Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
183 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
almost 8 years ago
A team that is focussed on delivering successful outcomes for clients

We have now both brought and sold using Josh Stirling and his team at McGraths St Kilda and on each occasion we have experienced great outcomes and they have ensured our journey through these projects was seamless and hassle free. We recently sold an apartment on the beach in Elwood and Josh and Tracy Paus produced a fantastic fresh looking marketing campaign which resulted in a high level of interest and high numbers of people through our opens. We interviewed four local Agents before settling on McGraths and it was the best decision ever to choose Josh and his team. At the auction the property was passed in and with Josh's high level of negotiating skills we achieved our desired outcome and all with 30 minutes of the auction finishing. We highly recommend Team McGrath especially Josh Stirling and Tracy Paus for the sale of your next property.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Super agent

I chose Melanie to sell my apartment because I trusted her advice and had confidence in her. She did a great job in selling my apartment and I felt comfortable with the process and very happy with the outcome. Thanks Melanie

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Trusted help from afar

We engaged Josh and his team based on a sensible and positive initial phone conversation. We needed to sell two properties in Melbourne, whilst we were located in Adelaide and he outlined a good solid sales plan. During the listing period, Josh and his team maintained excellent communication and gave us good peace of mind. The resulting sales price was wonderful and we highly recommend McGrath. Overall, Josh and Tracy's positive attitude, good communication skills and solid advice gave us great comfort from afar.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 8 years ago
Stellar Service

After an initial dealing with Melanie from a Tenant's perspective (we were renting a property she was selling), she was the only choice when it came to selling our own place. Incredibly attentive throughout the entire process, setting realistic expectations and going the extra mile to ensure the best possible result. I cannot recommend her highly enough!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
about 8 years ago
Excellent Team

This is an excellent Real Estate Agency. Josh Stirling together with Tracey Paus sold our apartment at auction after a short campaign. We selected this agency because of their knowledge of the area, their clear interest in helping us through the process together with a real feeling of energy and enthusiasm in the business. At all times they met our expectations. They were extremely impressive with communication which was always detailed, always on time and honest. While we sold on the day, we were confident that we would have been treated in the same impressive manner had the sale taken longer. We cannot recommend them highly enough.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 8 years ago
A fantastic agent, with a fantastic team

We could not rate Josh Stirling and his team from McGrath more highly. Josh was super organised and prepared in all our meetings, putting us at ease and explaining the process and plans for our sales campaign as this was our first time selling in Australia. Communication throughout the sales period was perfect, timely and easy. After each open we received reports and insight from those coming through the property and discussed any changes that we should consider. As the principal agent Josh was fully involved thoughout. Josh's insight of the market and area was great, and his recommendations throughout the process were spot on, and it was great to have such a trusted advisor on our side. Josh's performance on auction day was flawless, giving us a last update before running a great auction, ending in a fantastic result. We would not hesitate in recommending Josh or his team from McGrath as agents.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 8 years ago
Great Agent!

We deliberately targeted Josh based on observing historic local sales activity and local recommendations. Josh and his team were professional, passionate about the local area and conveyed a willingness and capabilty to manage the pre acution trades and house preparation which was an important consdideration for us given a tight turn around. His communication was consistent, pragmatic and accurate during the campaign which informed acution day strategy and he and his team delivered on the day.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 8 years ago
Consumate Professional!

Melanie was referred to us by a trusted adviser and from the very beginning of our engagement, we could see why. She has outstanding market knowledge which was demonstrated to us on a daily basis and her communication was always prompt, professional and informative. Melanie really cares about what she does and we found that so refreshing and reassuring. The result she achieved for us was beyond our expectations and is testament to her relentless hard work. Hands down, we'd recommend her in an instant!! Thank you Melanie.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Professional Agent

Melanie was a breath of fresh air to deal with. Open communication is such a key factor in any auction campaign and Melanie provided a level of service than met our expectations, that provided us with an excellent result on our auction day.

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Melanie Walden and team

Melanie worked hard in selling my place and the knowledge In the area and also working with my tenant and getting the best for my place was great . Communication with Melanie Walden was always friendly and open when it was time for open for inspections to the property and how it went. Melanie Walden and her team worked hard to get the best result for me .

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Good result in challenging circumstances

Ours was not the easiest sale as the market did not match our optimism. But Josh and Tracy worked hard to ensure there was a result that all parties felt comfortable with. My partner and I really appreciated their professionalism, ready communication and willingness to be flexible.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 8 years ago
Just brilliant

Josh sold us our flat 10 years ago and was the only person I would let sell it on. He’s brilliant at his job and very dedicated to getting the best results. Very attentive and switched on.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
97 - 108 of 183
© 2026 RateMyAgent