Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
183 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
over 9 years ago
Very happy customers!

Melanie Walden and Josh Sterling took on our property in St Kilda at a difficult time of year (Winter, election time) and got us the results we needed and wanted. Their communication and total professionalism meant that this was way less stressful than we expected it to be. Melanie ran open viewings with tenants in situ with care and consideration. Melanie and Josh's communication was positive, clear and professional throughout - that cheerful positve presence was great for us as sellers and I'm sure it showed in their communication with prospective buyers too. Thanks Melanie and Josh for everything you did - you made selling up at a tricky time of year a breeze!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Professional friendly team delivered a great result

Josh, Melanie and Tracy are a very smooth professional experienced team. The whole sale process was easy, friendly and efficient. I think that buyers respond well to their modern relaxed style and great local knowledge.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 9 years ago
Great people, great results

We bought off Josh many years ago and had a great experience from the buyers side and really wanted that same experience for the prospective buyers when selling our place. Josh, Melanie and Tracy were a pleasure to deal with and made the process of selling our place a hastle free one. Their experience in the area and campaign strategy got us a result we were very happy with and would love to work with them again. Highly recommend.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
Amazing sales team

Josh Stirling, Michael Townsend and McGrath St Kilda team have sold two properties for us in two and a half years, both for exactly the same amount. Go figure. Frankly, I wouldn't consider any one else to do the job. Great work guys. Thank you

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
Mel And Josh are the best agents I've had he pleasure to work with more than once

OK, so here is the scoop, there are agents and then there are agents and then there is the dynamic duo agents - Josh and Mel from McGrath in St Kilda. I had previously used these guys to sell one of my properties 3 years ago. I was extremely impressed with their advise, attitude and general knowledge of the market. We sold that property the day before auction and I was ecstatic with the result. So when I decided to sell off another chunk of my property portfolio I did not hesitate to work with them again. This last property was slightly unusual and it just needed to find the perfect new owner to fall in love with it. With some patience and perseverance Mel and Josh came through again, they sold it for me for my asking price, you can't get much better than that. I highly recommend these guys who don't stop until the job is done and all are happy.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
Unexpectedly surprised!

My husband and I approached a number of agents when we made the decision to sell our apartment in St Kilda. We were impressed with Josh and Melanie's forthrightness and knowledge of the local area. We relied heavily on Josh's advice when doing up the apartment for sale and were pleased with how these works were coordinated by his team. Josh and his team communicated with us regularly throughout the campaign and it was clear that they were working for our best interests. The sale result surparassed our expectations. We could not recommend Josh and his team highly enough.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
st kilda apartment sale

Josh and his team did a very thorough job and I would recommend him

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
Rate Josh Stirling.

All I can say is well done! Josh and his team,Mel & Tracy, really put the work in to achieve a great result for us. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend them. I know I choose THE RIGHT TEAM. well done.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
Josh Stirling - McGrath Real Estate

I recently commissioned Josh to sell my property in St.Kilda. Throughout the campaign I found Josh to be extremely professional from the initial introduction right through until the successful auction of the home. Melanie and Tracy were both punctual and thorough in all my dealings. Opens were done very well and feedback prompt. Josh excelled with his presentation in both the production of the video and auction of the home.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 10 years ago
Five Star Agent

Melanie was great from beginning to end. She did everything she said she would do. I live overseas which meant that I was very dependent on Melanie to keep things moving and to initiate conversations that kept me in touch. Melanie emailed me with updates each week, was proactive in ensuring I had all documentation in place and in the end she achieved a price significantly higher than I had expected and hoped for. I unreservedly recommend Melanie as an honest agent who does what she says she will do. I could not be happier with the result or the process.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
about 10 years ago
Great experience with Josh & Mel

The team worked tirelessly to sell my apartment for me and obtain a price i was happy with. Highly recommend.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
133 - 144 of 183
© 2026 RateMyAgent