Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
143 reviewsacross 28 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Dear Toby and team
over 9 years ago
Dear Toby and team

Your advice and guidance during our preparation of the property for sale greatly assisted us in being able to maximise the property's potential and deliver a product which received a high level of market interest. Your market knowledge during this phase was invaluable. Once the marketing commenced the thoroughness of the efforts by you and your team ensured that the property received maximum exposure as evidenced by the many thousands of web enquiries, the over 100 personal inspections made, dozens of contracts issued and the fantastic turn out on auction day. The success of the campaign was reflected by the sale price achieved being roughly 20% above the level we originally anticipated. Lynda and I would not hesitate to recommend you to any prospective sellers in the area

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Karen Joseph
over 9 years ago
Karen Joseph

Karen Joseph had been managing my investment property in Manly so when it was time to sell I couldn't have chosen a better agent. Her strategy was well thought out and consistent, and as a result I achieved way above expectation result for the sale. THANK YOU

Karen Joseph

Karen Joseph

  4.7   (13 reviews)
Seller review
Great result
over 9 years ago
Great result

Mark was a great communicator he kept us informed of everything every step of the way. We got a great result thanks to his tireless efforts. Would highly recommend!

Mark Madsen

Mark Madsen

  4.9   (26 reviews)
Seller review
An agent you can trust
over 9 years ago
An agent you can trust

After talking to many agents in the Northern Beaches, we decided to go with Toby despite him not usually selling properties in our area. From the get go, he impressed with great presentation skills and provided honest advice and feedback on our property and the likely price. He didn't over promise, but listened to our goals in terms of what we were after. Once appointed, Toby and his team hit the ground running and we had a first inspection the following weekend. Toby was there for every inspection arriving early to set up and be ready. From there he conducted many out of hours inspections for potential buyers (even on a Sunday) and was constantly in touch with progress. Toby has a cool head and alot of experience in negotiation, and skilfully worked with multiple potential purchasers to get the property sold prior to auction within 11 days of listing for an amount that was way over our target. The whole process would not have been smoother or better handled and we were just thrilled with the price we achieved. I would highly recommend Toby and his team, to sell your property be it in Manly or anywhere in the Northern Beaches.

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Exaclty what you're looking for in an agent
over 9 years ago
Exaclty what you're looking for in an agent

My husband and I have been involved with the sale and purchase of several properties over the years and have come to experience the good and the bad of the process as a whole. This time around, we were fortunate to have had Toby running the show and we can honestly say it was all good. He was personable, friendly, and communicated very well with us throughout the process. He went above and beyond what we'd come to expect from an agent and, although we hope we won't be selling again any time soon, if we do, contacting Toby will be the first thing we do as his results were exceptional.

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Mark is highly recommended
over 9 years ago
Mark is highly recommended

Mark is very knowledgeable, attentive and wise. He gave frequent updates and advice that proved to be very sound. We were very pleased with the outcome.

Mark Madsen

Mark Madsen

  4.9   (26 reviews)
Seller review
Number 1 Agent in Sydney!
over 9 years ago
Number 1 Agent in Sydney!

I recently engaged Toby to sell my Manly apartment and am absolutely ecstatic with the result he achieved within days of the property going on the market. From the get go Toby’s advice regarding renovating and updating the apartment was spot on – he even assisted in dealing with Tradespeople and organised professional styling quotes on my behalf. Toby’s sound market knowledge and extensive experience meant every aspect of the sale was handled professionally and the marketing was to the highest standard with the Realestate.com.au listing and Manly Daily advertisement attracting over 50 people on the first weekend! Three agents attended each of the open inspections meaning all buyers were serviced and my property was given the attention it deserved. I was kept informed at every step and trusted Toby’s guidance implicitly. Was I happy with the result? –YES - far beyond my expectations, I feel like I won the lotto! Thank you to Toby and his team, you won’t find and agency more hardworking and committed to exceeding the vendor’s dreams!

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Buyer review
Josephine Macri Review of Toby Hutton
almost 10 years ago
Josephine Macri Review of Toby Hutton

From the second I met Toby I felt totally at ease and confident I was getting all the right information with no hidden agenda. Honest, to the point and always contactable (not something you expect from a Real Estate Agent) Toby was more than happy to answer any questions or concerns I had, no matter how small, even on his day off, to make my journey easy and stress free. Toby's experience in the industry is a bonus, the manner at which he treats his clients is why I'm writing this review. Professional and personable. Great combo. Thank you. Couldn't be happier. Josephine

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Buyer review
Good communication
almost 10 years ago
Good communication

Amiable, communicative, professional

Mark Madsen

Mark Madsen

  4.9   (26 reviews)
Buyer review
HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS AGENT
almost 10 years ago
HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS AGENT

It was a pleasure dealing with Toby. He has helped to restore our faith in human nature! It was a valuable lesson that has impacted on us and our adult children. We also really appreciated the open, honest and transparent way in which the sale was conducted.

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Great result!
almost 10 years ago
Great result!

I was extremely happy with my result and would highly recommend Toby and his team. Toby was very upfront and direct about what to expect on price, he well and truely delivered on this!! His excellent knowledge of the local market, commitment and negotiation skills were evident during the campaign and very much appreciated.

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
Seller review
Good result with a unique property
almost 10 years ago
Good result with a unique property

Hi, I had a unique property in Manly for sale which was complicated the level of interest, asking price and negotiations. Toby was spot on with his market assessment, strategy and expected price 'quote'. His communication, professionalism and 24/7 attention was first class, as was that of his assistant Stephanie. R&H Manly have managed my property (Marlena) for seven years and then did the sale. All in all, I am a happy customer and highly recommend them. Their hard work and honesty was greatly appreciated.

Toby Hutton

Toby Hutton

  5   (110 reviews)
109 - 120 of 143
© 2026 RateMyAgent