Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
990 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Buyer review
Professional courteous and obliging
over 5 years ago
Professional courteous and obliging

I found Tim an absolute delight to deal with. He was informative and helpful, returned calls promptly when unable to pick up. He made the sometimes daunting experience of purchasing easy Many thanks Tim

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Excellent experience!
over 5 years ago
Excellent experience!

Tim and his team were fabulous. His honesty, knowledge of the market, efficiency and the professionalism of the entire team is expceptional. Highly recommend, Torquays #1 agency.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Professional and great agaent
over 5 years ago
Professional and great agaent

Tim was always informative throughout the whole process and has a great approach to us as the vendors

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Professionalism with the common touch
over 5 years ago
Professionalism with the common touch

I have had dealings with Tim and McCartney's for the last ten years, I have found them to be professional, friendly and honest to deal with. I recently sold my property and was pleasantly surprised at the result. Whether renting, selling or buying I am confident they are competent, trustworthy and respect both parties in the relationship.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
MVP of Real Estate
over 5 years ago
MVP of Real Estate

I've dealt with many real estate agents around the world and Tim is the best by a country mile. My process was conducted remotely from the UK during a pandemic, so it was far from optimal for all parties. From inception, it was clear my process was going to go well. Tim's market knowledge was concisely described in a professional document for my review, which was comprehensive and supported his opinion on the value and time to sell my house. This calibrated my expectations and displayed a level of transparency that was truly refreshing. The actual sales process was handled swiftly and professionally. Considered advice was provided regarding remedial work to maximize interest and sales level. Tim organized all of this seamlessly and my property looked the best it had in many years. At this stage, we were just so relieved to have such responsiveness and professionalism. The result was nothing short of astounding... Tim sold our property in one day at a level that comfortably exceeded the top of our range! The performance of Tim and his team at McCartney's really was "tour de force" given Co-Vid overlay. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Tim to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. What you see really is what you get and for us, that was tantamount to Tim ripping the ring off the backboard!

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Transparent and personable
over 5 years ago
Transparent and personable

Tim is a friendly, country guy that we warmed to straight away. We had never sold a house before, so we were very overwhelmed. But Tim kept us ‘in the loop’ during the whole experience. He gave us total reassurance. He went above and beyond for us, which was apparent in our amazing sale price. I would recommend Tim to anyone on the surf coast looking for an honest, hard working realtor.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Exceptional and Professional Service from Tim.
over 5 years ago
Exceptional and Professional Service from Tim.

I Mick would rate my experience with Tim as professional as one can be. Very happy with the service I have been given. Kept me informed all the way. Look forward hopefully doing more business with Tim.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Highly Recommend
over 5 years ago
Highly Recommend

After dealing with a few agents in the hunt for our first home Kirsty was a welcome relief. Kirsty kept us updated throughout the entire process and made it as easy as can be!

Kirsty Pertzel

Kirsty Pertzel

  5   (87 reviews)
Seller review
Ultimate professional
over 5 years ago
Ultimate professional

Mr Bennett was the number one choice in selling my home . His knowledge of the area and his three decades in the realestate business stood out . Mr Bennett’s rapport was exemplary. Always available to update on the sale .He was a genuine friendly Had a calm and reassuring manner that made me feel informed and settled during the sale . I would recommend him to anyone want to sell or buy a piece of realestate in the Surf coast area. I thoroughly endorse this realestate agent . Mr Bennet is a gentleman who I hold in high regard .

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Buyer review
Transparent, fair and responsive
over 5 years ago
Transparent, fair and responsive

Tim was transparent, fair and really responsive throughout the whole process of buying a house with him. He was excellent to work with and we'd recommend him to anyone.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Winchelsea Home
over 5 years ago
Winchelsea Home

Geoff has done an excellent job in selling our Winchelsea home, his knowledge of the local market and trends was second to none. At all times he was professional in his approach, his advice was both helpful and understanding of our needs. We wouldn’t hesitate in recommending and using Geoff’s services again in the future.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Unrivalled service and professionalism
over 5 years ago
Unrivalled service and professionalism

Our relationship with Tim began long before it came to list our property. Without hesitation, he has always made himself available to answer any questions and to support us, originally as purchasers and more recently as vendors. Tim is, without doubt, the most dedicated and passionate agent we have worked with to buy or sell a home. When selling, he ensured we were updated at every step of the way and on every single enquiry on our property. Tim tirelessly advocated for us and we always felt incredibly respected. His expertise and advice are exceptional and his manner is outstanding. We couldn’t recommend Tim more highly!

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
481 - 492 of 990
© 2026 RateMyAgent