Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
1259 reviewsacross 50 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Very positive experience
almost 7 years ago
Very positive experience

Su Reynolds is an authentic and professional real estate agent. Her sincerity and approachable attitude allowed for a confidant purchase and we could not be happier. I would strongly recommend Su for her experience, astute market knowledge, negotiation skills and affable demeanour.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Buyer review
Agent Review
almost 7 years ago
Agent Review

Having myself been in the real estate industry and bought and sold on numerous occasions it was refreshing to find agents like Tara and her team, professional but understanding, fabulous feedback and never pushy,a pleasure to deal wth Will be recommending Tara and her team without any hesitation to our many friends and acquaintances in the area .

Tara Torkkola

Tara Torkkola

  4.9   (297 reviews)
Buyer review
Simply perfect
almost 7 years ago
Simply perfect

Very easy going, natural and always available. Thanks for making the sale happen.

Helen Huntly-Barratt

Helen Huntly-Barratt

  4.8   (138 reviews)
Seller review
5 Star Professionalism
almost 7 years ago
5 Star Professionalism

Helen took our ideas about the particular unique qualities of our property, an acreage with a high level of biodiversity, and molded them into a package that would attract discerning compatible potential buyers to inspect the place. The ultimate buyer seems the perfect match to continue the 'caretaker' role that's required of a property that is somewhat more than just a house. Excellent work Helen!!

Helen Huntly-Barratt

Helen Huntly-Barratt

  4.8   (138 reviews)
Buyer review
Very professional and great service.
almost 7 years ago
Very professional and great service.

Su was lovely to work with was very open and always contacted us when she said she would. Helped make a very stressful time easier.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Buyer review
Recent purchase
almost 7 years ago
Recent purchase

We have recently had the pleasure I buying a property where Luke was the selling agent. His open and honest approach made the whole process very easy. He was very generous with his time and helped us out with any issues we had or thought we might encounter. Buying a property can be very daunting, we were lucky we dealt with an agent such as Luke ,who really looked after both parties interests. Which is probably what makes the sale Thank you

Luke Elwin

Luke Elwin

  4.8   (87 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, friendly, honest
almost 7 years ago
Professional, friendly, honest

We couldn't recommend Su Reynolds more highly. Su and her team were always available for us from the moment we listed through to the final settlement. Her experience and knowledge in negotiating the best deal for us was evident in us achieving the best possible price for our home.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
You deserve another star
almost 7 years ago
You deserve another star

It gives us great pleasure to recommend Su Reynolds to any prospective sellers or buyers. We have bought-sold-bought & sold with Su over the past few years so are experienced in our recommendation. Su's ability to listen to the needs of both her vendor and purchaser makes buying and selling stress free. She offers practical advice and gives an exemplary personal service that equates to a high success rate. If there was another star on this rating she would easily have earned it ... so Su you get a 6 star rating from us. A sincere thank you for your professionalism and friendship that developed purely from our real estate dealings. Graeme & Julie Dawson

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
Amicable, experienced and professional Principal real estate agent
almost 7 years ago
Amicable, experienced and professional Principal real estate agent

Having bought my Byron Bay property through the same agency back in 2005, I had Principal Su Reynolds sell my property in 2019. Even when it was off-market, she was able to get a serious interested buyer from her database which was tempting to accept, but she never pressured me into accepting the offer. In the end, I put the property officially on the market, and was rewarded with a higher offer. As this was a holiday rental house and I was living in Sydney, virtually all communication was either via early morning phone-calls or via email. Su was very prompt in terms of getting everything in action, and was particularly good in terms of answering inquiries and keeping me informed. Multiple requests for various matters were promptly attended to. She is obviously very experienced, knows the ins and outs, and will look after the vendor's interests at all times. She is very pleasant to deal with personally. She comes highly recommended, and I would not hesitate to have my return business should such an opportunity arise in the future.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Buyer review
Great service and support, again
almost 7 years ago
Great service and support, again

Thank you Su, we appreciate the work and continual communication.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
Professional, Available, Honest
almost 7 years ago
Professional, Available, Honest

Su was excellent with her advice and property knowledge. I felt very confident with her in charge of my property

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
Seller review
Always a STAR
almost 7 years ago
Always a STAR

My husband and I have known and worked with Su for many years. I don't even hesitate to contact her when we are selling and buying as I know the service will be excellent, she is honest in her approach and always kind and friendly. Over the last 15 years we have purchased 3 houses and sold 2 homes. I cannot recommend Su highly enough. Not just a real estate agent but a friend.

Su Reynolds

Su Reynolds

  4.9   (371 reviews)
673 - 684 of 1,259
© 2026 RateMyAgent