Our profile

Our reviews

  5  
417 reviewsacross 22 different locations, showing 12.
Our qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive, supportive, friendly, reliable, honest, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Always a pleasant experience
about 3 years ago
Always a pleasant experience

Selling our home could have been a scary and daunting task. With Jay and Sandy by our side it was quite the opposite. They were here to navigate us through the process making it stress free and easy. Open communication and answering all questions big or small they supported us all the way.

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
Seller review
Always a pleasant experience
about 3 years ago
Always a pleasant experience

Selling our home could have been a scary and daunting task. With Jay and Sandy by our side it was quite the opposite. They were here to navigate us through the process making it stress free and easy. Open communication and answering all questions big or small they supported us all the way.

Sandy Fairbrother

Sandy Fairbrother

  4.9   (575 reviews)
Seller review
Service that exceeded our expectations
about 3 years ago
Service that exceeded our expectations

Jay's experience and professionalism certainly made selling our home easier. He was approachable and never stopped working to get us the best price possible. When challenges arose Jay went above and beyond what is expected of an agent, to find us a solution and sell our property. I highly recommend Jay and his team to anyone looking to sell or buy.

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
Seller review
Goes above & Beyond
about 3 years ago
Goes above & Beyond

Jay Cleary is hands down the hardest working agent. He has gone above & Beyond to get the sale of our home over the line. I would highly recommend him to sell your home. An absolute proffessional and a great person to help you through the process of selling.Thankyou

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
Seller review
Once again great result
about 3 years ago
Once again great result

I’ve used Jay to buy and sell many houses over the years and once again he has been easy to deal with. He keeps me informed and up to date with what’s happening. I would not hesitate to use Jay again.

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
Buyer review
Sandy was very professional and easy to understand
about 3 years ago
Sandy was very professional and easy to understand

I found Sandy to be very professional from start to finish I would recommend him to Anyone thank you again Sandy

Sandy Fairbrother

Sandy Fairbrother

  4.9   (575 reviews)
Seller review
Sandy has been a hardworking agent from a good local business.
about 3 years ago
Sandy has been a hardworking agent from a good local business.

Sandy presented himself to me in person as he had seen the house getting tidied up from the street months before it was ready to sell. He followed up many times during the reno and was accurate in and honest in his appraisals. The commission offered off the bat was lower than the competition. He explained the positives of working with his businesses as the only two agents showing the house would be himself and Jay. They took time to remember specific features of the house, they knew my street well and were honest about the market conditions and final pricing unlike some bigger chains that were offering a higher price to try and get you to sign with them. I enjoyed seeing the quality of the finished add, all communication was quick without to much fluff. I'm sure they are guilty of working outside hours. The end result was a fair price with a reasonable commission in a timeframe consistent with the market at the time of higher than average interest rates.

Sandy Fairbrother

Sandy Fairbrother

  4.9   (575 reviews)
Buyer review
Friendly and helpful
over 3 years ago
Friendly and helpful

Sandy was very helpful throughout the whole process of buying our home. He took the time to talk to us about the houses we were looking at and suggested other listing's that suited our preferences. We were kept well informed as the sale progressed, a great experience.

Sandy Fairbrother

Sandy Fairbrother

  4.9   (575 reviews)
Seller review
Sale of Property in Bathurst NSW
over 3 years ago
Sale of Property in Bathurst NSW

I used Cleary-Fairbrother Real Estate to sell my fathers house after they had successfully sold a property for me prior. Jays knowledge of the market and ability to put the right buyer in front of the right property is one of the strong points of this agency. I required a quick sale at a fair price and Jay, Sandy and their team delivered. Awesome effort from a switched on Real Estate business.

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
Buyer review
Consummate Professional
over 3 years ago
Consummate Professional

From Day 1, Jay has made the process of purchasing my property hassle-free. Most importantly, he is extremely approachable & friendly & has made himself available on request. Thanks Jay, it's been a pleasure.

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
Seller review
Extremely Professional
over 3 years ago
Extremely Professional

We are extremely happy with all aspects of our dealings with Jay Cleary and also Sandy Fairborough. From our initial meeting (and we also met with 3 other highly rated local agents!) they stood out as being very professional, knowledgeable and honest with their valuation and recommendations. They listened carefully to our concerns/needs and were happy to take these into consideration. We achieved a fantastic sales result through Jay and have no hesitation in recommending him to others. Lastly, we found both Jay and Sandy friendly, down to earth and willing to give the personal time and attention needed to get the right sales result.

Jay Cleary

Jay Cleary

  4.9   (589 reviews)
373 - 384 of 417
Cleary Fairbrother Property
Contact Cleary Fairbrother Property
What information would you like?
© 2026 RateMyAgent