Our profile

Our reviews

  4.9  
502 reviewsacross 24 different locations, showing 12.
over 10 years ago
A most satisfying experience.

I have a lot of respect for Noel Susay because he is a very efficient, well spoken, sensitive and respectful person. I found him to be punctual at all our meetings, very well prepared and advised about information given to me. He executed the sale of my house and all related matters professionally and to the very best of his ability. He fulfilled all the duties that he undertook with ease and grace. I will recommend him to anyone.

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Fantastic Agent

Paul was a fantastic agent and made the entire process of selling my house quick and easy. He made sure he got me the best offer on the market and also in under two weeks!

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Sale of Tulip Grove

I was very happy with everything Paul Sibley did during the sale. He was genuinely happy for me & helped me right through to my actual move. Thanks Paul.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Paul Sibley - "What a cracker"

Paul is very relaxed and easy going! We found Paul to be honest and reliable, very good with communication & fast responses! Vote 1 - Paul Sibley Thanks Paul

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
2 WAY DEALING

I had the pleasure of buying and selling through Buxton with Noel Susay being the lead contact in the process. I found Noel to be particularly diligent, professional, knowledgeable and extremely quick to respond to any query or concern I had in respect to the processes I was dealing with. My overall experience with Noel Susay and Buxton was an enjoyable one and would not hesitate to recommend Noel Susay in the future. Maureen Wilson.

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Paul Sibley.

As first timers in selling real estate we found Paul to be exceptionally professional and down to earth. His manner was reassuring, and he was able to answer all questions. We would like to thank him for a positive outcome for the sale of our property.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Great work

Easy to work with. straight and direct!

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Paul Sibley

Apart from being a good estate agent Paul was an exceptional individual who became part of our family who always listened and never pushed us to do anything we didn't want to do as a result of this he helped us get a good price for our property and still keeps in touch we highly recommend Paul

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
A very happy Buyer

I was very impressed with Paul's professionalism.He is very knowledgeable,friendly and courteous. He was efficient and really worked hard to get me the property. I would highly recommend him to any prospective sellers or buyers looking for real estate.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Smile From Ear To Ear

Noel Susay is very well know in the bayside area for his professionalism and astute marketing techniques. I was at no stage ever disappointed with his service, he goes well above and beyond what a standard agent would, i was extremely well informed with all facets of the campaign knowing precisely where i realistically stood. I very highly recommend Noel Susay and his team!

Noel Susay

Noel Susay

  4.8   (138 reviews)
over 10 years ago
34 Marchant Street, Highett

Would absolutely use Paul again. The sale of our property went without a hitch due to Paul and his team and was a lot less stressful than it could have been!! His market knowledge and his ability to note the "smokies" in the potential buyers is amazing!

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
over 10 years ago
Fantastic Agent - don't look further

We feel very fortunate to have had Paul Sibley as our managing agent. His easy going attitude, attention to detail and professionalism shined through the whole campaign. Thanks to Paul we sold before Auction, and we were very pleased with the result. Trust is very important when selecting your agent, and I don't think you could find someone better than Paul to look after you.

Paul Sibley

Paul Sibley

  4.9   (313 reviews)
469 - 480 of 502
© 2026 RateMyAgent