Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
982 reviewsacross 23 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Ultimate professional
over 5 years ago
Ultimate professional

Mr Bennett was the number one choice in selling my home . His knowledge of the area and his three decades in the realestate business stood out . Mr Bennett’s rapport was exemplary. Always available to update on the sale .He was a genuine friendly Had a calm and reassuring manner that made me feel informed and settled during the sale . I would recommend him to anyone want to sell or buy a piece of realestate in the Surf coast area. I thoroughly endorse this realestate agent . Mr Bennet is a gentleman who I hold in high regard .

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Buyer review
Transparent, fair and responsive
over 5 years ago
Transparent, fair and responsive

Tim was transparent, fair and really responsive throughout the whole process of buying a house with him. He was excellent to work with and we'd recommend him to anyone.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Winchelsea Home
over 5 years ago
Winchelsea Home

Geoff has done an excellent job in selling our Winchelsea home, his knowledge of the local market and trends was second to none. At all times he was professional in his approach, his advice was both helpful and understanding of our needs. We wouldn’t hesitate in recommending and using Geoff’s services again in the future.

Geoff Bennett

Geoff Bennett

  4.9   (180 reviews)
Seller review
Unrivalled service and professionalism
over 5 years ago
Unrivalled service and professionalism

Our relationship with Tim began long before it came to list our property. Without hesitation, he has always made himself available to answer any questions and to support us, originally as purchasers and more recently as vendors. Tim is, without doubt, the most dedicated and passionate agent we have worked with to buy or sell a home. When selling, he ensured we were updated at every step of the way and on every single enquiry on our property. Tim tirelessly advocated for us and we always felt incredibly respected. His expertise and advice are exceptional and his manner is outstanding. We couldn’t recommend Tim more highly!

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
He got things done and everyone is happy.
over 5 years ago
He got things done and everyone is happy.

My interaction with Tim was brief, but I found him to be honest, helpful, prompt and when needed, he got back quickly. Very easy to talk to and he got things done.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Buyer review
Professional, friendly and very helpful
over 5 years ago
Professional, friendly and very helpful

Kirsty was very professional, friendly and helpful - at the open house sales she was informative but not pushy and had a good knowledge of the individual houses. If she could not answer a question she was prepared to follow-up with the owners. However, we purchased a block of land she had advised us of. In addition, the young ladies at the front desk (POC) were also friendly and helpful - in particular, Jess. I feel Kirsty and the POC Team are an asset to McCartney Real Estate, Torquay business practice.

Kirsty Pertzel

Kirsty Pertzel

  5   (87 reviews)
Buyer review
First home buyer
over 5 years ago
First home buyer

Kirsty was very professional and approachable in all dealings of the purchasing process. As a first home buyer it was a very daunting process - dealing with Kirsty made it very much an enjoyable and exciting experience and I thank her for all she did for me.

Kirsty Pertzel

Kirsty Pertzel

  5   (87 reviews)
Seller review
My experience with Tim was open and honest.
over 5 years ago
My experience with Tim was open and honest.

Timing is everything and Tim certainly new when to put the house on the market. His wealth of experience and knowledge of the demand for property in the area at the time was what enabled us to achieve a result above our expectation. Tim advised on maintenance and presentation works for the property to achieve the quick sale we required. With Tims client data base the property was sold after one opening an amazing result for us. Tims open and honest approach with us is what made everything about the sale an easy process. Thanks Tim and Mcartney relestate we couldnt be happier.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Outstanding
over 5 years ago
Outstanding

Great service as usual from Tim and the whole team at McCartneys. Down to earth agents and staff, who actually listen to their customers.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Great Agent
over 5 years ago
Great Agent

Kirsty was really easy to work with. She was in constant contact with us to let us know how the sale of our property was progressing. Which I found was very helpful as we had never sold a property before. Our Unit was only on the market for approximately 8 weeks before it sold. Thanks Kirsty.

Kirsty Pertzel

Kirsty Pertzel

  5   (87 reviews)
Seller review
Professional & Knowledgeable
over 5 years ago
Professional & Knowledgeable

Tim was a pleasure to deal with. His professionalism and knowledge about the market is fantastic. He followed up every week and kept me up to date with all aspects of the sale of my property. I would recommend Tim highly.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
Seller review
Buying and Selling
over 5 years ago
Buying and Selling

Tim is an excellent real estate agent. Tim took the time to understand our families needs and helped us to find the property we’d been searching for. Tim was able to provide a realistic valuation and timeframe for the sale of our existing property. I would highly recommend Tim and the McCartney team.

Tim Carson

Tim Carson

  4.9   (699 reviews)
481 - 492 of 982
© 2026 RateMyAgent