Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
183 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
about 11 years ago
Delivered to his promise

Josh delivered what he promised. His level of professionalism and communication was just what I was just what I was looking for in an agent. Thanks for the great outcome.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 11 years ago
Melanie is my agent!

The deal simply wouldn't have happened without Melanie's persistence. I was sitting on the fence about selling, and Melanie took it upon herself to bring the buyers to me. Still not convinced, I waited and let her do her job. Gradually, she worked potential buyers up to a price that I was very happy with, and we got there. There was such little pain and effort, and Melanie is a star!

Melanie Walden

Melanie Walden

  4.9   (77 reviews)
about 11 years ago
Thank you Josh

Hey Josh, a big thank you out to you and Melanie. You are both a great to team. Over the 5 weeks, Melanie kept me up to date through the whole process and a very personable. Josh on the day of auction, you made feel very relaxed and confident that we were going to sell. Your introduction to the property was so good that I thought (for brief moment) why am I selling! My mate Philip who was with me on the day, also thought you did a great job from start to finish. Thank you once again. Darryl

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 11 years ago
'POSITIVE PROFESSIONAL COMMUNICATE!

My apartment attracted a very small market for a higher end 1 bedroom therefore needed extra effort to show the added facilities of the block. Josh was my 3rd agent and unlike the others at no time did I feel Josh would not get this property sold for a workable price, he was always very positive and gave me very honest feedback without the old excuses, 'the body corp fees are to high' 'there are too many stairs' etc all the old habits of an agent! He would simply say it wasn't for them. His many years of experience showed when it was really needed. I will just finish with while other sales agents intimate "they will look after your property" they will be at all open for inspection and then send someone else" Josh is actually there at every open to make sure he has first hand knowledge and uses his extensive years of experience to first hand sell your property. I would highly recommend this genuinely honest agent.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 11 years ago
46 Brunning Street

Josh Stirling has been working in the area of Balaclava for quite some time and my wife and I have seen many successful results. Josh and his colleague Melanie were invited to take care of our property because we wanted a team that were knew the area, were people that we felt we could work with to get the best result possible. Throughout the campaign Josh made every effort to keep in contact and work relentlessly on every interested party. In the end we were incredibly happy with the result and felt that Josh and Melanie did everything to get the best result. We would certainly use Josh and his team again.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 11 years ago
Professional and Trustworthy

We opted to sell with Josh and Melanie at Hodges St Kilda partly due to their strong track record of success in the local market, but also because as interstate sellers it was really important for us to work with people that we could trust without our being involved in every step. Throughout the campaign they were extremely vigilant in keeping us informed of every development and as first time sellers they took the time to ensure that we understand all the ins and outs. We found the Hodges St Kilda sales department to be wholly professional and I would have absolutely no reservations in recommending them to anyone looking to sell in the area.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
about 11 years ago
Excellent service and an excellent result

Josh and Melanie Walden did an excellent job in marketing and selling our property. They were professional, kept us fully informed at all stages and gave good advice on presentation and marketability. The auction was very well conducted, achieved a great result, and was backed up by an effective marketing campaign and getting good numbers for the open inspections.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 11 years ago
the best result possible in the market

We have now seen the reports in the Age and the outcome not only of our auction, but others on the day. I think it is fair to say that we achieved about the best result possible in the market. • We had an almost perfect campaign • We listened and reacted timely and appropriately to the feedback • You set the right price range (!) • We worked together well As a result we had the necessary number of interested parties at the auction to move the bidding along. We had the reserve at just the right point, so there was a second wind to carry it to the final price. You guys should be chuffed with where we got to, I certainly am. I like to congratulate you on your professional approach and the fantastic backup by the rest of your team. A well-deserved ‘thank you’ from me and the rest of my family.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Best agent and auctioneer!

It has been a pleasure dealing with Josh Stirling and his team. We did a lot of research before choosing our real estate agent and chose Josh because he was personable, professional, had proven success in the area and is by far the best auctioneer in our area. The entire process - from putting our house on the market to selling was made as stress free as possible. I recommend using Josh and his team highly.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Consummate professional

Market knowledge, attention to detail, good listener, charismatic, confident presenter, good finisher. Works hard for your business and takes nothing for granted. Three cheers for Josh Stirling and the whole team at Hodges St Kilda. A great effort and another happy customer.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Highly recommended

We highly recommend Josh Stirling and the team at Hodges in Carlisle Street. Josh, Mel and their support team were professional, driven to achieve a good result and always a pleasure to deal, thank you!

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
over 11 years ago
Professional service

I have no hesitation in recommending Josh. Our experience with Josh and his team was professional and reassuring in what can be a stressful time.

Josh Stirling

Josh Stirling

  4.9   (106 reviews)
169 - 180 of 183
© 2026 RateMyAgent