
From 2093 reviews overall



Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
9 Sparke Street Georgetown
The team at Robinson property were fantastic in helping establish a new investment property as a rental. They were professional, efficient and minimized any down time. The first open home was organised the day after settlement and suitable tenants were promptly found. We would be more than happy to recommend the team at Robinson property.
City Top 5
ratemyagent award
Newcastle - Maitland2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
Australia2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Merewether2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Newcastle2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Newcastle West2026
From 208 reviews overall
Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
93 Marks Point Rd Marks Point
This our second time using Nisha, we were so impressed last time we wouldn't go anywhere else. We rang her last week about leasing our investment property out and unbelievable she has it leased in 1 week, for the price we asked, now that efficient! We love her efforts & care, we know we are in good hands with our investment.
State Top 10
ratemyagent award
New South Wales2026City Winner
ratemyagent award
Newcastle - Maitland2026National Top 100
ratemyagent award
Australia2026Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
1/39A Beaumont Street Hamilton
Green Street Property has managed our property for several years, and we’ve consistently appreciated the professionalism and support provided by the team. Hannah, our property manager, is proactive, practical, and always offers reliable advice whenever issues arise. We recently went through a tenant changeover and were particularly impressed by how well the team — especially Hannah — communicated with us throughout the entire process, keeping us informed every step of the way.

From 91 reviews overall


Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
7a Fanning Street Gillieston Heights
After having some less than average experiences with agents out of state, when our rental property in Gillieston Heights came up for rent we interviewed so many agents in the area to make sure we were in good hands. BOY did we make a great choice. Nicole and her team at Valley Estate Agents are hands on, proactive and true gatekeepers of our properties. From fast communication to high quality tenants, detail oriented tech based inspections and reporting, as well as the friendly, accountable and accessible team at the ready. I'm thoroughly impressed with the quality, morals and standards of VEA. They are avocators for both tenant and landlord (which is so important), full of up to date knowledge and take the stress out of property investing. Things always pop up with property management, but I feel good knowing that when they have, I know about it quickly with an offer of help and its not swept under a rug which keeps all parties happy. I've put so many people onto them already and wouldn't hesitate to recommend anyone else who needs a professional on their investment team. Many thanks!
1/28 Baluster Street Raymond Terrace
My experience with Eastern Valley Real Estate has been terrific, as they have successfully managed and rented two of my properties while I am living overseas. They maintained excellent communication throughout the process, keeping me fully informed of all viewings and applicant progress. The team expertly managed the open days and handled the entire transition for new tenants, including representing my interests by attending the handover process with the builder. Their proactive approach and professional advocacy have provided complete peace of mind, making the management of my international assets simple and stress-free.
19 Kite St Aberglasslyn
We chose to work with Valley Estate Agents as our property managers and it's been a great experience. Nicole Ansell is incredibly personable whilst still maintaining prompt and professional communication, efficient property organisation, and is results driven whilst still being considerate and empathetic to renters.
City Top 5
ratemyagent award
Newcastle - Maitland2026Suburb Winner
ratemyagent award
Farley2026Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
37 Lees Street Charlestown
Arnold property was really supportive in seeking consult from the owner when we requested. We had issues with dead possums and electricity faults and they promptly organised their repair/removals. We have nothing bad specifically to say, but the service just felt a lacking in experience and personality. The notice to vacate felt very harsh and unsympathetic, to the point and by the book in a very tough time for us. Particularly when we were genuinely great tenants who left the place in better condition than when we found it.
6/283 Pacific Highway Charlestown
Arnold property have followed up on: 1) a visit to the property 2) issues concerning the roof, and interior ceiling. 3) when required communicating to Raine and Horne as Strata managers.
Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
45/292 Park Ave Kotara
We all sometimes want change. But that come with attachments. Idea's and a working relationship. Yes that's the one statement. (Working relationship) Being a landlord with Creere property since 1999 yes OMG .Thanks Creer . Say no move .A working relationship. That is what being a landlord is really all about .Greece thank you .looking forward to the next 20 yrs and beyond.
20 Richards Road Swansea
Emily has done a brilliant job of keeping me informed on the progress throughout from advertising to house inspections. Her professionalism is outstanding. I am a first time landlord. It was overwhelming & Emily helped me through it with ease.

From 43 reviews overall

Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
2/21 Royston Circuit Farley
The team at Ellejayne are responsive to my property and tenant update requests. Their tenant selection process is comprehensive, providing for quality tenants that care for my property. I’ve received great tips regarding insurance and maintenance. I highly recommend them.
1/40 Camelia Street Gillieston Heights
I want to offer my sincere and heartfelt recognition to Caitlin Shipton from ellejayne, whose professionalism and dedication have transformed my experience as a property investor. Over the past 18 months, Caitlin has managed my investment with exceptional care, intelligence, and initiative. From seamless onboarding and securing outstanding tenants, to proactively resolving issues before they escalate, her approach has been nothing short of exemplary. She navigates warranty matters with builders, vets applicants with remarkable insight, and manages every detail with precision and confidence. What truly sets Caitlin apart is her ability to deliver peace of mind. I hoped for an investment I could confidently set up and forget, and through her diligence, expertise, and commitment, that vision has become a reality. I would highly recommend Caitlin to anyone seeking a skilled, professional, and proactive property manager. Her standard of work reflects genuine excellence, and I am deeply grateful for everything she has done. Thank you Caitlin.
14 Clayton Cres Rutherford
I recently rented out my first property and had the pleasure of working with Ellejayne and my property manager Caitlin. From the very beginning, their professionalism, attention to detail, and clear communication made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Caitlin, was especially wonderful, she took the time to understand my needs and ensured that everything was handled promptly and efficiently. The entire team went above and beyond to secure reliable tenants and provide expert advice throughout the rental process. I couldn’t be happier with the service I received, and I highly recommend Ellejayne and Caitlin to anyone looking to rent their property. Thank you Caitlin and the Ellejayne team for making this such a positive experience!
City Winner
ratemyagent award
Morisset - Cooranbong2026Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent
333 Glebe Road Merewether
Our experience thus far with Shiels and co is flawless. Personalised treatment and lots of market knowledge!!! Kylie has been the best property manager we have ever had after years of renting our property. Her communication and management of tenancy has made the rental process easier then it has ever been!! Thankyou
Reviews in Newcastle - Maitland
Rented
For Rent