Our profile

Our reviews

  4.8  
59 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
over 7 years ago
High energy and natural charm secured a win-win

We met Matt a couple of years ago when we were looking at a property to purchase in the Allambie area. Although we didn’t buy then, Matt remained engaged and when recently we found a house we loved, I reached out to Matt to get his insights. He ended up acting on our behalf as a buyers agent and secured our forever home for us. When it came to selling it was an easy decision to chose Matt as our agent with his energy and natural charm and market knowledge. We couldn’t be happier with the result.

Matt Nicastri

Matt Nicastri

  4.7   (75 reviews)
over 7 years ago
A Good Captain in Turbulent Times

We chose Matthew (and Simon Carroll) after some consideration and looking at seven different agencies (three of them in detail). Reviewing other sales at the time and reflecting on our outcome, we still would have chosen them despite originally wanting a higher price for our house. There were a few surprises along the way but Matthew and Simon managed to navigate around them, As an example, Simon took some clutter to the tip for us two days before settlement because we apparently misunderstood the purchaser was happy for it to stay. Matthew was good at adjusting their sales strategy along the way for a good outcome.

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Great service

Thank you Matt for your help during the sale. I liked the way Matt followed up every step of the way and continues to do so while we are in the process of settlement. Matt has responded to all my queries in the process of sale and settlement and has always got back to me in a timely and efficient manner Many thanks and a pleasure to deal with Regards Sonny Martis

Matt Nicastri

Matt Nicastri

  4.7   (75 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Would Highly Recommend!

Having bought and sold property before and being very underwhelmed with real estate agents in the past, we have nothing but great things to say about Matt and would highly recommend him as a real estate agent. An experienced agent and excellent salesman - enthusiastic, knowledgeable, trustworthy and affable. He somehow managed to effortlessly walk that fine line of balancing both the sellers and buyers expectations and wishes, which resulted in a quick and easy purchase. He will be the first agent we call if buying or selling in the future. Many thanks Matt!

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
over 7 years ago
Great Agent!

Matt was fantastic throughout the whole period when we were looking to purchase our house. Always contactable, always touching base to see if there was anything he could do and transparent throughout the whole process. Cant speak highly enough of Matt, whether purchasing or selling your property.

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Truly Professional

Deciding on a Real Estate Agent is an extremely difficult decision, however, once we had made the decision to go with Matt from Cunninghams we never looked back. Matt has an upbeat and positive attitude with excellent communication skills. We would not hesitate to recommend him to our family and friends.

Matt Nicastri

Matt Nicastri

  4.7   (75 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Seamless Process

Mathew did a great job selling my home a few years back, so when this property became available I was thrilled Matt was the agent, he was so accommodating with inspection times and questions and the whole sale just went so smoothly. I’m now in my new home and just love it. I couldn’t recommend Matt high enough. Thank you. Elisa King 😊

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Stellar Agent

Matt has been such an asset while preparing our place for sale; extremely knowledgeable and approachable, Matt brings a relaxed and professional approach to his work. Matt was able to guide us to present our place as not only somewhere we loved to live, but somewhere a new family could build their home also.

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Vendor's Agent

It's not often you write a positive review about the Vendor's agent but I found Matt extremely professional to deal with throughout the purchase process and he was extremely responsive to my queries/requests. Highly recommended.

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
Brilliant agent!

Matthew Lemon was such a delight to work with, he made the process of selling our home stress free and effortless. His wealth of experience and pleasant demeanour instilled confidence from negotiation to settlement. Thank you Matt

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
A really positive experience

My partner and I had a really positive experience with Matthew. Matthew is an excellent communicator, always keeping us in the loop during the negotiation process. He was reasonable and his experience in the industry was really evident in our interactions with him.

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
almost 8 years ago
I would recommend Matthew Lemon as an Agent

My Wife and I recently engaged Matt and his team on the sale of our house in Terrey Hills. From the outset, Matt was extremely impressive and from the first meeting we felt the comfort that Matt was a professional and not a salesman, which was important to us. Our one request to Matt was that he be honest through the process. Matt understood that we had purchased elsewhere and the sale to us in a quick and professional manner was important. Matt and his team helped get the house ready for sale and whilst it took a lot of hard work from us to get it ready - which we understood - his team certainly carried some of that load and the house looked great for the sale based on much of their recommendations. Matt and Mark were entirely professional through the process, doing everything that they said they would do. Unfortunately the Market took a turn South at the time that we decided to sell our house and Matt was realistic in his advice around that and we understood that it was a hard time to sell as the Media Reports reminded us each day. And the sales results for Sydney also reflected that it was a bad market to be selling. Through his advertising and promotion of the property, Matt achieved 16 parties through our house two days after the home listed and the frequency and numbers of interested parties following that first inspection were encouraging. Matt also made himself available for unscheduled viewings which was appreciated when we knew we weren't the only people he was selling for. Matt's updates on potential purchasers was great and he managed to sort the people that were legitimate from the people that wouldn't be in a position to buy the property and then create a short-list of people worth negotiating further with. In the end, Matt managed to negotiate with the eventual purchaser to a figure that both the purchaser and my wife and I were comfortable - and within two weeks of the first open home. Thanks Matt, Mark and the Team at Cunninghams

Matthew Lemon

Matthew Lemon

  4.8   (55 reviews)
1 - 12 of 59
© 2026 RateMyAgent