence fortifies her position as department manager of the Property Management division. Her former life in running her own business within the retail sector, comprising of both administrative and customer focused initiatives, evolved Rae’s standard to duty of care and has earned her leadership as head of the rental team. Since appointed govern, Rae directly oversaw Buxton’s property management portfolio develop from a humble 120 listings to more than 2000. Such groundwork contributes now to Buxton’s exponential growth, represented by both fiscal sustainability and reputable quality. Rae’s diplomatic, analytical and practical resolve to all situations concerning the consistency of care delivered by all staff in conjunction to the uninhibited function of the rental team as a unit, accompanied by the compassionate and rational support she devotes to everyone, ensures the allegiance and commitment of each property manager under her charge and replicates the same respect and devotion as a team and as individuals. Never one to divide the importance between owner and tenant, Rae’s equal measure of service awards all clientele the consideration and attention to customer care that endorses Buxton’s blue-ribbon history and proven quality time and again.
Bo Natoli
Bo Natoli

Senior Property Manager

bon@buxton.com.au
About Bo
Upon first meeting Bo, it is evident that her effervescent nature is on par with her professional and practical approach to Property Management. Prior to the entering the real estate sector, Bo spent several years in the retail and beauty industry, acquiring extensive experience in customer relations, ensuring that presentation – in all forms – is key. Dedicating her time in roles from administration to sales, Bo illustrates her all-encompassing skills in procedure and customer care that take pride of place within Buxton and the Real Estate industry. Whether it be the overall presentation of a new listing, the coordination of a property’s marketing campaign or the ongoing maintenance of an established tenancy, Bo’s diligence is one to be trusted in upholding Buxton’s quest for excellence. Outside the hustle and bustle of Real Estate’s insatiable market place, Bo enjoys applying the latest beauty trends, embarking on yearly visits to China, cheering on the Sydney Swans and sharing a home cooked meal with friends and family, all cherished past times that complete the work/life balance.
Suzette Tayler
Suzette Tayler

Senior Property Manager

suzzettet@buxton.com.au
About Suzette
With more than 20 years’ experience and a trusted reputation built on personal integrity, trust, loyalty and accomplishment, Suzette now brings to Buxton a fresh perspective with longevity of vocation as a guide. During her tenure throughout the Real Estate sector, Suzette has a history of civic duty, alongside the duty of care she exhibits on a daily basis, having been elected a local council member and has sat on various Committees and Advisory Boards over a ten-year period. Such appointment offers Suzette the advantage to understand all aspects of Property Management, with demonstrated experience of representing Landlords, Tenants, Owner’s Corporations and Council welfare interests. The point of difference that compels Suzette to pursue her career in Property Management is the diversity each day invites and the relationships she builds between Landlords and Tenants, alike. In her free time, Suzette finds joy in simple pleasures, immersing herself in nature with beach walks and, when the seas are clear for sailing, indulges in nautical pursuits with her love of boating. Outside of sea-faring adventures, Suzette is happiest most in her time she dedicates to charity work and the cherished time spent with her beautiful children and grandchildren.
Kimberley Drew
Kimberley Drew

Senior Property Manager

kimberleyd@buxton.com.au
About Kimberley
Growing up in Emerald and Phillip Island, Kim began working in Real Estate at Phillip Island in 2011 before moving to Melbourne to further her career in Property Management. She has experience as a Leasing Consultant and Assistant Property Manager, Property Manager, Senior Property Manager and Business Development Manager. Outside the Real Estate Industry Kim has experience in Safe Working on the railway and in Drug and Alcohol Rehabilitation. She is currently studying a dual Certificate 4 in AOD (Alcohol and Other Drugs) and Mental Health. Having previously worked with our agency from 2015 to 2018 as a Property Manager, we are very excited to welcome Kim back! Joining the Buxton Stonnington team in 2021 as a Senior Property Manager, she enjoys being part of a team and offering support and guidance to her colleagues whenever she can and developing strong office relationships that allow her to deliver a better service to her clients. Kim enjoys helping people on many levels – from helping renters to find the right place to call home, to helping rental providers find the right renter for their property. Genuinely valuing the importance of being organised and always doing her very best every day, she believes that having the right attitude can get you a long way and that listening to people’s needs is equally as important. When Kim is not at work she can be mainly found at the gym. She has competed in many bodybuilding shows at both a national and international level and enjoys being outside, walking, sitting on the beach, baking, going for massages, and just enjoying life in general!
Shai Robinson
Shai Robinson

Property Manager

shair@buxton.com.au
About Shai
From Melbourne, Shai began working in Real Estate in 2017. Her industry experience before joining the Buxton Stonnington team in 2021 was in Reception, Property Management Administration, and Leasing Consultancy. Prior to this, she worked in Retail Management. Initially starting as an Assistant Property Manager, Shai’s ability saw her promoted to a Property Management position after a brief time. Her strengths include her exceptional interpersonal and organisational skills and her honesty and problem-solving ability. Passionate about developing trusting relationships and supporting clients and work colleagues to the best of her ability, she enjoys the variety, challenges and multi-tasking required in her role, and the sense of accomplishment gained from working efficiently and meeting deadlines. Shai’s interests outside of work include spending time with her family and two dogs, long walks while listening to podcasts, going to the gym, and catching up with friends over brunch. A huge Collingwood Football Club supporter, she will be found either at the MCG during the AFL Season or watching at home with her family.

About us

Our Stonnington office opened on Chapel Street Windsor in 2019 to service Melbourne’s immensely popular ‘Southside’. Covering the area’s key neighbourhoods, South Yarra, Prahran and Windsor, Buxton Stonnington’s presence can also be seen in Richmond, Malvern, Armadale, Bentleigh and Melbourne’s inner-west including Footscray, Newport and Ascot Vale.

Our reviews

  4.9  
17 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 6.
over 3 years ago
Good condition

Good condition im happy

Buxton Stonnington

Buxton Stonnington

  5   (75 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Professional, caring and attentive.

Buxton Stonnington is in my opinion a highly regarded Agency who are fantastic with their Communication and Professionalism. They have always been very responsive to any maintenance requests whilst providing updates throughout the process. Buxton Stonnington has been one of the best Real Estate Agents I have rented through and I would highly recommend. It's a breath of fresh air being treated like a human being and not just another number as a Tenant. In particular I would like to thank Bo for her Professionalism and timely communication.

Buxton Stonnington

Buxton Stonnington

  5   (75 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Great Management

My property is well managed with prompt dealing with all matters, be they monthly management, repairs and finding new tenants. A very satisfied landlord

Buxton Stonnington

Buxton Stonnington

  5   (75 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Excellent Service

Always helpful and proactive. In a recent issue with a tenant, the matter was resolved effectively with insurance claim lodged and paid out promptly. Thank you!

Buxton Stonnington

Buxton Stonnington

  5   (75 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Property Rental

Suzette Taylor and the rental team at Buxton Stonnington in Prahran were super quick in finding a suitable tenant for my rental property in Armadale at a very good monthly rent rate. In general, they are very helpful, provide quick assistance to queries, communicate well and seem to have a thorough knowledge of the rental market in the area.

Buxton Stonnington

Buxton Stonnington

  5   (75 reviews)
over 3 years ago
Bo Natoli is Ace

I think Bo Natoli the Property Manager is fantastic ! I’m counting on her for another unit when lm back from NT in Dec or Jan… very accomodating good communication and just great to talk too! There’s a few floors but that’s only because of High turnover of staff but not enough to keep me away👍🏽

Buxton Stonnington

Buxton Stonnington

  5   (75 reviews)
Show all 17 reviews

Our rental properties

Buxton Stonnington has 17 properties for rent and rented 265 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Rent
$550.00/week
3/14 Tivoli Pl
South Yarra VIC 3141
2
1
1
Apartment
Rented
Plant Street
Malvern VIC 3144
2
2
2
Apartment
For Rent
$675.00/week
22/670 Malvern Road
Prahran VIC 3181
2
1
1
Apartment
For Rent
$650.00/week
307/99 River Street
South Yarra VIC 3141
1
1
1
Apartment
Show all 282 properties
Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent